Crooks to appeal judge's ruling on recall campaign
by Kathryn Dobies
kdobies@mdjonline.com
March 13, 2010 01:00 AM | 1205 views | 15 15 comments | 15 15 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA - Cobb County School Board member Dr. John Crooks said Friday that he will appeal a judge's ruling that authorized a recall campaign against Crooks to proceed.

In a statement to the Journal, Crooks said he believes there are several legal errors in Judge Walter Matthews' ruling and that he and his legal team from FSB Legal Counsel will appeal to the Georgia Supreme Court.

"We, me and my legal team, respectfully believe that the judge's remaining order may create a dangerous precedent by allowing school board members and other elected officials to be subjected to recall proceedings simply for making motions in open, public meetings in which the board's lawyer was present and he did not raise any objections to the motion." Crooks said.

"We also believe that there are a number of legal errors in the order, and that there was insufficient evidence to allow the recall to move forward. We are looking forward to the opportunity to address these issues before the Supreme Court."

On Tuesday, Matthews found that the facts set forth by east Cobb parent Carrie Nicholas-Welkis are sufficient to constitute a recall, based on the grievances of intent to mislead the public, just one of the grounds Nicholas-Welkis set forth in her petition to recall the board member.

Following the judge's ruling on Tuesday, Crooks said he was disappointed with the ruling, but thought the "judge was correct in dismissing three of the four allegations because they were not supported by the facts."

In a hearing last week regarding the recall efforts, Crooks denied purposely misleading the public by not giving proper notice that the cell tower item was placed on the July 23 school board meeting agenda. Crooks did, however, admit to saying that notifying the public of the item "would have probably caused a circus," a quote that was printed in the Marietta Daily Journal on Aug. 14.

Last July, Crooks called for a vote to allow a 150-foot cell tower at Eastvalley Elementary School, a proposal many parents and residents opposed as an unwanted and unsafe eyesore. Crooks placed the cell tower matter on the board's agenda the day of the July meeting without advance notice. Several families then filed suit against the school district, arguing that the board violated state Open Meetings Act by failing to give proper advance notice on the vote.

Cobb Superior Court issued a temporary restraining order against the board, halting any work from being done on the tower, but then Crooks called for second vote on the tower in October. This time it was advertised on the agenda in advance, and the board approved the tower.
Comments
(15)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Cobb County Watch
|
March 15, 2010
Something that made me chuckle: I googled John Crooks and ended up on his campaign website. According to the site, he entered the race due to the lack of an "open and fair governmental process" and because the board had "detached itself from the public, doing instead, whatever it decided."

Heh. Talk about spewing hot air just to get elected.
Defend this
|
March 14, 2010
So Crooks wants to be the hero of lying politicians everywhere lest they become victims of voters that are fed up 'intent to deceive the public' lying politicians like himself. Crooks, please don't take the money the taxpayers give to the kids for this noxious cause.
anonymousfriend
|
March 14, 2010
I am a friend, too. Give it up, John.
DearJohnny
|
March 14, 2010
Dr. Crooks is taking his arrogance all the way to the Georgia Supreme Court. The judge told him "no", but boy scout Johnny doesn't like it (such poor representation for a such a wonderful organization). JC does not like it when he is told that he is wrong. Johnny...did you not take your ADHD medication (again) when the judge ruled? We know that you think that you are above law, and always have to have the last word...

REPEAT: He said "no" to you. Now you can see just how powerful those East Cobb mommies are. You tried to please them, messed up, and now they are having you for lunch. You should have learned your lesson a long time ago. It is one thing to represent your constituents, but kissing up to people can be very dangerous. You never did what was best for students in the first place. So sad!

At this point: You should be worried about damage control. Save your tainted reputation while you still can. People that befriended you in the past are running far, far away!
Watcher...
|
March 13, 2010
The legal costs of Dr. Crooks MUST be born by Dr. Crooks!

against the stream
|
March 13, 2010
Bite by bite, chomp by chomp, we, as a public force will go after the whole lot of them until we successfully purge the school system of the very board members who don’t listen to who actually put them in office, rid the school and administrative staff who are incompetent “yes sir” ninnies for the board, fire the board’s inept legal team, and last but not least, run good old Fred on a rail.
please go away
|
March 13, 2010
Crooks can not represent the East Cobb parents and students in any meaningful way while he is arguing about keeping his seat for what amounts to the end of the year.

HE MUST RESIGN.

Crowder-Eagle is too stupid to ask him to resign.

He is too egotistical to resign on his own.

And both of them are screwing over the East Cobb parents and students.

He Must Resign.

Let's start the call right now - and over and over again. Step Down Crooks.

If he walks out now we get to choose our representative. If he drags his feet the board gets to appoint someone for the rest of his term.

How good a choice do you think they will make for us?

The would love Crooks to stay on because they can make their budget cuts at our expense.

We need an advocate. Not a self absorbed political hack.

Step down now.

Bury his office in requests for him to step down now.

Bury Crowder Eagle's office in the same request.

It's time for the MDJ to lead the charge and ask him to step down.

http://www.cobbk12.org/board/

This link takes you to all of their emails.

Step Down John. Put it in the subject line.

Step Down John.

Go spend time with your hair. Or your family. Or your ego.

But go away. Now.
East Cobber
|
March 13, 2010
So, Dr. Crooks said he was not going to run for reelection, so what is the purpose of the appeal. Oh wait, it's EGO, just like the other members of the CSB. Out with all of them...
Good Sheppard
|
March 13, 2010
Yes Rev. Crooks, this may set a precedent for recalling other politicians when two different judges have determined that the lying politician broke the law and "intended to deceive the public." Isn't that the precedent that actual Reverends would want set in our community? Are you planning to make the taxpayers pay for your slimy defense of a politician's right to lie to constituents?
anonymous
|
March 13, 2010
John, please give it up and resign already. I once considered myself a friendly acquaintance of yours. The way you have handled the school board has made me want to stay a mile away from you. It's embarassing to you, your friends and your family. Please resign and put it behind you and us.
littled
|
March 13, 2010
Crooks should let his legal team speak for him; and we all know how competent the Brock legal advice is during these board meetings.
Cobb Taxpayer
|
March 13, 2010
So, Reverend Crooks' argument to the State Supreme Court is that 2 million a dollar a year legal counsel, Glen Brock, is incompetent in providing legal counsel to the school board - sounds like the good Reverend Crooks needs to share this revelation with the state bar ?
John Gerbil
|
March 13, 2010
Reverend Crooks do the right thing and step down from the school board. The truth shall set you free.
RayRay3
|
March 13, 2010
The esteemed Dr Crooks said> "me and my legal team"....

Are you kidding me? ME and my legal team.....

A board member who cannot speak proper English!!!
Frankie58
|
March 13, 2010
OK, I'll bite, who is going to pay for this appeal? Second, why is so hard for these board members to understand that the law says "reasonable advance notice on agenda items", this doesn't mean 5 minutes either....
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.