The School Board
March 10, 2010 01:00 AM | 2015 views | 12 12 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
THOSE IN CHARGE of the Cobb school system have proven many times over that they don't listen to parents, don't listen to teachers, don't listen to bus drivers, don't listen to taxpayers and don't listen to their constituents. The question now is, "Will they listen to the county grand jury?" Don't hold your breath.

The jury's presentments announced Thursday hammered the system hard, describing "a serious need for a culture change, starting with the top management of the transportation department at the South Cobb Bus Shop." The jury listed 16 "serious issues/bad management practices," among them poor record keeping, lack of work instructions for mechanics, lack of a defect analysis being performed, unsafe lifts in the mechanics shops and school-bus fire extinguishers that were missing pins or low on chemicals.

And validating the allegations raised by MDJ columnist Laura Armstrong in recent months, the jury noted "the drivers and mechanics work in an environment of intimidation and 'virtual fear' of losing their jobs - it is palpable and we heard and saw it time and time again."

That jury presentments came on the heels of the January presentments, which sternly admonished the school board for limiting public debate and making policy decisions behind closed doors. The earlier presentments came as a shock - but if anything the latest round is even more damning of the system's poor management.

Truly, why was it left to the grand jury to investigate the poor operation of the transportation department? Why didn't the school board order its own internal probe after so many credible allegations were raised by Armstrong and by the myriad of bloggers who commented on them? Where there was that much smoke, there had to be fire.

Instead, the board complacently swallowed Superintendent Fred Sanderson's platitudes about how all was well. And new school board Chairwoman Lynnda Crowder-Eagle improbably chose "teamwork" as the topic of the board's winter retreat. Even though the central office is within a 10-minute walk of the bus barn on South Cobb Drive, the Transportation Department might as well have been deep in the Okefenokee for all the interest the board and Sanderson showed in its proper operation.

We're tempted to suggest that this school board has all the curiosity of a brain-dead amoeba - but that would be a disservice to all the amoebas out there.

***

UNFORTUNATELY, the grand jury story was not the only school-related story that emanated from the courthouse last week. There was also the hearing into the grassroots effort to recall board member Dr. John Crooks for his role in sneaking a proposal to erect a controversial cell tower at Eastvalley Elementary School onto the board's agenda without public notice, a clear violation of the state's Sunshine Laws, to say nothing of the "Golden Rule" about doing unto others as you would have them do unto you. Last week's hearing saw Crooks deploy a hair-splitting rationale worthy of Bill "the meaning of 'is'" Clinton in a lame attempt to justify why he acted as he did. The truth is that he and a majority of the board again relied on bad advice from their attorney Glenn Brock about the Sunshine laws, which is a simple law grounded in basic fairness and the Golden Rule.

And Friday saw a meeting between the lawyers and judge in the "Astroturf" suit brought by an opponent of the system's plans to spend up to $11 million of SPLOST funds to install artificial turf on high school football fields. At issue is whether such spending qualifies as a legitimate educational purpose under the SPLOST law. Yet credible reports indicate Brock told the board before the SPLOST vote that it does not, but that the board insisted on including it in the plan in order to sway the votes of athletic booster club members.

There also are reports that attorney Tom Harper warned Brock he would sue the system to try to stop the SPLOST spending on the turf, which he now has done. If that were the case, why did the board not resolve the matter by putting out its RFPs for the turf sooner, so that the project could already have been under way in time for football season?

***

WE'LL CLOSE with a pair of quotes. The first is from the latest grand jury presentments: "It is high time that the school board and all levels of management below them hear and understand this. To allow this atmosphere to continue unabated is the grossest form of mismanagement."

The second is from the Georgia Constitution: "All school systems are to be under the management and control of the board of education."

Unfortunately, the Cobb school board deserves a failing grade for its management of the school system and the superintendent. In fact, as we have noted here before, the Cobb board seems to be under the management and control of the superintendent, instead of the other way around.

Will the board and superintendent laugh off this latest public paddling by the grand jury like it did the first round of presentments? Or will they finally listen - and act?
Comments
(12)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Big D to Just Me
|
March 15, 2010
Nope. I'm neither from West Cobb nor East Cobb. The data about students' performance that I cited was taken from district-wide results. I know of plenty of success stories from S. Cobb HS, Pebblebrook, etc.. Plenty of problems also exist across the district. But, the students prevail anyway.

As I said before, they score higher than state and national averages "across the board"!!!
tired of it
|
March 13, 2010
Another Grand Jury has been assembled and I can't wait to hear from what they find! OH no...this isn't over yet!!
just tired of it
|
March 12, 2010
It all boils down to saving money due to the economy! Rick and Mike are doing what it takes to save money and are willing to sacrifice the safety and well being of the buses to save it!!! We are not hauling blue jeans here but children!!!! My 3 children ride and I hope that their buses are are being cared for to the best that our mechanics can do!Do you want to save MONEY or have SAFE BUSES???
Just me
|
March 12, 2010
To: Big D,

you must live in East or West Cobb. Check your entire school system. Even South Cobb who has a magnet program is falling behind. Look at Pebblebrook, Campbell (Campbell has an IB program.). Along with Griffin,Cooper,Floyd and Campbell Middle. Across the board our students deserve the best education out there. I assure you there is no chip on my shoulder. I do pay close attention to the antics of this school board.
They Listened to me
|
March 11, 2010
Hey Alan!

Wow, you think I'm that kind of bigwig? No way!

Not a CCSD employee; Not a Gala attendee; not Lindsay Tippens, nope none of the above.

I am a Cobb native, graduated from Cobb schools in the 1970's, married with three kids, all graduated from Cobb schools.

Run my famiy business and just work hard at being a good person.

I'll admit that Laura Searcy had a hard time listening to folks, but otherwise, it has not been a problem at all over 22 years of parenting my children through three elementary schools, two middle schools and one high school.

Maybe I'm just a nice person, who asks politely and people just seem to like.

Maybe some of you who whine so much should just try good old fashioned southern manners. Like my Mother always told me, being polite and showing respect to your others will take you far.

Hey Alan, why don't you try that for a change instead of villifying these dedicated public servants duly elected by the citizens of the county to represent the best interests of their districts.
Alan Faircloth
|
March 11, 2010
To Just Listened to me....if we knew who you are, that might explain why they listened to you. The Board hears just fine, but they only listen to those they want to. Perhaps you are one of the District employees at Glover or one of the Gala attendees or Lindsey Tippins. These are people they might listen to.....rather than voters and constituents. I think you've got your minority/majority grouping mixed up.
Pffffft
|
March 10, 2010
The Board already thumbed it's collective nose at those know-nothing, no power grand juries. They could care less what is said. It will be business as usual (ignoring what is right for what is inept) for the CCSB.
Big D
|
March 10, 2010
To Just me: I don't know where you have gotten the misconception of "... our students are still failing..." YOU COULDN'T BE FARTHER FROM THE TRUTH ON THIS ONE!!!! Our students CONSISTENTLY score higher than students across Georgia and across the nation!!

If you've got a chip on your shoulder with the Board, let 'em have it. But DON'T demean our students' achievements or the teachers who guided them there. As the saying goes, "you've got a right to your opinion, but not your own facts."

just me
|
March 10, 2010
To, they listened to me: You must have had a problem that was minor and did not need any thought behind it. My BOE will not listen until the Grand Jury gets involved and still they turn deaf ears. Do you not read the papers(MDJ and ATL. Const.) or watch the news? Cobb has been in the negative for over 2 years. Our students are still failing and the county is still spending money on things we don't need. Wake up.
Obvious
|
March 10, 2010
Obviously I am in that small minority along with many judges, juries, grand juries, employees and taxpayers who think this school board is the worst ever and going down hill daily. The MDJ reports facts, such as police reports, surveys and such and does listen to citizens. Thank you, MDJ.
They listened to me
|
March 10, 2010
Just because a small vocal minority perceive that the School Board members don't agree with their issue du jour, that doesn't mean that the board members don't listen and heed the desires of the voters.

They do listen to the voters! They listen to me and others like me who don't agree with the vocal minortiy who make news for this newpaper to publish.

Very simple.
Hilly Dean
|
March 10, 2010
Why didn't the school board order its own internal probe after so many credible allegations were raised by Armstrong and by the myriad of bloggers who commented on them?

BECAUSE THEY ARE BLOGGERS, YOU NITWIT! Who in their right mind would listen to them?
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.