Illegal, But Enrolled: Case a wake-up call for taxpayers, lawmakers
May 11, 2010 12:00 AM | 2130 views | 38 38 comments | 20 20 recommendations | email to a friend | print
IS IT OK TO CHEAT at Kennesaw State University? Apparently so. That's the only conclusion that can be drawn from the sequence of events that have played out there in recent days.

Senior Jessica Colotl, who is in the country illegally, was stopped for a traffic violation while driving on campus without a valid U.S. driver's license and then gave false and misleading statements to KSU and Cobb police. We suspect that in most cases, such a string of law-breaking and half-truths would be grounds to be hauled in front of a school's Honors Court. But not at KSU. Just the opposite, in fact.

"This is great news for Ms. Colotl, her family and friends and for the KSU community," crowed President Dr. Dan Papp when her release from custody was announced on Wednesday. "We are especially thrilled she will be allowed to continue her studies here at KSU. We would also like to thank everyone who was involved, both on campus and within the larger community, in helping Ms. Colotl."

We understand that educators go into education because they like helping people and mentoring them, and Papp might well have been torn about what to do in this case. But the law is the law and must be upheld.

We wonder whether KSU would look so favorably on a student who cheated on a test or who forged his transcript? It appears that a precedent has now been set for "looking the other way."

The special treatment awarded Ms. Colotl is a slap in the face to Georgia taxpayers and their children who hope to someday attend college or get an advanced degree.

***

WHEN STOPPED March 29, Colotl had an expired passport and no valid driver's license - although she had a Mexican one - despite reportedly having lived in this country since age 7. It is unclear whether she owned the vehicle or was an insured driver.

She was arrested by KSU police a day later and taken to the Cobb jail, where she gave booking officers a Duluth address as her residence. (Yet when an MDJ reporter visited that location, the person who answered the door said she had lived there five months but had yet to meet Ms. Colotl.)

The student was duly handed over to Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials and initially was given 20 days to leave the country. Then - after a full-court lobbying effort by Papp and the school's taxpayer-funded legal team - she was abruptly released on Wednesday and granted a one-year deferment by ICE during which to pursue her studies.

It probably comes as a surprise to most readers to learn that Georgia colleges and universities allow those in this country illegally to register as students, but it is the truth. As we are learning, our campuses are "sanctuaries" of a sort, where certain laws that apply elsewhere no longer apply.

Such students are not eligible for in-state tuition, tuition wavers or other state programs to defray their costs - although those on the left are trying to erase even that hindrance. And in some cases - like that of Ms. Colotl - they are, in fact, admitted as in-state students and charged tuition at the much lower in-state rate.

Some of Ms. Colotl's defenders on the MDJonline.com blog site and elsewhere also have suggested that racism is at work in the coverage of her predicament. As one put it, "If (she were) Polish or Swedish, no one would be flipping out about this."

Well, if this were the case of a Polish or Swedish student, they would almost certainly have come here legally, not illegally - and they and their supporters wouldn't have the gall to demand special rights. And you can be sure that if this were the case of an American student illegally in Mexico trying to get a college degree, she wouldn't be getting the kid gloves treatment.

The episode also is a reminder that people will do nearly anything to break into our country - and that you never hear of anyone desiring to break out of it.

Moreover, if a succession of presidents and Congress had not closed their eyes to the problems of illegal immigration, we wouldn't have an estimated 12 million to 20 million illegals living in this country with more on the way.

***

WE CANNOT BLAME Ms. Colotl - who having apparently spent most of her life in this country, is probably more American than Mexican at this point, and to her credit, has many KSU friends willing to go to bat for her - for trying to get the best education she can. It is not her fault that she was brought here as a young girl by her parents, or that she was a bright enough student to be attractive to college administrators at KSU.

Colleges, after all, are merely trying to get the best possible students. But Georgia's institutions of higher learning were built and paid for by the tax dollars of our state's citizens. And how many bright Georgia young people are being denied enrollment in our colleges and universities because their slots were filled by those who are in our state and country illegally?

If one follows the logic of Ms. Colotl's supporters at KSU to its logical conclusion, our colleges should have an "open-doors" policy admitting anyone from anywhere in the world, as long as they can sneak past the border guards to get here and pass an entrance exam.

Yes, federal law requires that children who are in this country illegally receive a K-12 education, and though very costly for taxpayers, it is a justifiable approach. It is to no one's benefit to have a permanent class of completely uneducated people in this country illegally.

