Police lawsuit could cost county taxpayers
by Kim Isaza
newseditor@mdjonline.com
August 27, 2010 12:00 AM | 3033 views | 30 30 comments | 16 16 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA - Although the county wasn't named as a party to the federal civil-rights suit filed this week against two Cobb police officers, taxpayers are still likely to foot the bill - and it could be a hefty one. The county's Internal Affairs department is also now investigating the incident.

On Monday, lawyers at the Southern Poverty Law Center, based in Montgomery, Ala., filed suit on behalf of Angel Francisco Castro-Torres against Jeremiah Lignitz and Brian J. Walraven. The suit alleges that Lignitz and Walraven, who are both Cobb police officers, stopped Castro-Torres without cause on March 26 - violating his Fourth Amendment right against unreasonable search and seizure - beat him, arrested him and took him to Cobb County Jail, where he would end up in immigration custody.

In his report made at the time of the arrest, Walraven wrote that Castro-Torres was wearing gang attire, and that "the Hispanic male failed to yield and entered the crosswalk with his bicycle and almost struck our patrol car." That report also notes that the man repeatedly refused to give his date of birth, tried to break away and attempted to grab Lignitz's Taser.

Lignitz's report notes: "I struck the male with my forearm in the face to make him release his grip on my Taser."

While still in custody at the Cobb Jail on misdemeanor charges of obstruction, Castro-Torres underwent surgery at Northwest Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery on April 8 to repair his left eye socket and his nose. The Cobb's Sheriff's Office paid the $2,600 surgery bill, sheriff's Col. Don Bartlett said.

The civil-rights suit filed Monday in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia specifies that Lignitz and Walraven are being sued only "in their individual capacities," and they are the only defendants named in the suit, which seeks unspecified damages.

"Violating an innocent man's civil rights carries no price tag," said Sam Brooke, one of the lawyers at the SPLC who filed the suit. "The 287(g) program does not work and needs to end. In the meantime, every member of law enforcement who operates within an area where these type of programs are in place need to know they can not violate someone's civil rights."

As of late Thursday, a check of the federal courts' online filing system indicated the officers had not yet been served with the suit. They have 20 days from the day they are served to file a response.

After the suit was announced, Cobb Police Chief John Houser requested an Internal Affairs investigation of the officers and the arrest, county spokesman Robert Quigley said.

Lance LoRusso, a lawyer who represents the state Fraternal Order of Police as well as the local lodge in Cobb County, said the defense of such civil-rights cases is "extremely expensive."

"Whether these officers are cleared, the way this was drafted was intended to create a financial burden on these officers to defend the case," LoRusso said. "They're trying to make these officers pay a tremendous amount of money. And if there's a judgment against them, it likely would be paid by Cobb County, because they're acting as employees."

Any such judgment could also include the plaintiff's legal bills, which LoRusso said could easily be at least $100,000.

Because the two officers were on duty at the time of the alleged incident, the county expects to provide lawyers for them, the county's spokesman said.

"It is our intent in this case to provide legal representation to the officers," spokesman Robert Quigley said.

Brooke, of the SPLC, said his group - and the other five lawyers representing Castro-Torres - are not seeking damages directly from the county or the police department.

"(Castro-Torres) is seeking to recover damages from these two individuals. On paper and what will be told to jury is that these two are the ones who any damage amount would come from," Brooke said. "It's these two officers who violated his Constitutional rights. They had the discretion, the opportunity to either pull him over without cause and assault him, or not. And it's for that violation that they are being sued."

Lignitz has been with Cobb Police just over three years, and Walraven has been an officer for nearly 10 years, a police spokesman said.

The advocacy group claims in the suit that the two officers stopped Castro-Torres about 4:30 p.m. on March 26, as he was riding a bicycle near the intersection of South Cobb Drive and Old Concord Road. He spoke little English, the suit notes, but the officers continued to question him about his immigration status and did not seek an interpreter.

"The defendants stopped and arrested Mr. Casto because of his Latino race and ethnicity, from which they inferred that he was a noncitizen," the suit states.

The officers did not appear in Cobb State Court to testify in the obstruction case against Castro-Torres - even after Judge Toby Prodgers issued subpoenas for them to do so - and on Aug. 10 the case was dismissed, both the suit and State Court records indicate.

