Children will suffer if school buses privatized
April 27, 2010 12:00 AM | 733 views | 11 11 comments | 7 7 recommendations | email to a friend | print
DEAR EDITOR:

I drive a school bus for Cobb by choice. I get up every day proud of the job I have. I love working with the children and parents. They become family. I anxiously await the news from "Bobby" or "Susie" about their evening prior, their grades and progress at school. I worry about them when they are sick, just as if they were my own. That is why the news about privatizing hurt me so. These babies are not going to be the purpose of the job that way. I fear that without parental and community support this takeover might be allowed. Right about now it may seem easier to just let someone else deal with it. That is a mistake - one our children will pay for.

As it stands, we have the children's best interest in mind. We have good equipment, we have trained personnel that have gone thru vigorous background checks, we have communication with parents and administrators. We have policies that protect the children, designated stops with printed times that are strictly followed. We will return to pickup a child to ensure they get to school safely. We are highly trained professionals who care about the children, not the job. Yes, people will say "Oh they do it for the benefits." Well let me tell you that those people do not know the whole story, we are not the ones with those benefits. Bus drivers are here for one reason. We want this job, it is our choice to be here.

We have terrific mechanics and supervisors, who also truly care about the children. For me, the district I work in is like family, as I think the whole county is. And in any family you have some issues, just like we have had. But what sets us apart from a private company is this - responsibility. We all have our own sense of responsibility for these children. Everything we do revolves around those children, not the job. I would guarantee you that any bus driver, mechanic, teacher, parapro or administrator would agree with me on this. We focus 100 percent on the safety and well being of every child. You will not find that in a private company. They will not be held to the same standards as us. That is scary to me and should be to all.

Yes we had some minor issues. We have fixed our wrong and grew from it a better department. We need for people to understand that this private company takeover is a really bad idea for our children. Why make them pay the price they will have to pay if this happens? We can come together and take the cuts that are needed in stride.

Parents, stand behind us on this. You do not want private owners! They will do as they see fit and no public input what so ever! Help us help your children now!

Pamela Gullett
Marietta
Comments
(11)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
justMHO
|
May 05, 2010
Hey Otto Man,

just type in "First Student Bus Problems". Wow quite a record!

Now - type in "Cobb County School Bus Problems" - all you see is positive things and what the county has done to improve their system.

All parents compare the ratings between the two. That will answer you question, "what is wrong with Privatization".
East Cobber
|
April 28, 2010
The issue we all need to be aware here is the hidden cost associated with all employees; benefits (employee burden/overhead).

Business/political entities pay; Social Security match (6.2%) if they opt in, pension contributions, medical/dental/eye care and who knows what else. This number can be 20-30% of wages; get rid of the employee, get rid of the burden.

This is why outsourcing is so popular? Theoretically you can still provide the same level of service and transfer the hidden cost to some one else . This is wrong, in many ways.

There is no easy answer to the budget issue, but the bureaucratic organization behind the scenes needs to shrink before the first line employee...

Not the Same
|
April 28, 2010
Two quick things to think about concerning privatizing or OUTSOURCING the districk transportation dept.

1. Most of the time, do you really get good service when calling an 800# for "customer support" that usually ends up being in a foreign country? Most of the time NO. Privatizing or outsourcing the transportation is the same principle.

2. The vast majority of the school bus drivers do enjoy their job, but they also enjoy & need the medical benefits. A private compnay will not offer the same good benefits & therefore you will get inferior drivers who come and go. Not the same quality or stability as the employees now who drive our children.
Pamela Gullett
|
April 27, 2010
I am not concerned about the private company hiring me. I am concerned over the company drivers that would take over if they do not hire current drivers. My knowledge of private companies like Laid-Law they bring their own drivers. I could find another job I am sure, but can those babies I drive have another compentent driver like the ones Cobb employs? The children are my concern. I have heard horror stories of company drivers in schools from accidents to letting students off at wrong stops and the list goes on. That is why I am begging parents to get involved to protect their children from this...not my job.
mom to 2
|
April 27, 2010
My heart goes out to you Pamela. You sound just like the woman, Marie, that picks up my children for school each day. We absolutely love her. She has called me during the floods last fall to warn me she'd be delayed to re-routing around flooded roads and asked if I could let the other parents know. And another time couldnt get down our road due to construction and asked if one of us could meet her on the busy road before she let the kids out to walk on there own. She awaits each day to make sure all parents are home before driving off to her next stop. I cannot imagine what it will be like without our Marie who puts our children's safety above all. Just another added headache to many of the parent concerns for future of our kids.
Otto Mann
|
April 27, 2010
Why wouldn't the private company hire you Pamela?
anonymous
|
April 27, 2010
Whew, the list is long... A history of NOT ADDRESSING the following continuing problems in Ohio, Florida, Michigan, and New York:

1) Not completing background checks on drivers

2) Buses not showing up or being extremely late on a regular basis

3) Drivers being unsafe

4) Not protecting the safety of the children.

And this company apparently does not return calls or simply says "sorry".

Unfortunately our school board has a history of repeating other school systems' mistakes. Hopefully that won't happen here.
Alan Faircloth
|
April 27, 2010
Can't unelect the private company and we've seen that the Board refuses to deal with contracts for services as they should (The Facilities Group on SPLOST contracts, The Legal Services Agreement with Brock Clay, etc.). Voters don't have a say on the contracts, but we can fire Board members.
What the!?
|
April 27, 2010
The savings that privatizing would bring would be minimal at best I think. A bus is a bus. Fuel is fuel. A driver is a driver. Maintenance is maintenance.

What is it that a for-profit company can provide that the county cannot? Better management? Better efficiency? Lower human resources costs?

Seems that can be done in house if someone had the cajones to make it happen and hold people accountable.

The system is a multi-million dollar enterprise and it is apparent that local small-time politicos are ill equipped to be at the helm.
anonymous
|
April 27, 2010
more than likely a private company would hire the existing staff to reduce the learning curve, so in the case mentioned here, these current staffers would then become bad and dangerous because of who signs their paycheck.
????6
|
April 27, 2010
Why would it follow that the bus drivers from a private company would be any less caring?
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.