But higher education is different. Those in college are not minors dependent on their parents. If it is illegal for an adult to work in this country or reside here without the correct immigration documents, it should be illegal to study here as well. Georgia's policy that allows them to do so merely rewards illegal behavior and penalizes those who follow the rules in their own attempts to become citizens.

The Colotl case should serve as a wake-up call to lawmakers, college heads and the Board of Regents that entrance to our institutions of higher learning should go first and foremost to Georgians - and not those in our state illegally.
comments (38)
« citizen789 wrote on Saturday, May 22 at 03:45 PM »
I've only got one thing to say, check the stats for yourself:

http://immigrationcounters.com/

« mvale wrote on Thursday, May 20 at 06:35 PM »
Sorry but this girl has taken the place of a legal American. Also, I want to know if she is going to pay the out of state tuition that she owes this college?
« USAproud 2Bhere wrote on Wednesday, May 12 at 11:27 AM »
Let me get this straight...you're telling me a person came to our country illegally in 1996, was able to get

into a Georgia public school system at the age of 7 (without the proper identification) then was able to go thru her whole elementary, middle school and high school career, and finally three years of college without a RED FLAG being raised to school officials...I understand KSU admitted her because she was an in-state student BUT there are many forms and identifications that must be shown to many school officials to get into the system that obviously weren't, WHY? You've got to be kidding me! WOW! Then she gets caught with NO drivers license (needless to say she has been driving for several years without one, unbelievable!) Then of course the icing on the cake, she is ASKED to leave VOLUNTARY, yeah right! Let's all play Lotto too and win the grand prize and live on the beach!

This is just another sad testament to our country's future fate due to the massive amount of illegal aliens living in this country.....U.S. taxpayer's can't keep paying for everyone's free ride....we are at the breaking point...... and sadly too many people have FORGOTTEN THE RULE OF LAW! I don't care that Ms. Coloti had a 3.8 GPA. The law is the law!

Think about how many times you have to show your picture ID to get anything done in this country.....how was Ms. Coloti able to do this for so many years without raising a RED FLAG, if it were you or me, we would still be in jail.
« Jonathan McLain wrote on Wednesday, May 12 at 10:42 AM »
Illegal Aliens are not legal aliens and should be deported. They are law breakers. This is not only a slap in the face of GA law enforcement officials but all Georgians. KSU should look for a new president. This guy is laughable. What a sign that illegal immigration is way out of hand.
« PossumRed wrote on Wednesday, May 12 at 09:19 AM »
Great idea-give her just enough time to produce an 'anchor baby' so as to increase her chance of avoiding deportation.Why doesn't KSU just ban American citizens and open admission to 'ille'...ooops....'undocumented guests' only? Will been-in-U.S.-eleven-years-yet-no-English-speak-mother be deported also?
« Ripped Off Tax Payer wrote on Wednesday, May 12 at 06:47 AM »
Eric Johnson is right the 16% increase by the board of regents is because Jessica Coloti and others like her. They have invaded the country sealing services for hard working Americans and unemployed Americans. Your school taxes are more, auto insurance, health insurance and all other government cost because of this. I just didn’t know that illegal aliens had so many rights. After all they did fight to evade detection to get into the country. If we catch them can we send them to the Middle East to help us? Just remember if Jessica gets pregnant the kid get another door prize it’s a Unites States citizenship and goes straight pass go and gets social security only in America!!
« insideknowhow wrote on Wednesday, May 12 at 04:53 AM »
Someone might want to look into the statuses of the two young ladies who are the ones issuing the statements for this case and loudly expressing their views over what needs to be done. Perhaps there's a reason they now, according to other stories, are unable to be contacted by the media. Too much spotlight to be comfortable?

On another note, Miss Colotl now faces severe criminal charges which should be investigated. Driving w/o a license, possibly driving without insurance or correct registration and tag, forgery of documents to receive the previously mentioned, working within this country illegally (since she says she did it to pay tuition; this should also affect who employed her), providing false of misleading information to police officers upon arrest (this is the biggest one that people seem to be sweeping under the rug), buys and owning forged documents (if shes never been to Mexico she received the Mexican license here as well as the passport which mean they are both forgeries), falsifying federal or states documents to receive in-state tuition, receiving in state tuition which basically amounts to theft by receiving doesnt it?, and a whole hosts of other federal and state laws that appear to have been broken. Maybe it wouldve just been better for her to hope on that bus back to Mexico, at least she could be with her father, but here she might end up in a lot of trouble.
« Cali Girl wrote on Wednesday, May 12 at 02:08 AM »
"I believe that these people are especially brave to live the lives they do. They are not here for themselves, but rather to leave nations in political and economic turmoil".