At Tuesday's county commissioners' meeting, anti-illegal immigration activist D.A. King called on the commissioners "to publicly vote on a resolution to reaffirm support of sheriff's use of federal 287(g) program, and further, to express their support of the two officers who have been smeared by the parasitic hucksters at the SPLC and the open-border communists at the National Lawyers Guild, which is the main organization of the National Immigration Project."
Comments
(30)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
el paso
|
August 31, 2010
Some of you people are actually saying that if someone may be here illegally, then you have no problem with them being physically injured without justification. This certainly does not speak well of you. The problem with the 287(g) program is that suspected illegals are arrested on false or minor charges, and often deported before the court hearing. The 287(g) program is supposed to be used to deport violent criminals, not someone driving without a license.
jhf
|
August 30, 2010
As a retired Border Patrol Agent, I wouldn't form any opinion on the guilt or innocence of the officers involved or on Castro-Torres without seeing all the available information. Still, it seems to me that it's "over-kill" for this guy to have six lawyers. And the problem here isn't "287(g)"; it's the possible misconduct of the officers or of Mr. Castro-Torres.
fastteam
|
August 29, 2010
these officers are a disgrace to their uniform and should be punished
Lauren P.
|
August 29, 2010
The Southern Poverty Law Center is a scam moutfit. They file these suits all the time to make a buck.

It's this kind of nonsense that is getting in the way of law enforcement officers to DO THEIR JOBS!!! To PROTECT AND SERVE! If a judge allows this case to proceed, get him or her off the bench.

VOTE TUESDAY, NOV. 2ND -- REPUBLICAN AND/OR CONSERVATIVE INDEPENDENT!!!! Every time liberals are in the majority this nonsense continues to happen!!! TAKE BACK YOUR COUNTRY BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE!
Willie Brown
|
August 28, 2010
The officers had every right to stop and question him since he almost hit the officers vehicle.If he is in our country he should be deprted now. The cobb county commissors and the cobb county police department shoud defend the officer in a court of law regardless of what it cost.
MorrisDees <3es $$!
|
August 28, 2010
This is the typical shake-down style which has given the SPLC the aroma of a 5 day old fish in the noonday sun. The fool Dees has no scruples & thus has lost whatever credibility he once had about 45 years ago. But if the craven politicians of Cobb County cave in to this shake-down pressure, then they will help to keep his criminal enterprise rolling! Then whose a fool?! I say they should stand firm & tell Dees "We'll see you in court, Sucker!"
bertcoker@bellsouth.
|
August 28, 2010
Is this person legal or an illegal alien trying to smear these officers to gain entry to the U.S.A. and will these lawyers pay if these officers are found not guilty?
Obbop
|
August 28, 2010
May a horde of illegals descend upon the Southern Poverty Law Center enter and desire what they see; their cars, assorted property.... all the stuff that strangely disappears when the illegals enter the areas I, a working-poor USA citizen, was living in illegal-dense California.

And may the SPLC be confronted with the "machismo culture" as I and other USA citizens had thrust upon us, requiring physical confrontation to defend ourselves from that craziness.
fiscal conservative
|
August 28, 2010
Does this article say Torres is here illegally? Or are we to just assume this to be the case?
Just Wait
|
August 27, 2010
It is not fair to look at all Hispanics and believe they are here illegally. It is not fair to paint all those who speak against Hispanics here illegally as mindless idiots without any regard for others. It is fair to expect everyone to follow the letter of the law. If you are breaking the laws, do not expect to then use them against those who do. This country is one of tremendous freedom and tolerance. It would be wise not to push these gifts too far.
Empty
|
August 27, 2010
The 14th amendment gives the children of illegals protection. That is questionable at best but as of today they are called anchor babies and are protected by the amendment. It does not extend to other illegals in this country. Why on earth do services like the SPLC waste their contributed funds protecting illegals from laws they have no protection from in the first place? Help those who are legal and need your help. Not the other way around..
Atticus Too
|
August 27, 2010
This is simple -- whoever broke the law needs to suffer the consequences. (Note: 'if" means a conditional statement). If Mr. Castro-Torres is illegal or resisted the officers, then let's enforce the consequences. If the officers broke the law, his 4th amendment rights or assaulted him, then let's enforce the consequences. That's the law and order approach.

