Budget solutions? Redistrict, cut pay at top
April 11, 2010 12:00 AM | 1596 views | 31 31 comments | 16 16 recommendations | email to a friend | print
DEAR EDITOR:

The Cobb County School District has loudly proclaimed it has a $137 million budget shortfall (this number has grown from initial proclamations without much explanation as to why those estimates were so wrong). CCSD has asked for input from the public - nay, suggestions for ways to address the shortfall. Although CCSD and the school board have already decided what to do and the survey, this cry for input, is just for optics and perception, I will bite and offer my suggestions via this letter and not simply by completion of a SurveyMonkey survey.

First, the entire organizational structure and staffing needs to be redrawn - but from the ground up (or I should say classroom up). Start with the classrooms and the number of teachers required based upon a hard and fast student-to-teacher ratio, not an average that allows higher numbers to be offset by special classes where the numbers are lower. Teachers are the most important job in the education process. Everyone else is just support staff. Pictorially speaking, think of a pyramid and how they are built, bottom to top and not from the top down.

Second, redistrict the entire county. Cobb has a number of schools that are underutilized and a number that are overutilized from a student capacity standpoint. It is time to stop Band-Aid fixes or adjustments and to swallow the bitter pill that is a county wide redistricting to address population shifts and changes.

Third, the lies and deception must stop. Trust must be rebuilt so that teachers can trust administrators; parents can trust board members, board members can trust administrators and each other; and voters can trust those they elect, both board members and state legislators. False promises, manipulative conduct, secret voting and disregard of the public are counterproductive and must cease.

Fourth, leaders must lead by example and no one should be shielded from adversity that must be born of necessity. For example, if teachers are being required to take salary cuts and furlough days, then so should the administrators at the Glover Street headquarters. Apparently, though, this is not what happened. Rather, information available from the Georgia Department of Audits and Accounts indicates that raises/salary increases were common among and for Glover administrators. It has been stated by board members that nothing is off the table. My information is that this is not quite true when it comes to athletics, as coaches and staffs are immune from any cuts. Large is the mantle and great is the protection of "Coach Sanderson" (Superintendent Fred Sanderson).

Fifth, look at your data before releasing it. On the CCSD Web site April 2, it said that among the CCSD's 15,211 employees were: 6,636 classroom teachers, 1,672 special ed teachers and 1,168 bus drivers. That adds up to 9,476 people/positions. That is FAR short of 15,211. Even if we add up all the numbers listed on the CCSD Website for every position including, but not limited to, school counselors, social workers, psychologists, media specialists, etc., the total is 1,433 short of the 15,211 reported employees. That's a lot of people to lose, so where did they go? Are they real, imagined or test subjects on an alien vessel?

Sixth, use the money you have wisely. Be fiscally responsible, not irresponsible. I find it inconceivable and suspicious that estimations could be so far off and so many times wrong. Curriculums do not need to be updated every two to three years, particularly for kindergarten and first grade where there is no great and new body of knowledge to be taught or learned. Is the money spent on all the electronic gadgets and gizmos required for students to learn? How many Blackberrys does CCSD pay for? Do we need Picasso, Bus Radios, GPS units, etc.?

Alan Faircloth
Kennesaw
Comments
(31)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
CobbOak
|
June 07, 2010
Please help Oakwood High School continue to serve Cobb County Students!

Last Chance, unless you decide to sue because of their violation of due process:

6/9 CCSD Board Meeting

Public Comments - 7:30 AM sign in to speak

Board Meeting, comments - 8:30 AM

514 Glover St. Marietta, Georgia 30080

(Legal Adoption of the FY2011 Budget at Regular Board Meeting)
Harry Jones
|
April 16, 2010
He doesn't know what he's talking about!
A taxpayer
|
April 15, 2010
I looked on the county's site and I can't find the place that shows the assistant area supers -- where is it, or do they actually exist? Things are bad enough without you having to make up stuff. Focus on reality, please.
Alan Faircloth
|
April 15, 2010
When the info from CCSD keeps changing...it is hard to remain correct. I remember when the budget shortfall was $58 million. Now it is $137 million. Now there's change you can believe in, right? How about the cell tower and calendar and other things.....LCE and Cash...WE HAVE EMAILS...oops, no we don't; Cell Tower WILL NOT be placed on agenda...oops, yes it will. I could go on with the list of lies and misinformation from CCSD, but there is not enough time, space, ink, paper and stamina from readers to finish it.
a mom
|
April 15, 2010
The administration is constantly pushing down ultimatiums to the teachers. The teachers are currently overloaded and in need of assistance in the classroom. They look to the parents for assistance. However, a particular elementary school has recently tried to inact a 45 time limit for each parent to be in the school, per day. They might work for a parent of an only child, but what about a parent that ususally helps two classes, two days a week for an hour each? Do you expect that parent to choose which class they will help? This is not to mention that 98% of the parents are unwilling to come in an do the time consuming task to prep for projects or when they do volunteer to come in it is to assist with an event and just stand around.
A teacher
|
April 15, 2010
Again, it boils down to teachers and students. That's what education is all about... not the other.

Some of you may be right that you can't make the entire budget cut with other things?? But I know one thing for certain--- when you are making budget cuts of this demand, you better make them in an orderly fashion. And that does not mean cut teachers and then spend thousands on phones, guest speakers, LA adoption, ELL adoptions and more.

Teachers are the very last thing that should be cut for that is who actually touches the students.