Seriously, Flipand? These people are not brave, they are not noble, they are lawbreakers with monster sized cajones. They ARE here for themselves. Mexico is an oil rich and wealthy country and it's a lot easier for the elite to bleed off their poor by encouraging them to go north instead of taking care of them. Why deal with the issue when the American saps who can't or won't control their borders will do it for them? They are not brave - to be brave and noble they would need to stay and fight for their rights in their own country - not go north and nurse off of the American taxpayer.
« TWA Fly Girl wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 09:28 PM »
WHAT does the word ILLEGAL mean????? Why have we let this immigration situation get to this? She should have filed her papers years ago.....and been "legal" by NOW!
« NtheNo wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 08:37 PM »
If you're illegal you should be deported - end of discussion. This appears to be institutional arrogance at its worst. Shame on you KSU - How disgusting.
« Gaanon21 wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 06:45 PM »
Why did U.S. immigration officials bow down to the ACLU and KSU? Shouldn't someone be asking quesitons about this case in Washington?

If everyone complains maybe U.S. immigration will release everyone and no one will ever be deported again; a proposal that the "open borders" crowd would love. Do your research people and wake up before it's too late!
« Kevin Lombard wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 05:46 PM »
My 20 year old college attending daughter was stopped a week ago in a vehicle safety checkpoint. She gave the police her license which she doctered to appear 21 years old. The policeman saw that her license had been tampered with. Well, I had to bail her out and get her a lawyer. Why? Because we are just American taxpaying citizens. And this illegal alien gets a pass, why? That's a shame on the American system.
« Pat H wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 04:07 PM »
I thank the MDJ for taking the right position on this matter. Insofar as her being such a bright student - well, two words: affirmative action.
« David S. Schneider wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 03:49 PM »
Since 1996 it has been a Federal Felony "Aid and abet or harbor an illegal alien", punishable by up to 10 years in a Federal Penitentary.
« fishtales wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 03:41 PM »
Flipand - Are you kidding me? Yeah I got documentation...it's called a birth certificate from a US hospital and just for giggles a GA drivers license...which the law requires me to carry for some crazy reason. This has nothing to do with racism, but just like many other issues today, when you run out of excuses, just play the racism card. Yay!!!
« Ron Mexico wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 03:08 PM »
Well all I know is she better be getting in some serious trouble with the county, gonna have some serious fines and probation to deal with now girly. At the very least (since I'm guessing she won't be sent back to her own country) the laws she broke that don't have anything to do with her immigration status BETTER be enforced. If I got to go through it if I break the law, so do these illegal immigrants.
« KLMPF wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 01:57 PM »
Our education system, from kindergarten through higher education, needs to be changed for citizens only, so taxpayers aren't paying for people who don't belong here. This is one of the perks that keep illegals coming here. It needs to be ended, along with automatic citizenship for those born here of illegal parents. She still has a legal Mexican license. Not surprising as many immigrants and illegals always keep one foot in their own countries, where their tax-free dollars made here, goes farther. What an injustice and slap in the face to citizens and legal immigrants. When will all this abuse be ended by our government? These leeches should all go back to where they came from, and not just Mexicans, either.
« JB Janes wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 01:24 PM »
why is this college charging anything? Should people just be able to walk in and take a seat. Wonder how this school would handle not knowing how many students it's required to educate, or even who they are.
« Toby Miller wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 12:43 PM »
I find the whole situation disgusting. Especially the actions of KSU. This is why corporations and now universities should be financially punished for harboring and exploiting illegal immigrants.
« Flipand wrote on Tuesday, May 11 at 12:36 PM »
The underlying racism of this article is disgusting. Who among us has a perfectly legal or documented ancestry? I know I do not and I doubt whoever wrote this does.

I believe that these people are especially brave to live the lives they do. They are not here for themselves, but rather to leave nations in political and economic turmoil. To make better lives for their families. While I am sure it is easy to sit in this nice little hamlet of Marietta and look down on brown skinned people, try and have a little bit of perspective that while everywhere is the "real world," Marietta and north Metro Atlanta has a decidedly different definition of reality. Treat others the way you would like to be treated.

Best and warmest regards,

A blessed white man from Kennesaw