Cobb lawmakers divided over cigarette tax hike bill
by Jon Gillooly
jgillooly@mdjonline.com
March 20, 2010 01:00 AM | 1861 views | 13 13 comments | 12 12 recommendations | email to a friend | print
ATLANTA - Cobb legislators are divided over a bill that would raise the state tax on cigarettes by a dollar per pack, from the current $0.37 to $1.37.

House Bill 39 is sponsored by Rep. Ron Stephens (R-Savannah), who says it would raise an estimated $350 million in new state taxes and attract another billion dollars in federal health care funds to Georgia. Stephens says Georgia's existing cigarette tax, the fifth lowest in the nation, generates about $237 million a year, but Georgia spends $537 million a year treating smoking-related illnesses in Medicaid patients alone. That means taxpayers are subsidizing the medical costs for smokers to the tune of $300 million a year. The last time the tobacco tax was raised was in 2003, when the state bumped it from $0.12 a pack to the current $0.37, he said.

Wellstar Health System supports the tax hike, taking out ads to urge voters to lobby their legislators in favor of the proposal.

Of Cobb's 14 state representatives, six say they support the tax increase. Those are Judy Manning (R-Marietta), Alisha Thomas Morgan (D-Austell), Sheila Jones (D-South Cobb), Terry Johnson (D-Marietta), Sharon Cooper (R-east Cobb) and Don Parsons (R-east Cobb).

Cooper, a registered nurse, speaks grimly of what smoking can do.

"I have held people's hands as they've died gasping for breath, and it's one of the most horrible deaths you can think of," she said.

Manning said the tax increase won't fill the budget shortfall, but it will help. Manning said while she is not a fan of raising taxes, smoking is a choice and Georgians can choose not to smoke, and not pay the tax.

Parsons said he supports the tax because the state's hospitals are going to take a significant financial hit from additional taxes or loss of their sales tax exemption.

"Yes, I support raising the cigarette tax to make it less difficult on our hospitals and all of us who need them," he said.

Jones said she is also supportive of the tax due to her concern about the proposed tax to be levied on hospitals to cover the state's budget shortfalls.

"I am alarmed by the number of health care employees (that) proposal may affect. While the increase of taxes should always be undertaken with great caution, raising the tobacco tax is a superior option, as well as having the beneficial effect of reducing the rate of smoking in Georgia," she said.

Three of Cobb's state representatives, Earl Ehrhart (R-Powder Springs), Ed Setzler (R-Acworth) and Matt Dollar (R-east Cobb), say they oppose the proposed cigarette tax increase. Ehrhart says it's not a dependable source of revenue since every time the tax is increased it brings in fewer dollars.

"It's a market-based equation. If you can buy it cheaper somewhere else, they will," Ehrhart said.

As for the health argument, Ehrhart said if the Legislature was truly interested in stopping teen smoking, it would have approved a bill he and state Sen. John Wiles (R-Kennesaw) pushed a decade ago that would have taken away a teen's driver's license for smoking.

Four Cobb state representatives say they haven't made up their minds about the bill, among them Rich Golick (R-Smyrna), Rob Teilhet (D-Smyrna), Pat Dooley (D-Marietta) and Don Wix (D-Mableton).

Dooley says while she's leaning in favor of the tax, she wants the General Assembly to examine the numerous tax exemptions given out first.

State Rep. Bobby Franklin (R-east Cobb) did not respond by press time.

Of Cobb's five state senators, three say they oppose the bill, among Judson Hill (R-east Cobb), John Wiles (R-Kennesaw) and Steve Thompson (D-Powder Springs).

"In this tough economic time for all Georgia citizens, I do not think tax increases of any kind are warranted," Wiles said.

"I believe that we must continue to reduce government spending and not attempt to increase revenues by general tax increases. I therefore do not plan to support a tax increase on cigarettes," Wiles said.

