Don McKee: Hill says 'I'd rather be conservative than chairman'
by Don McKee
Columnist
April 19, 2010 12:00 AM | 959 views | 8 8 comments | 12 12 recommendations | email to a friend | print
State Sen. Judson Hill (R-Marietta) lost the chairmanship of the Senate Reapportionment and Redistricting Committee for voting against his party's tax hike bill, but he won something that may be more important in the Republican primary July 20.

It's an endorsement from a tea party group.

On his website Hill has posted this: "Due to vote against tax increases & stand for liberty the TEA Party Patriots announced their endorsement of my reelection @ ATL TEA Party."

The Atlanta rally came a week after Hill refused to join a Republican Senate caucus majority in voting for HB 307. The bill imposes a 1.45 percent provider fee on hospital beds to raise $216 million to close the state Medicaid budget gap.

After voting against the bill, Hill was summarily stripped of his chairmanship by Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle and the Senate leadership which later added an amendment to remove the 2.5 percent state tax on insurance premiums and labeled the measure "a tax cut."

Although the MDJ was unsuccessful in contacting Hill afterward, he had an interview last week with WVGA Radio in Valdosta.

"I'd rather be a conservative than chairman," he told the talk show host. Hill said he believed his vote against HB 307 represented the people of his district. He also said legislators should "dig down deep to the core services of government" to find "additional savings" instead of increasing taxes and fees.

In an interview with the same radio station, Lt. Gov. Cagle, the Senate president, was asked why Hill was stripped of his chairmanship. Cagle replied: "He chose to violate the rule. He knew what the consequences were." The rule requires all caucus members to vote for a bill when two-thirds of the members do so.

"It's a team sport," Cagle said. "The senator chose to violate a caucus rule." He added, "There is no wriggle room in this."

Hill did not speak out in the Senate about his losing the chairman's post, but Sen. Preston Smith of Rome, who lost the Judiciary Committee chairmanship, castigated Cagle, president pro tem Tommie Williams of Lyons and majority leader Chip Rogers of Woodstock in a 20-minute barrage from the well of the Senate.

Describing how his fellow Republicans left the caucus meeting to do the bidding of their leaders, Smith said: "Like a scene from 'Lord of the Flies,' the group marched back in to the Senate to follow the order."

Judson Hill in the GOP primary faces challenger Lynda Coker, chief deputy sheriff of Cobb and former state representative. Hill's vote against HB 307 and his endorsement by the tea party gives him good talking points at a time when anti-tax sentiment is running strong here and across the country.

As tea party members gathered in Marietta before joining the thousands in front of the Georgia Capitol on Tax Day, one of the placards that stood out in the crowd put all candidates on notice:

"November is Coming."

dmckee9613@aol.com
Comments
(8)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Phonies
|
May 01, 2010
...so let's get this right.

The Teabaggers are against a bill that helps close known budget deficits? I thought their whole deal was about balancing budgets. Oh wait, so what we find out is that they're really just about the maniacal reduction/elimination of any and all taxes...but really just fake their true intentions under the guise of "budget balancing". Why don't they just take their precious money and find a Caribbean island willing to take them into their tax-free haven...oh, just some minor details, these tax-crazed lunatics will have to given up their medicare, their national highways, their security....but I'm sure like Thurston Howell while stranded on their desert isle, they can find a genius professor who can rub two tax-free coconuts together to provide any services they may need.
Bob The Business Man
|
April 22, 2010
Judson ran like a school girl from the capital he didn’t take a stand an vote no. He knows he he’s in trouble for reelection another “Dead Man Walking”.
East Cobb Voter
|
April 20, 2010
Senator Hill did not vote against HB 307! He skipped out before the vote. I would have a bit of respect for him if he had actually stayed and voted NO.

Senator Hill has a problem telling the whole truth. This sounds like when he said he was running for Attorney General and then found out that Sam Olens was running. He claimed that he never said he was running for AG.

Now he is telling people he voted against HB 307. To vote against a bill, you actually have to be there and pull the lever!

Yes, the voters will remember, but it will be in July for Senator Hill.
Cobb Resident
|
April 20, 2010
Don McGee: Unless you know something that other columnists don't know, then you need to correct your facts. Sen. Judson Hill physically left the building and NEVER voted against the tax on hospital beds. Yes, he may have violated a caucus rule by not voting in unison, but what voters want "block voting", choreographed by three people (Cagle, Williams and Rogers)?

Voters: We need to wake up. Who wants "caucus-block voting"??? We elected Sen. Hill (or any Senator) as an individual and expect him/her to act as one -- an individual who represents those individuals who voted him/her into office. We didn't vote for a minion who works exclusively for the Lt. Governor, Pro-Tem leader and Majority Leader!!!

Cagle is a slimy weasel, Rogers is getting too big for his britches and Williams is an idiot!

If this is the best that the Georgia Republicans can do, then we need rules changed and instant turnover.

We, the People, deserve better!
EastCobb
|
April 19, 2010
I will vote and donate to Senator Hill. I will NEVER vote for or donate to a Cagle campaign again.
Free Citizen
|
April 19, 2010
Thank you Rep. Hill. You would have my vote, if I were in your district. Citizens, who in the past were silent or complacent, are watching more closely now and they will turn out in mass in the next elections. We do not want this country to be Obama's 100% gov't controlled empire. To let 234 yrs. of independence go down the tubes in 4 yrs would be treason.
Let Justice Prevail
|
April 19, 2010
Justice is Justin Hill running for and winning the Lt. Governor primary....defeating Cagle. As for Isakson, he (and Chambliss) also voted for the 787 Billion Bailout bill. I haven't checked to confirm, but I think they also voted to approve re-appointment of Ben Bernanke.
Pat H
|
April 19, 2010
You are right, Mr. Hill. We, the people, and the taxpayers, are well aware of the problems in the Dome. Can you run for US Senate? We have only an impostor Democrat by the name of Isakson running. We remember his work on the amnesty bill with Kennedy, and will not vote for it.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides