Cliff Johnson: Teen drinking story shows need for fair treatment
by Cliff Johnson
Guest Columnist
March 12, 2010 01:00 AM | 1093 views | 3 3 comments | 10 10 recommendations | email to a friend | print
It's not really tough to figure out, is it, armed with nothing more than common sense? As the incendiary debated raged over affluent teens going unpunished for a recent drinking party in Cobb, the not-so-white elephant in the room sits silent, as always, unnoticed and unimportant in the corner. It's not pompous parents behind exclusive communities that cost us in Cobb. It's juvey hall, get it? But not because affluent youths or parents who are judges act any better or more moral. It's not who we let get away with it that costs us dearly, it's who we punish and why.

It's long been known through ad hoc studies and incarceration counts that a disproportionate number of our community's at-risk, minority youth population get arrested by local cops patrolling easy streets instead of busting dangerous burglars, because they are easy targets, while affluent kids and parents hide the same alcohol and marijuana use in nicer neighborhoods and only hit the papers when summoned to a well-known house.

There's a huge elephant in the corner of Cobb County, as with most, going unnoticed, while this pointless Cobb Teen Drinking Party story reaction rages. The elephant that we won't deal with is this - Georgia's juvey halls are bursting with troubled teens, overwhelming the system. So is Georgia's prison system. The populations incarcerated for substance related charges are above 20 percent; the population is growing exponentially, but the tax base to pay for all this so-called moral incarceration is not growing. It's eating up more and more of your paycheck each year.

The system is broken, because we bust disproportionate at-risk youth of color, black and Latinos, who then enter a system and emerge having been exposed to adult criminals ready to take them in and who now have a record and a blight on their self-concept. You can change a juvey record, but a self-concept is a fragile thing. It's no small coincidence, in fact its causal, that kids busted and spending time in juvey hall have a much higher propensity to become adult criminals, for these reasons and more. So say social work agency studies across the spectrum.

So, if you want to reduce your taxes, reduce Georgia's overcrowded prisons, juvey hall, and overwhelmed, underfunded social work safety net system for at-risk kids in Cobb who see violence and trauma and look for alcohol to self-medicate a bleak future - then stop worrying about what happens to rich kids in Cobb and start worrying about what happens to the poorest kids in Cobb, who are busted more often, with worse penalties and worse outcomes.

So let's not let this event and opportunity go by without framing the debate for public utility - namely, how to stop targeting our at-risk youth for juvenile justice, in order to reduce the growing need for social services, and thus reduce tomorrow's prison population, and the needs for more and more of your tax dollars to house today's victims, which uncared for, will become tomorrow's predators. Instead of three strikes and you're out, how about one strike means we need to care more?

Think of the energy spent by Cobb citizens on this story, wanting somebody to pay - when they are the ones paying the biggest tax price, for that attitude.

Believe me, the affluent teen drinkers will learn their own lessons much too late, when their special privileges run out and meet up with life.

Meanwhile, let's use this event to help those children without special privileges being targeted every day for arrest unfairly. Give them the chance to do better without a record that we give affluent kids every day. Put the focus back on fair crime and punishment, and you instantly relieve the burden on Cobb's social services safety net, to improve youth, reduce teen depression and suicide and reduce dropout rates.

Give the right people a break for once!

Cliff Johnson is enrolled as a master's candidate at UGA's School of Social Work. He has worked with at-risk, traumatized youth, recently incarcerated homeless populations, and social service agencies to study Georgia's mental health system, from metro hospitals to indigent care throughout Atlanta.
Comments
(3)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Vyper3000
|
October 12, 2010
This is one more reason for the problems we have: yet another future social worker who has no more idea than a goose what is wrong - but he's sure that it is that the "disadvantaged kids" are being unfairly targeted. Here's a revalation: they aren't being unfairly targeted: they are being CAUGHT. What he SHOULD be arguing for is that the affluent white kids - if they are, in fact, affluent - be given the same treatment as everyone else.
West Cobb Mom
|
March 12, 2010
One more time- listen

The issue never was about the kids, it was about the adults that tried to intimidate the police, bury the story and get everyone involved off.

I think those of you that keep trying to bring this back to the kids must have something to hide.

Were these adults your friends perhaps, you sound awfully defensive!
WestCobbertoo
|
March 12, 2010
Just a question - with the debate over the Walker School students going on for weeks, no article failing to mention that they were Walker students why is the media so silent all of a sudden on the "drug" incident with MHS? Guess this is not such a hot issue because these kids obviously aren't the elite from toney snobbish neighborhoods who attend private school
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.