Hill said he would always oppose any legislation that increases taxes, while Doug Stoner (D-Smyrna) and Chip Rogers (R-North Cobb) say they're undecided about the bill.
Comments
(13)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
tlynn0156
|
May 12, 2010
Enforce the law and deport the illegals in this State. Across the Country, they have depleted our tax dollars to the point of massive budget shortfalls. How many illegal aliens are in the school systems? There's at least one at KSU! Punishing the legal citizens of Georgia, those of which pay the lion's share of taxes, does not make sense. Deporting those who CHOOSE to break our laws would not only save millions of dollars, but free up jobs which I think by now, not one unemployed person would mind doing.
Smilingmonkey88
|
March 24, 2010
I agree with a lot of the comments. I am a smoker and don't necessarily oppose another increase in the tax.. however, there are also a lot of other things in society that are bad for a person and raises medical bills that should also be taxed. Why is smoking always the tax that is raised? If we need money that badly raise the tax across the board.. that way smokers aren't just singled out and it won't be drastically raised. We can still get a lot of money by a slight raise in many things than a drastic raise in one.
Mike Jones
|
March 22, 2010
Who does the Goverment think they are kidding? You are going to raise taxes so you don't have to cut spending. Give me break... What's next, a tax on ammo, or sugary soft drinks? Typical RINO's... You say you are "anti-tax" right up until the point of running out of money, then you decide to tax something..
lockheed widow
|
March 22, 2010
representative? - who died and made you the spokesman for everyone in Rep. Wiley's district. What makes you think that you can speak for everyone in your district. You sound like a liberal dem who says whatever they want and believe people will just accept it. You all have a way of trying to make people believe you are speaking for the masses, when it is only your own little bias and discrimination against a group that is coming out. You fool, you say you have already decided to vote for Tippens - why should Wiley even listen to you.
IndianJoe
|
March 22, 2010
ou people make me sick - raise taxes as long as it doesn't have any influence on you. Why not say that there will be a surtax n every family who has more than 2 children - or anyone on Medicaid or welfare who has more children will be dropped from the roles, or anyone more than 10 pounds overweight will paid $100.00 more per pound every year on their taxes. It is amazing how evryone wants to tax someone else's pleasures. So when the price is increased $1.00 per pack and half the peoplel quit, you won't get t he $1. or the .37 now collected. Let's tax everything an extra dollar which contains sugar, tranfats, chocolate. How about chewing tobacco and cigars. Or how about this, let's just send all of our money to the various governments, let them divide it up between themselves and send back what they think we should be allowed to keep. Problem solved- and everyone pays equally. Yes, I have seen people die from smoking illnesses, and have also seen people die of old age (well into their 90's) who have smoked all their lives), have also seen people die as a result of drunk drivers, accidents, malnutrition, lack of being able to afford medicine, and some pretty outdated laws which say who can and who cannot receive tansplants. But let's just pile on this one segment - and incidentally, I DON'T smoke, but believe fair is fair. Let's look at the cost of treating smoking illnesses as compared to illness causedby obesity - so let's tax all of the fat people - fat being what the government considers fat. Let's also tax all of the cable channels and movies which promote sex - leads to STD's, pregnancy, etc which also cost us a lot of money. The list is endless, who has some others?
ATF
|
March 21, 2010
I would like to urge Matt Dollar and Judson Hill to support this increase in cigarette taxes.

It raises revenue. Income from the tax should be used to pay for health care for Georgians.

It doesn't matter if it will drive some people to another state to buy cigarettes. Yes, it will happen but those who live in any place other than a border town are not going to go to the trouble.

Raise the tax. Who are we protecting?

Peggyspickens
|
March 21, 2010
Has anyone ever thought of raising the beer and alcohol tax. Seems a better option. Too many completely innocent people, very young and very old, are killed in alcohol related accidents.
CommonSense336
|
March 20, 2010
Every congressman should pass the bill! Get a grip...teachers are losing their jobs, education is already in shambles, and poverty is on the rise. Do something good for our state and cut the political posturing!
anonymous
|
March 20, 2010
For heaven's sake, raise the tax and quit playing concerned politician. We need the money and this is a good way to get some. While you're at it, raise the alcohol tax and the movie tax.
Pufferfish
|
March 20, 2010
Look - people who smoke die 10 years earlier than they would if they didn't smoke, saving the taxpayers a bundle in long term medical care. You want to really collect some tax money, increase taxes on french frys and milkshakes being sucked down by all the balloon butts.
representative?
|
March 20, 2010
Hey Wiles, try representing your contituents for once, did you ever think that we (majority) embrace the idea of a cigarette tax. Since you don't represent anyone but your pious self, maybe Lindsey Tippins will listen. He's already got my vote!
SouthernGal
|
March 20, 2010
Not only raise the tax on all tobacco products need to also include:

Candy, potato chips,beer, wine, liquor, sugary soft drinks and any item deemed unhealthy for human consumption.

Add a tax to those who participate in dangerous sports...mountain climbing, parachuting, motorcycling, football etc.
Frankie58
|
March 20, 2010
..."Cooper, a registered nurse, speaks grimly of what smoking can do.

"I have held people's hands as they've died gasping for breath, and it's one of the most horrible deaths you can think of," she said."... and MS. Cooper I have held the hand of a man that died from a disease as horrible and as lengthy as smoking related diseases, Sclerosis of the liver, and we buried my Uncle three days later! Alcohol is catching up to tobacco in terms of "costs" real quick.

*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.