Phil Gingrey: Health care summit a good photo op, but that's all
by Phil Gingrey
Guest Columnist
March 04, 2010 01:00 AM | 883 views | 14 14 comments | 5 5 recommendations | email to a friend | print
For the last year, Democrats in Congress have debated how to reform our health care system in the United States. Over and over again, we have heard how a massive government takeover of our health care system will be "better" for us, that having federal bureaucrats make the decision about what care we receive will ensure we get better results. The only problem for Democrats is quite simply Americans don't want this type of health care reform. In fact, the polls are remarkably clear: 73 percent of Americans think that Congress should start over on health care reform or do nothing, rather than pass the Pelosi-Reid plan.

I had the privilege of practicing medicine in Georgia for nearly 30 years. I have firsthand knowledge of the highs, and the lows, of health care. I firmly believe we can improve health care for every American - making it more affordable, easier to access and of a higher quality. But I know, and you know, the Democrats have not found the right solution, particularly since their solutions have been negotiated behind closed doors, out of the view of Republicans and Americans.

I was hopeful that the bipartisan health care summit at the Blair House on February 25 would have offered House and Senate leaders of both parties the opportunity to start over and make real progress.

Rather, it was more of the same, with Democrats refusing to abandon their goal of a government health care takeover or, for the most part, even acknowledge that Republicans have substantive ideas. It was a day of each side making statements, but a refusal on the part of Democrats to restart the debate on health care.

The president's latest health care plan, and what Democratic leaders continue to push, is the same big-government scheme that the American people have overwhelmingly rejected. It will increase government spending, raise taxes, kill jobs and allow taxpayer funding of abortion.

In addition, what is most unfortunate is that this singular focus by the president on health care has had some disastrous consequences for the rest of our nation. Since last February, when the Democrat's trillion-dollar stimulus was signed into law, more than three million jobs have been lost in this country and unemployment is near a record 10 percent. In Georgia, we have lost more than 130,000 jobs. While trying to ram through a massive government health care takeover - which will raise taxes and kill jobs - the Democrats have pursued policies that have had a chilling effect on our economy.

Democratic Sen. Chris Dodd has said that 14,000 Americans lose their health care insurance every day. Unfortunately, much of this is because of unemployment. Therefore, instead of having tunnel vision on health care - and particularly on a bill that will make our economy worse - we need to re-prioritize our efforts and get Americans back to work.

If Democrats are serious about bipartisanship, we must start from scratch. Unfortunately, that does not look like the path they want to pursue. Democratic leaders are plotting a strategy to abuse the rules of the Senate and overturn the will of the American people using the reconciliation process - meant for deficit reduction bills - to try and pass the Senate health care bill. Using this method would ensure that they only need to get 51 votes in the Senate instead of 60, which would be required to pass the bill by regular order.

Additionally, it appears the only concessions Democrats are willing to make would be relatively meaningless, designed to garner a few more Democratic votes in the House and Senate.

Now that the bipartisan summit has come and gone, it is apparently back to "business as usual" in Washington. In our Democrat-led Congress, that means meetings behind closed doors and ignoring the American people - which ultimately means the Blair House was a good photo opportunity, but nothing more.

U.S. Rep. Phil Gingrey (R-Marietta) is an OB/GYN.
Comments
(14)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
GA Clark
|
October 09, 2011
To Indian Joe and been there - serious morons with too much time on their hands. Why not just turn down health care coverage if you don't want it...what do you think it is from the corporate oligopolies (may want to look up this term guys - you know who you are)?
NorthSouth
|
March 08, 2010
"been there" seriously...what a load of FIX NEWS, but the part about this administration being the worst you have seen! Seriously where have you been for the past 8 years? Canada getting brain surgery?

As far as Gingrey...thats is also very funny:

- He is a doctor so he knows what he is talking about, therefore knows how to change the system.

So, I tell you what since you know him so well, why don't you ask him some SPECIFICS beside:

" improve health care for every American - making it more affordable, easier to access and of a higher quality." and the answer is: He has nothing!!! Because why would he change a system that is perfect for him and his family and bring him extra money every month.

- Politicians are crooks, Gingrey is a politician therefore he is a crook.
to been there.....
|
March 08, 2010
.....then why was he seen being buddy buddy w/ Hank Johnson,... calling him a good friend?? Come on, you can't have it both ways-- check out just who Hank from Dekalb County is. He's the worst of the worst!!! Know someone by their friends!
been there
|
March 07, 2010
With the exception of 2 comments from Cobb and Indian, what I'm reading, here, reminds me of a box with a lot of minds locked inside. Try thinking outside the box. Try looking into the problems with socialized medicine in other countries. Try researching how citizens feel in countries where government controls everything. Try imagining what type of life (including healthcare) we will all have when our government is bankrupt, because we're fast approaching bankruptcy. Try reading the legislation, instead of believing everything you hear, simply because you want the government to help you.

Think outside the box. Who pays for this healthcare? Taxpayers, not the government,... those with jobs or businesses paying taxes to the government. But 4 million people have lost their jobs this year and businesses have closed or moved overseas, because they can't make it in our economy. How long will it take for this system, insuring 30 to 40 million ADDITIONAL people & costing trillions of dollars a year, to bankrupt America, while our economy continues to decline? How long will it take for us to become like Mexico, financially, and where will YOU be, then? But we won't have an America to migrate to.

I have worked for politicians and around politics for 26 years, and I can speak from experience that most politicians tell you whatever you want to hear, then they do whatever they want to do. This congress and administration is the worst I've ever seen about spinning the truth. But I've watched Rep. Gingrey closely for 3 years, and he is one of the few ethical and honest congressmen that I can trust and believe, and he takes his job of representing his constituents seriously. He's a doctor, and he knows how to change the system for the better of his constituents, not for his benefit. He knows what he's talking about, and you need to listen to him. Inform yourself. Get out of your box.

Cobb conservative
|
March 06, 2010
Those dems that say the Republicans don't have a plan need to do their homework. They also have a health care bill that the media won't talk about. Thanks Dr. Gingery for listening to the people you represent.
NorthSouth
|
March 06, 2010
Indian Joe with his conservative passion and yet no plan. I could tell you to stop listening to the pill addict or maybe to stop watching Billo, but you still had the MDJ. Anyway, let me help with the concept you do not like:

- Having to buy Health Insurance. Let's drop it for you Indian Joe,and for those who do not wish to buy it. Is it fair enough??? You are in good shape you do not need it. Yet, If one day, you get sick very sick, and do not have health insurance and not enough money to pay for it. I (the US gouvernment) MUST have the right to repo your truck, house etc.. to pay to save your life. If you don't want that..well then you get to save your life elsewhere..or die complaining to the MDJ.

-Also, I do like your last line: "But then, of course, liberals have always felt they knew what was best for everyone else, as long as they don't have to abide by the same rules or restrictions. " That is funny knowing the last administratioon VERY FUNNY
Indian Joe
|
March 05, 2010
Felt compelled to respond to all of the liberal/dem writers before me, who seem to think the Obama/Reid/Pelosi heathcare plan is just great. Do any of you people work for a living? Do any of you have employees whose health care cost, if business is forced to absorb it, will put them out of business? Do you have any concept what any of these bills contain - or do you get your info from lame stream media, Robert Gibbs, or sound bites on a major network? Yes, the summit was a sham, unforunately, because Obama and the dems can now say "we held out our hand" but the republicans did not want to accept it. Truth of the matter is nothing changed in this bill as a result of this supposed summit, photo op with a very arrogant appearing president and cohorts. If it is such a great bill and so great for the country, why are they even worried about getting republicans to vote for it - they have the majority in both houses. If none othere than members of their own party vote for it, it is a done deal. Can't anyone see that these members of the majorty are not for it - BECAUSE THEIR CONSTITUTENTS ARE NOT FOR IT. I thought we had a representative government, not a delegation government - with 6o%, or more on any given day, Americans against this, why is this message not getting through? But then, of course, liberals have always felt they knew what was best for everyone else, as long as they don't have to abide by the same rules or restrictions.
mk/no-one w/ brains?
|
March 05, 2010
Mr. Gingry,...hanging out w/ extreme lefty Dekalb County Hank Johnson, calling him a 'good' friend?????... are you freakin' kidding me? Who's next, David Scott, Nancy Pelosi,... or how 'bout just some late night poker games w/ Obama. You guys are all career politicians w/out the least bit of concern for the American people! I hope people in your district see through your shallow skin!
anonymous
|
March 05, 2010
This topic is totally polarized. Obama it trying to push through plans that are not discussed or reviewed for true cost or impact and the republicans say no to everything but have not published any plan that they think will work. Let's start slow and break the issues into sections and work one at a time. Yes, some people are really off insurance due to major problems, but if you have people on welfare and other entitlement that say they can not afford insurance but have cell phones, cable tv, internet, car leases, etc then someone needs to review each and every one. I do not want to enable more people to sit on their sofas while myself and others cover their laziness. You could easily do a credit search to see what accounts they have. Sometimes you have to force people to take care of themselves. If you chose not to have insurance, then that is not governments place to force it on someone or on business
Heaventree
|
March 04, 2010
Of course, "Dr." Gingrey has a personal financial stake in the outcome of this issue, but we're not supposed to notice that, oh no no no.
ATF
|
March 04, 2010
Gingrey - it was a photo op for Republicans because you and the rest of your party had no intention of making it a chance to actually make a legislative difference.

I am appalled at the wasted opportunities of Republicans who have no ideas of how to make a change but can only support the current system and just watch it continue to spin out of control.

Kim Huffman
|
March 04, 2010
Same old tired story line given every month by Phil...nothing substantive. Phil could have spent more time being explicit with the Republican plan and what they would do in a a "start from scratch" session than spending his column bashing Dems.

But that would just go against Republican talking points and prove that the plan Republicans have is no change or no new plans.

Come on Phil, you can do better than that!
WAW
|
March 04, 2010
"Corporate Republican" spin! If Phil was working as hard for American Citizens and he is for the insurance, drug and hospital corporations that own him, he might have something meaningful to say.
NorthSouth
|
March 04, 2010
Here you go Senator Gingrey...same old lies from your part!

OUPS, hold on...I am sorry, you have a plan You want to:

" improve health care for every American - making it more affordable, easier to access and of a higher quality."

What a plan!!! That is why you are elected! Therefore, would you please take the time tomorrow to write a second article with more SPECIFICS on your plan before your share it with congress. I mean I do not believe the Democrats will be against that! We are so proud of you, here in Georgia. Thank you for working on heatlh care, and come up with some first two lines.

Cannot wait for the rest of your plan.

I would also love to help you on a different topic: HIGHER EDUCATION: I think, and I am sorry, I am just a uneducated local citizen, but I think we should improve it, "maybe make it more affordable and of easier access to everyone, and of better quality"
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.