School board attorney expected to resign
by Kathryn Dobies
kdobies@mdjonline.com
August 11, 2010 12:00 AM | 3123 views | 21 21 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA - In a surprise move, longtime Cobb school board attorney Glenn Brock is expected to resign at today's Board of Education meeting, the Journal has learned.

Although the 30-member, Marietta-based Brock, Clay, Calhoun and Rogers law firm will continue its contract with the school board, Brock is expected to suggest to the board that partner Clem Doyle take over the board's work. Brock will likely continue to work with Fulton and Clayton county school systems, both of which the law firm represents.

Doyle has been a partner in the Brock Clay law firm since 2006 and was the attorney for Marietta City Schools before joining the firm. When he joined Brock Clay, he brought that district's account with him.

A native of Athens, Doyle is a graduate of Princeton University, where he played football, and of University of Georgia law school. His specialty is education law.

He and his wife, Mary Margaret Hines, have two young sons who attend Marietta City Schools.

Brock reportedly will tell the Cobb school board today that he is "transitioning" from the Cobb board rather than resigning. He has been involved in several controversies with the board in recent years, especially over repeated board violations of Georgia's Open Meetings laws and high profile lawsuits of which the board has lost.

In 2005, Brock and his attorneys advised the school board to go ahead with spending more than $100 million in special purpose local option sales tax money on laptops for all district middle and high school students. That decision spiraled out of control and cost the district an expensive lawsuit, resulting in then-Superintendent Joe Redden to step down.

In July 2009, Brock admitted that the school board had been voting secretly in executive session since January 2007, a violation of the Georgia Open Meetings Act. At the time, Brock said he took full responsibility for the secret votes, saying: "Mistakes have been made. We're making efforts correcting them."

Also, in July 2009, Brock provided legal advice to Dr. John Crooks and the board, allowing them to place an item on the agenda the day of the meeting regarding a controversial cell tower vote. The decision to place the item on the agenda on the day of the meeting eventually led to a lawsuit against the board for violating state Open Meetings Act by failing to give proper notice of the vote. The court issued a restraining order for any work on the tower, but that became moot when Crooks called for a second vote on the tower. The cell tower issue also led to an unsuccessful effort to recall Crooks.

Another controversy centered on Brock's secretly approved contract in 2007 that provided it would roll over automatically every four years unless the board voted to cancel, which was exposed by the Journal a year later. That contract is worth about $2 million a year in legal fees, much of which is a result of the many special education issues Brock Clay handles for the district. Although the current contract is not set to expire until the end of 2012, Brock wrote the board - after the Journal exposed the secret contract - that it could disregard the contract whenever it wanted, but did ask for six months notice should the board ever want to terminate the contract.

The fact that the legal services contract has not been bid out since Brock took over the account more than 20 years ago has been a source of controversy as well. Several school board members campaigned on unfulfilled promises to bid out the legal work, including both Crooks and Dr. John Abraham in 2006. More recently Kathy Angelucci, who was elected to succeed Abraham on July 20, and Scott Sweeney, the Republican candidate who is vying for Crooks' east Cobb seat, also promised to bid out the legal services once sitting on the board. The controversy surfaced again weeks ago when it was reported that Sanderson had bid out a small audit contract for SPLOST III, but did not bid out the much more costly legal services.

It is not known if Doyle and his Brock Clay partners will work under the old secret contract or void it and work for the board on an hourly basis.

Also today, the school board will hear an update from the superintendent regarding the district's Strategic Plan, but has no plans to talk about a reimbursement for the roughly $41,000 in legal fees Crooks accrued to fight the unsuccessful effort to recall him.

Board Chairwoman Lynnda Crowder-Eagle said the board is still waiting on some information from Crooks, as well asBrock Clay, before it plans to further discuss possible reimbursement.

"As soon as we receive that, we will put it on our agenda, or if Dr. Crooks prefers we will call a special meeting," Crowder-Eagle said.

A heated debate among board members regarding the reimbursement occurred at the July 22 meeting.

The board eventually voted 5-1, with David Banks dissenting, to table the decision for reimbursement and seek legal advice from Brock Clay on whether there were previous rulings involving such situations.

As for the Strategic Plan, Crowder-Eagle said the board will hear an update from Superintendent Fred Sanderson, although the board chairwoman doubted it would be a full update since she didn't think the district had received all of its test scores yet.

The board will also discuss implementing the district's new scheduling plan to all of its high schools.

In February, the board awarded a contract to Edupoint Educational Systems to install a new scheduling system on a trial basis at three middle schools and four high schools. During this preliminary period, Sprayberry, Lassiter, Harrison, and Pope high schools, and McClure, Lovinggood and Garret middle schools briefly tested the system. Based on that successful implementation, the board is poised to install the system at the rest of its middle and high schools for a cost of $500,842.
Comments
(21)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Curious One
|
August 11, 2010
Resign my foot, Brock should have been fired years ago and disbarment procedings completed. Bid out the contract for the first time in 20 years will likely save taxpayer money and get real legal advice.

Ok, Board what will you do ?
NewName
|
August 11, 2010
With regards to Brock leaving his duties with the CCSB, it was probably long overdue. Mr. Doyle should be given a fair chance and from all appearances thus far, he does seem to understand the law with regards to open meetings. Of course, I am not crying for Mr. Brock, because as a senior partner in that firm, he will sill enjoy the money that flows into the firm from the CCSB.

As for tonights meeting, I would like to find out how much his new scheduling program will save us in the form of payroll....I would think there would be some reducion in headcount on Glover Street as a result of this.

It will also be interesting to see how LCE handles the Crooks reimbursement issue, either sooner or later. My guess is she will continue to put it off hoping it just goes away. Of course, it is very doubtful that someone like Dr. Crooks is going to walk away quietly wih that type of legal bill hanging over his head. My guess is if she approves and votes for it, we will have another new face on the school board when her seat is up for re-elecion.
Replace the Law Firm
|
August 11, 2010
It is about time Cobb County wakes up and rids itself of the money hungry lawyers conduting themselves illegally, who follow their own agenda. The actions of the law firm Brock, Clay, Calhoun,and Rodgers indicate the entire law firm should have been replaced a long, long, time ago.
Clean House
|
August 11, 2010
The county needs to dump this law firm and hire a firm with ethics and who understands the law about open meetings. Clean house and hire honest lawyers.
beth a
|
August 11, 2010
the way every one is carring on about this i wonder if all of you are perfect.

think about all this mess you are saying about BROCK CLAY

.WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO SAY WHEN YOU STAND BEFORE YOUR MASTER ?
Snake pit
|
August 11, 2010
The snake may have put his head back in hole, but he's just one in the pit with many more still slithering around waiting to strike.

New school board do us a favor and find a reputable firm altogether and get rid of the waste in the administration.
retiree
|
August 11, 2010
it appears all the rats are trying to get off the sinking ship.
Omar the Begger
|
August 11, 2010
Brock, Clay, Calhoun and Rogers, you know people,if you or I did any of the things listed in the M.D.J. that this law firm did and I use the term Law Firm in the loosest term possible, they would not have a jail cell small enough for us. God people how much money will the county school system loose because of this firm. I will say to Dr. Crooks I am sorry for all of the evil that was visited upon you, even though you though you were getting good legal advice all I can say to you is good luck and please seek out a good law firm in the future. Mr. Brock, please leave and do not go away mad just go away; we now have to clean up this mess you left behind.
Wanda Rules!
|
August 11, 2010
The School Board is probably stupid enough to think this gesture solves the problem.

Hint: Even though there is another face up front, does anyone think Brock is not going to get the lion's share of the $2 million?

Further Hint: Doyle is so inexperienced that he is not even rated in Martindale, the lawyer's Bible.
HE Reynolds
|
August 11, 2010
Brock Clay....is this the same Clay who is the mouthpiece for Brown and the Cobb EMC board who are supposedly stealing money from Cobb EMC with "their" Cobb Energy sweetheart deals?
anonymous
|
August 11, 2010
Don't be fooled, Cobb County. Brock is going to concentrate on winning that Dekalb Cty contract. It's all about the money. And what is this about "service" to Cobb? Brock does this to be paid, and paid well. There is no service in this. Get real!
come on
|
August 11, 2010
Brock Clay knows that big changes are on the way at the CCSD and they are just trying to cover their backsides.
just the facts
|
August 11, 2010
This school board just cannot tell the truth to the public. Brock was forced to resign by his law partners because of all the embarrassment he has has been to the CCSD and the law firm.
Highschoolparent
|
August 11, 2010
the scheduling system also has an annual cost of about $130,000 after this for a total cost of about a million. What happens after 3 yrs? another new system like schoolmax?
idunno
|
August 11, 2010
to Pope parent- they need the system to schedule classes. duh.
pope parent
|
August 11, 2010
What is this new scheduling system that costs half a million dollars??? Why do we need it?
Pat H
|
August 11, 2010
What is his hourly rate? It should be no more than $200, and even at that it is too much.
anonymous
|
August 11, 2010
New school board members, new super, new attorney - now just clean out some of those administrative people making $130,00 retirement or more and we might be back to running smoothly - we can only help.

thanks Glenn for your service, I'm sure you have to be relieved to be getting out of this mess!

givemeliberty
|
August 11, 2010
Maybe Mr. Brock has that "out of sight, out of mind" mentality. Given the Board's proclivity to being rather short on sense, they just might think that with the new Mr. Doyle that the Board has a new law firm and therefore no bids are necessary.
noseriously
|
August 11, 2010
Clem is a good man for the job.
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.