Cobb Commission candidate 'ashamed' of road-rage arrest
by Katy Ruth Camp
krcamp@mdjonline.com
July 15, 2010 12:00 AM | 4441 views | 46 46 comments | 25 25 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Earl Stine, one of three GOP candidates for District 3 commissioner, acknowledged Wednesday that he had displayed a handgun to another driver in a 2005 road-rage incident in Fulton County, a crime for which he spent two years on probation.

"I'm so ashamed of that point in my life," Stine said. "The bottom line in all of this is, in spite of what this fella did, I didn't have to do what I did, and I screwed up. ... It's really embarrassing. I was ashamed about 10 seconds after I did it."

But Stine said he is not dropping out of the commission race, which could be decided by Tuesday's primary.

"This will not affect my ability as a county commissioner. If I had to do it over again it wouldn't happen. But I'm human, I made a mistake and I accept the consequences of my actions," Stine said. "I hope people will forgive me and continue to support me."

The road-rage situation happened about 4 p.m. on Dec. 12, 2005, on Interstate 20, according to the Atlanta Police incident report.

But Stine said it began a little while earlier, as he was merging onto I-20 east near Six Flags, when an SUV with darkly tinted windows drove from the far left lane into Stine's lane, sending Stine into the ditch.

"I wanted to make sure he missed me, because he was going to hit me," Stine said.

Further up the interstate, Stine said the SUV pulled up beside him, and Stine shook his head at the driver to show his disdain at the earlier incident.

Stine said that's when the SUV began jutting into his lane, and the driver of the SUV continuously flipped Stine off, shook his fist and made other obscene gestures towards him. At this point, Stine said, the two drivers were on I-285.

"I just wanted him to leave me alone, to get home, so I had my windows up and put the profile of my .40 caliber Glock next to the window. It had a clip in it, but there was no bullet in the chamber, and I certainly had no intent to pull the trigger," Stine said. "I made a fool out of myself, quite frankly. I was angry and made a really bad decision and I accept responsibility for that."

"Ten seconds after it happened I said, 'Earl, you're a blooming idiot. What have you just done?' I accept the consequences of everything I do, and I'm just really ashamed of this," Stine said.

Stine got off at Atlanta Road and saw "two or three police cars sitting there, waiting for me," he said. The other driver had called 911 and been routed through Cobb County dispatchers. Stine said he pulled over and told the Cobb County Police officers they would find a gun in his glove box and a clip in his center console. Stine said he had a concealed-carry permit and had the gun in his car because he had recently been wild boar hunting.

The other driver, named in the police report as Jerome Durham of Hiram, also pulled over at Atlanta Road, but did not get out of his car. Stine said he didn't see anyone else in the other car.

"He was a few cars behind me and had rolled the window down and talked to the police. He was 40 or 50 feet behind me, and still at that point I didn't notice anyone else in the car. To be honest, I was kind of nervous to begin with when that happened because I'm not used to that sort of thing. I've never been in trouble in my life, and I haven't been in trouble since. I wasn't interested in getting in a fight," Stine said.

Durham did not immediately return a telephone call for comment.

According to the Cobb Police incident report, the other driver, reported to 911 dispatchers that Stine "had pointed a gun at him on I-20 eastbound before I-285 in Atlanta." During the traffic stop, Cobb Police confiscated Stine's weapon, a Glock model 22). "We determined the actual event occurred in the city of Atlanta. Atlanta Police did not respond to the scene so we advised Durham of warrant procedures and released both parties," Cobb Police noted.

Atlanta Police wrote up the incident report a week later, on Dec. 19, 2005. Stine hired Marietta defense lawyer Beth Guerra, who was in contact with the Fulton District Attorney's office. Stine was initially charged with, and later indicted on felony charges of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, possession of a firearm during commission of a felony; and two counts of second-degree cruelty to children, as there were two children in Durham's car.

Stine said he had arranged to turn himself in on Feb. 3, but said his appendix ruptured the night before, and his surrender was delayed several months as he endured other personal and family medical issues, including a car accident that left his son in a coma for several weeks.

He surrendered to Fulton County Sheriff's office on Aug. 28, 2006, according to the book-in records, and was released two days later on $125,000 bond. Stine said his time behind bars was spent in the jail's medical ward.

On March 20, 2007, Stine pleaded guilty to three misdemeanor counts of simple assault. Fulton Superior Court Judge Tom Campbell sentenced him to two years on probation and ordered him to complete an anger violence course, which Stine had already done.

His probation term ended in March 2009.

Last Friday, Stine visited the Journal for an editorial board, and denied he had any skeletons to reveal.

"I've got one of the most boring lives in the world. I haven't got anything," he told the Journal at that time.

On Wednesday, Stine apologized and said he was trying save his family from the public embarrassment. He said he explained the situation to his two sons, who were 19 and 24 at the time, as "the perfect example of what not to do."

"I feel bad I didn't come out with it six or eight months ago, but it's really more embarrassing for my wife than it is for me. She was really appalled that it happened because she couldn't believe I would do something like that," Stine said.

Stine also said he did not renew his carry permit after the ordeal.

"I felt like I didn't deserve to carry a concealed weapon if I couldn't be responsible. Both my boys have carrying permits and if they ever did something stupid like I did, they should let it lapse," Stine said.
Comments
(46)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Heaven help us
|
July 20, 2010
Just what we need... somebody that thinks being "good with financials" is a good complement to a criminal record. But what the heck, go ahead and vote for Stine in the chairman's race if you want to.