The real shame is that Judge Toby Prodgers could have easily resolved this had the officers shown up in his courtroom. Judge Toby is good people. His integrity, conduct and sense of justice is second to none in the county. BTW Judge Toby is a Vietnam Vet with a Bronze Star and a Combat Infantry Badge -- he's paid his dues.

Both parties are entitled to their day in court. That's our system and anyone who attacks that system is getting on real soft ground. Oh, and by the way, most of you commentators can't serve on that jury of 12 or 6 citizens since you've already made up your minds about who's right and wrong. That's our system too, thank the Lord.

I really really hope our police officers are found not-guilty. To think otherwise is scary for us all. More pay for our Cobb County's finest - our police and fire fighters!
FED UP
|
August 27, 2010
Why are People so quick to say get the illegals out..History tells us that WE ARE ALL ILLEGALS.THIS LAND BELONGED TO THE NATIVE AMERICANS BEFORE ANY OF US EVER STEP FOOT ON THIS LAND!!(SOME BY CHOICE,OTHERS BY FORCE) YOU CAN'T DISCOVER WHAT WAS ALREADY FOUND!! El paso is correct all those with the negative comments probaly say they're christians...sad because there is nothing CHRIST LIKE ABOUT YOUR COMMENTS..THE BIBLE SAYS JUDGE NOT LESS YOU BE JUDGED..STOP THROWING STONES IN GLASS HOUSES!!!TO GOD NO ONE RACE IS SUPERIOR TO ANOTHER....GET OVER YOURSELVES!!!!!
Robert Valdez
|
August 27, 2010
I an an immigrant and came here legally. I am happy to talk to any police officer and was taught to respect them. This man was obviously here illegally and tried to get away. I hope the officers are praised, not sued.

I support the law and 287G.
SPLC is shameless
|
August 27, 2010
This will serve to bring the commuity together even more on the crime of illegal immigration.

I am in the huge majority that supports our Cobb Police. Like Mr. King, I am waithing to see the Commissioners make their position clear.
Sloppy Joe
|
August 27, 2010
Those who have commented here need to be careful not to assume that all police officers are either good or bad, or that all hispanics are either legal or illegal. Remember: "Whether you're an honest man, or whether you're a thief, depends on whose solicitor has given me my brief." (Benjamin Franklin)
Marie in Marietta
|
August 27, 2010
As usual, Mr. King summed it up perfectly.
juliay
|
August 27, 2010
I'm sick and tired of all these illegal thinking they have rights--they don't YOU ARE ILLEGAL. Good for the police that took him down when he tryed to get his taser.What do you think would happen if an american was in his country and got into a fight with a police person-they would be under the jail for a long long time-but here in american you can sue the police-YOU ARE ILLEGAL YOU HAVE NO RIGHTS YOU DON'T LIKE THE WAY YOU WERE TREATED GO HOME AND TAKE ALL YOU ILLEGAL FRIENDS AND FAMILY WITH YOU THAT THIS COUNTRY IS PAYING FOR.(SCHOOLS-MEDICAL-HOUSING-FOOD-MEDICINES ETC.

mk--thanks, D.A.!
|
August 27, 2010
Any people that want to support this Torres guy, the SPLC, the ACLU, LaRAZA, etc., as well as illegal immigration,... I suggest you go take a Sunday drive through the area where this guy was picked up,.. the South Cobb Drive/Benson Poole/Pat Mell intersection. Take a ride through the surrounding neighborhoods- its a 3rd world disaster zone,... & the effects will cost Cobb & its' citizens for years to come! Illegal immigration is having a huge detrimental effect on anything good happening in Smyrna! It's time to pull your heads out of the sand & SEE!
el paso
|
August 27, 2010
So many of you are willing to throw our constitutional rights under the bus it is scary. The officers apparently did not come to court because they did not want to questioned under oath. From what the officers describe there can be no justification for the injuries Castro suffered. To say a human has no rights if they are here illegally shows a serious lack of morality.
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.