Again, I think Mr. Faircloth did an excellent job of bringing up points that many haven't considered. It may not solve the problem of the budget, however it does bring up major spending problems. It also brings to light issues with trust.
Again, AFIF
|
April 15, 2010
There are no Area Supts and Area Assistant Supts. This is what I mean by AF doesn't know what he is talking about!
Tired of it
|
April 14, 2010
Alan.. Thank you for all your insightful comments!! Being a member of ccsd you have missed out on some employees of ccsd such as the mechanics of fleet maintenance(school bus mechanics) and our maintenance dept. who do a great job maintaining the schools and the grounds! Human resources,Payroll dept.
Tired of it
|
April 14, 2010
To Pete v...the answer is yes! They get it all!! and the 12 month employee only get 13 holidays a year and we know that is more than the general public gets but that's the rule and I'm not complaining.3 personal days and sick time can acrue up to over 900 hours.That said, our new management team at fleet maintenance wants to pave the parking lot for 350 buses at south cobb shop and the other 3 shops also.NOT NECESSARY IN A BUDGET CRUNCH WHEN SANDERSON WANTS TO LET GO OF 200 DRIVERS!Save the drivers and forget the lot!!
Alan Faircloth
|
April 14, 2010
I agree with Cut the Area Supers....In looking at CCSD's organizational structure, it seems the order of the day is that everyone needs an assisstant or associate. I was amazed by the number of titles that had one of these words in them. It became laughable when I saw that Area Supers needed Asst. Area Supers.....
anonymous
|
April 14, 2010
Hey Cut the Area Supers- You have to remember that there are what, about 900 buses running each day. Those are employees. Who fixes things? Maintenance and fleet maintenance to keep buses running and schools fully functional. I would guess that is a couple hundred employees. What about all those wonderful tech items? Someone has to be ready to fix those since teachers can not teach with a blackboard and books anymore. Does someone deliver mail and supplies to all the schools every day? That is probably a few people every day as well. Custodians? You may want to check your numbers. I think some high schools have 10-12 There are a lot of support personnel that are needed everyday, people just do not put those in the picture when they are looking at it. Schools do not magically work on their own. Are there non-personnel areas to look at? Absolutely. Are there some positions out there that could be outsourced or done away with? Absolutely.
Cut the Area Supers
|
April 13, 2010
You can eliminat the 6 Area Supers with their average $116K salary, their admin assitants, their cars, their perks, their bonuses and their benefits and save the district $1M overnight. If nothing else, it will send a message to all that the central office/ivory tower is willing to do what it takes across the board and save teacher jobs where and when possible.

BTW ... how can there be more non-teach employees in the system in the first place? Look at the typical roster of employees at a school, 80-90 teachers, 8-9 lunch ladies, 4 custodians, 2 librians, 3 admins, 4 assist principals and one principal. That adds up to a better than 3 to 1 ration of teachers to staff. Where are all of these other people on the payroll? How are they contributing DAILY to the educaiton of the students?
Pete V
|
April 13, 2010
A question:

Do "full time" employees - principals, those in central office... - get all the breaks that the teachers get during the school year. i.e. - thanksgiving week, 2 weeks at Christmas, spring break...

Do these "full time" employees get all the holidays off too? Presidents day, MLK day...

How many additional "vacation" days and sick days do they get?

I'm just wondering how many more days - these "full time" employees work over the teachers.

As I look at the salaries of all these Supers and assist supers and see that many are at or over $80,000 - $100,000 I'm wondering exactly how many days these people work.

Maybe the reason we have so many employees at central office is because none really work "full time" at all.

I don't really know - could someone tell me?
Not Retired
|
April 12, 2010
If you did not want to retire then you should not have. It is wrong to take away income from a young teacher when retirees are double dipping. If we force all these young teachers out and keep all the retirees.....we will lose a whole generation of teachers. Don't be selfish retired teachers.
Curious One
|
April 12, 2010
The Cobb School District pays $2 million in legal fees to Brock and Clay - cut that in half to say $1 million and go down from there !
Harry Jones
|
April 12, 2010
Well said, Big D.

AF is on the outside and making HUGE assumptions!
anonymous
|
April 12, 2010
The GPS devices will assist with payroll, in my understanding, by accurately recording start and end time vs a manual honor system. Maintenance will be able to locate the closest person that can help with an emergency vs a radio blast to everyone. It is not a tool to target people, it is a tool to manage and automate the business. Transportation can use it to back up their work, like when a person calls and complains their bus did not come by the house, was late, or in a place did something wrong. They will know precisely when the bus was at a specific time, that is liability mitigation. Those that complain are those abusing the system. It is the board's responsibility to use whatever tools that are available to manage costs, just like any business. If you had to manage 1000 people, do you want to do it without help and use an honor system?
Alan Faircloth
|
April 12, 2010
First, to AFIF, rather than generally aver to unspecified inaccuracies, provide the correct data, include a source for it so it can be verified, and then give us non-insiders a way to evaluate your expertise so as to make a credibility assessment. Second, I never said that cuts at the top would address the budget problems. However, there is a problem when rank and file employees that are the real backbone of the system suffer salary/benefit cuts and furloughs and employees above a certain level do not or actually receive increases (all verifiable if anyone will take the time to look). Third, GPS units are an unnecessary item. The concerns that CCSD has with bus drivers can be resolved through other non or less costly means. Plus, if the GPS units were intended to simply help paint targets on potential subjects for firing, that is wrong and should be opposed outright. GPS won't solve Grisham's inability to manage people. Finally, they need to modify the acronym SPLOST because it is no longer Special Purpose and it absolutely isn't limited. I suggest LOST...Long term Optionless Sales Tax.
ForceFed
|
April 12, 2010
Do your math again, Alan. The CCSD employee count certainly adds up to 15,211.
retired teacher
|
April 12, 2010
First of all, the county saves money on retirees who teach 49%. They get more classtime and pay no benefits for these employees. Just the lack of benefit package saves the county thousands on each of these employees.
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.