GA Grad
|
July 20, 2010
Not a smart move to do it nor to hide it. But, I think Stine is pretty good with financials, which I question Lee on based on the bankruptcy information.
Gagirlnow
|
July 19, 2010
Another out of control politician - why is it just more boring news? As long as money runs government and buys elections we'll have more unqualified politicians in office. Government of, for and by the corporations - quoted from an 1890's history of politics-THAT'S 18990's, not 1990's!
three strikes
|
July 17, 2010
Strike 1: Poor judgment in pulling a gun on somebody.

Strike 2: more poor judgment thinking you can run for office with a (recent) criminal record at all, much less one like this.

Strike 3: poor character in not confessing when specifically asked.

We didn't need a voodoo doll wielding commissioner in southwest cobb, and we don't need a gun wielding commissioner in northeast cobb either.
Alabama Boy
|
July 16, 2010
You don't hunt wild board with no semi auto pistol you use a 357 mag or 44 mag six shooter. This boy not telling the truth or You all are dumb in Georgia.
Dont blame Victim
|
July 16, 2010
Don't blame the victim Mr. Stine you pulled the gun on children you plea guilty and served the time for it.

If you are trying to blame law enforcement then you really should re-think running for this office.Those brave men and women put their life on the line everyday so people like you can travel on our roads knowing no one will pull a gun on them or their family. Oh thats right you did pull a gun on a family well they cannot be 100%. Move on to another level of blame it was not the police and it was not the victim accept it you were wrong and were convicted of it no one else.
anonymous
|
July 16, 2010
law enforcement is not to blame. I know liberals play that card all the time. They deal in facts

1. he had the gun 2. he pointed the gun at another person 3. there were children in the car he pointed the gun at. 4. He tried to hide the gun. 5. He did not call to report that his life was in danger because he was too busy covering and trying to get away before Cobb Police stopped him. So how was this the fault of law enforcement. On your comment alone he should not be running for public office since he will be overseeing the public saftey dept.
neutral party
|
July 16, 2010
While Mr. Stien was wrong he should have demanded a jury trial. The actions of the other driver clearly show a disregard for the safety of his passengers as well as for Mr. Stein.If the other vehicle kept moving into the lane occupied by Mr. Stein then that should be considered an assault with a deadly weapon, his vehicle, and he should have been charged or at the very least he should have been made to explains his actions to a jury and let the jury decide who was being the bigger threat.

This was very shoody work on the part of law enforcement.
Factor
|
July 16, 2010
I'm not saying Stine was in the right at all in this incident, but according to the information in the article, the other driver is certainly not completely innocent. If Jerome Durham was indeed swerving repeatedly into Stines' lane and trying to hit him (as it appears in the article) WITH his children in the car then that seems to me to be child endangerment at the very least. And THEN later to hide behind the same children he just put in harms way when the police arrive is the height of cowardice and gutlessness to me. Again, Stine is not lily-white here but Durhams behavior is, to me, in many ways worse.
Action over words
|
July 15, 2010
Hey Im sure he is a swell guy but he was not dragged into this race and forced to do this. He has spent alot of his own money creating an image hoping to hide from his recent past. This was not a teenage prank it involved a GUN and he was 50 years old at the time and should have know better. When you stand for public office you need to let the people know that they can trust everything that comes from you mouth. Not just when you are caught. This is a truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth. HE FAIL THAT MISSION
pressaver
|
July 15, 2010
We did not read in this article the countless number of Habitat houses and volunteer efforts Earl has been a part of. Stay strong Earl!
anonymous
|
July 15, 2010
Earl would have been a real good commish....Oh well.
schooboardparent
|
July 15, 2010
Over the past 10 years, the MDJ has called Commissioners and School Board members into their office for a grilling. Many of them have stalled, stumbled, told half-truths and angered voters. The point is to tell the truth the first time. He lied on Friday to the editors and only ‘fessed up Wednesday when caught by evidence. How can we trust him with a four year term and believe any future statements?

Lee and Birrell
|
July 15, 2010
OH MY what a terrible thing for Cobb. Tim Lee and Joann on the same board. It is bad enough Lee is with Woody Thompson. We need more diversity on our board. And Madam Helen is with this program also we need somebody for the people. Voters beware!
Supporter
|
July 15, 2010
Just voted for Earl and so did my neighbors. GO EARL!
DIRTY JOANN
|
July 15, 2010
If Joann's camp can stir this kind of action I am worried about her being our commisioner! She will do whatever it takes to get things her way. You voters need to know the facts this woman is lethal. She has the big guns behind her. We need a commisioner that represents the people and not the establishment. JOANN IS DIRTY AND DANGEROUS!!!!! VOTE JULY 20th anybody but Joann. JOANN Yes she can ruin our county!!
CountToTenChildren
|
July 15, 2010
So, this man wants to serve in public office that oversees Public Safety and Police? He said public safety would be his first priority, but apparently not in his own life. Based on his temper and gun charges, sounds like he should remain a citizen and not elected official. Forgiveness is one thing, electing him is another.

Job one Truth
|
July 15, 2010
Well it seems that Tim Lee is not the only one with a Bankruptcy problem. Stine seems to be a little bankrupt on the truth.

So when did you realize you had not told the whole truth before or after the MDJ called about the story?
Committeefriends
|
July 15, 2010
To ToddEastCobb: OK, we get it. The committee to elect this man supports him. But undecided voters deserve more answers. By your logic, should all the candidates go commit a crime and “come clean” to earn your admiration?

Mother Irish
|
July 15, 2010
Earl is a very humble man, and yes he made a mistake. He and his wife Cindy are very giving people, active in their church. He is not a red neck and you would know that from the first time he speaks. He is a concerned man who wants the best. Who among us has not done something we regretted later? He will work hard for us as our commissioner and he still has his yard sign in my yard and the two votes from this household. You go EARL!
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides