Dick Yarbrough: Walker supporters need to remember who caused the mess
by Dick Yarbrough
Columnist
February 27, 2010 01:00 AM | 1206 views | 17 17 comments | 67 67 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Dick Yarbrough
Dick Yarbrough
slideshow
My column in last Saturday's MDJ about the contrast between the tragic death of McEachern High School scholar-athlete Rajaan Bennett and the group of underage teens busted for drinking last December by the Cobb County police at the home of municipal court Judge Diane Busch brought a lot of mail. The majority share my outrage.

Some, however, felt I was being unfair to The Walker School since all of the students attended class there.

Sorry. You are shooting at the wrong target.

If you are concerned about The Walker School's image, let me suggest that you aim your slings and arrows of outrage at the people most responsible for your ire, namely Ms. Busch, state Sen. John Wiles (R-north Cobb), the kids who attended the party and chugged the hooch even though they were underage and the parents who should have known what their children were doing at 3 a.m.

I did not host the party. I am not the person being investigated by a special prosecutor on the suspicion of providing alcoholic beverages to underage youth. I did not threaten to call Cobb County Director of Public Safety Mickey Lloyd and/or police Chief G.B. Hatfield. I did not pull a police officer off to the side and suggest that he go easy on a Walker student who has a baseball scholarship to Rice University.

I did not get the baseball player in hot water at my party and then represent him as his attorney, writing a memo to an overmatched assistant prosecutor in the Cobb Solicitor's office and asking if he would consider an "alternative diversion program" and let the kid's baseball practice serve as community service since Rice (and I love this part) "is a not-for-profit University," clearly distinguishing it from Rocky Vista University College of Osteopathic Medicine in Parker, Colo., a for-profit school with whom Rice University is often confused.

There is an old saying in the public relations business: "If you don't want to see your name in the New York Times - or the Marietta Daily Journal - then don't say it or don't do it."

The corollary to that is "If you don't want to see your institution's good name besmirched then (a) don't serve alcohol to underage students who attend said institution; (b) don't drink it if you are said underage student; and (c) don't get righteously indignant with the police who are investigating (a) and (b).

That, boys and girls, is how you get your name in the paper.

To my knowledge, neither MDJ news editor Kim Isaza, who has reported on the story, nor your modest and much-beloved columnist has gotten the facts wrong. The wrong is questionable behavior by a bunch of people associated with the school. It isn't being helped by Busch's poor judgment or Wiles' press release, which doesn't mention asking police to cut the baseball player some slack and which claims he never told police he was a state senator. Police reports say he did. Who are you going to believe?

Two positive things have occurred recently. First, Cobb Solicitor Barry Morgan has refiled charges against William Maxwell, the 19-year old baseball player who whose blood alcohol reading, according to a Cobb Police report, was more than twice the legal limit, which doesn't qualify him for the diversion program. A first-offender's blood-alcohol content must be .08 or less at the time of the citation. Maxwell's was more than twice that - .171 - according to his citation and news reports. Not only is the diversion program toast at this point, it also doesn't allow him to work on his cut fastball as public penance.

Second, Walker Headmaster Don Robertson, in a letter to parents, called the incident "an opportunity to turn a horrible situation into a teachable moment." I couldn't agree more.

He might start his tutorial with Sen. Wiles and Judge Busch who don't seem to understand the term, "I apologize." They are too busy covering their rear ends and lawyering up to remember what can happen when teens, alcohol and automobiles are mixed.

Then, Mr. Robertson might want to remind The Walker School family that the press didn't cause this mess. They did it to themselves.

If you don't want to see your name in the paper - well, you know the rest.

You can reach Dick Yarbrough at yarb2400@bellsouth.net or P.O. Box 725373, Atlanta, Georgia 31139.
Comments
(17)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
intoxicated
|
March 07, 2010
WOW! Can you please give me a list of schools through out the atlanta area that a teenager hasn't had alchol on campus or off campus??? Bet ya can't cause guess what? Too much of it happening right on campuses all over the public school system. What's done instead? Just sweep it under the carpet with the drug problems because there would be to much embarrassement to the public school system. Georgia doe couldn't even come up with a true graduation rate for public schools. WHY? Too embarresed to let you all know just how bad it is! Wake up people GEORGIA is 47th in the country for EDUCATION! Susie is getting all A"S ya right! Guess how? GRADE INFLATION! Talk about cheating and pampering! The Walker School students have to earn there grades and ALL graduate and ALL go on to college and ALL get throught college because they are truly educated!!! YOU parents of these wonderful Georgia public school keep throwing stones at The Walker School. You know what's truly taking place here. Just waiting for The Walker School and other private school kids to mess up because then you feel justified as to why you AREN"T doing better for your child!!!!! You only get one shot at education for your child, WHO IS BEING THE IRRESPONSIBLE PARENT HERE? I am not saying the Walker parent is right, I am saying this has nothing to do with the school!!! The Walker School has been around for over 50 years with an outstanding reputation. It sure sounds like someone is truly trying to bash it because of pure jealously about the terrible reputation that the public schools have had since the beginning of time for Georgia public ed!
Indian Joe
|
March 03, 2010
So let me get this right, Dick, because these kids go Walker School, the school is at fault; even though it was during the holidays, was not on campus, and certainly not condoned by Walker. Are you suggesting that the school be held responsible because of the irresponsible actions of some of its students while on holiday and off campus? You are painting the entire school and all students with the same broad brush, when in fact only 10 or 12 out of the entire school were involved. It seems like Walker is being blamed because the Judge and her attorneys tried to wield their influence with the police - much the same as most all politicians do (unless your name is Kennedy, of course). As one writer said, I only hope that the next party that is busted for underage drinking, will receive your same attention to the schools represented. The anger should be directed at the politicians. Kids are going to drink, and they are going to experiment with drugs - either now or when they go off to college - to think otherwise is putting your head in the sand. Some (a small minority) will get caught - most will not and will determine for themselves it is not their cup of tea. Just which of the students or students' parents or school officials tried to cover this up? I don't believe there were any - except for the party host,but you make it appear that the parents of these kids, the kids themselves and Walker are to blame. Is this guilt by association or only fair game because it is a private school?
St Joe Parent
|
March 03, 2010
Job well done Mr. Yarbrough! Very well said!! Keep up the good work, and fair reporting.
hahahaiudhweofu
|
March 01, 2010
worry about something else old man
Kennesawcarol
|
February 28, 2010
I agree on every aspect of this. Walker should never be embarrassed by the behavior of a few students. But I would like to remind everyone in Cobb that we have a duty as citizens to remove from office those who abuse it. Underage drinking crosses many socio-economic levels but not all are being treated the same in this county. When the county and the state decide to do true determents such as increasing the community service with each incident and limiting where the community service can be served so that it is a learning experience, then we may see a change, but until then we can expect underage drinking to continue. Many of us were 18 and drinking was legal because we were allowed to vote and serve out country, but it seems to me this has just become a revenue source for the 'powers that be' in the state and the legal system in general. It is all about who you know in the county,city or state......so let's change the representation. Amazingly you see few of those providing the alcohol ever being given the severe sentences they deserve, it is always the 'children'. That needs to change also and this is the perfect opportunity for the county to do the right thing.
Disgusted parent
|
February 28, 2010
I absolutely agree with your points. Why wouldn't Don Robertson issue a statement that this is an unfortunate incident that is not representative of the precious Walker school? Why not state the Walker school does not condone this behavior, and they will not tolerate such actions? Does it maybe have to do with the people involved and how much those said individuals contribute monetarily to the school? I find it unacceptable that we are not "teaching the lesson" to be responsible for your actions and behavior, to be a responsible member of society. Why not teach the kids it is about taking responsibility for your actions, and that it is not all about you? Instead, the Walker supporters are teaching these children it is about money and how to weasel out of trouble you cause yourself-trouble you have gotten into as a result of your choices. Choices you were free to make, not choices made by the police or other investigators. Instead, it is about creating smoking guns and shifting blame. Way to go, Walker, for molding outstanding, fine citizens!
chaderv
|
February 27, 2010
From what has been reported this whole event started when the Cobb County Police were responding to a weapon being fired in the early morning hours. It concludes with citations being written for underage drinking.

How did we get from square one to square two? Are the two connected? Was the weapon complaint ever been resolved?
MDJ or TMZ ?
|
February 27, 2010
Mr. Yarbrough,

Yep, the MDJ has only served the public good these last few weeks associating the school of these "pretigious" teens with non-stop replays of details in a police report. What exactly was the point of mentioning their high school? Why is it even relevant? Here is a news flash - teenagers make poor choices and the faculty, parents and fellow students at their schools don't have anything to do with it. I assume to be fair you will list the schools and their Principal/Headmaster whenever you run a story on a police report involving teens in the future. That way we can all be alerted to the guilt by association of several hundred people who were not involved but deserve a public beatdown none the less. Maybe you can find out where these teens go to church so we can throw mud at those institutions as well; might as well bring down anybody that even knows this wild bunch.

Your editorial of today is a self-righteous joke. I don't know why the MDJ wants to trash the reputation of a great local school but it's pretty clear your staff is on a mission. Hey Dick, just curious, anybody at your high school ever drink alcohol before they were legal age? If that happened I sure could use that information so I can shield my kid from associating with anyone affiliated with such a terrible institution. Sorry to tell you but I would not be able to read your Commentaries with an open mind knowing you were part of such an irresponsible student body.

I can't wait to read tomorrow's public flogging - I guess that was your point all along.
Cobb Taxpayer
|
February 27, 2010
Could not agree more - But Walker folks, the seriousness of the illegal teenage actions and your inaction is being overshadowed by cover-up and fix actions of Chaperon Mom Middleton, Senator Wiles, Judge Busch, Solicitor Morgan, Judge Campbell and lawyer Summers - hopefully no other officers or officials are involved but the MDJ is the hero in this case simply by doing what the press does - report ! Behave and respond responsibily and the press is not your enemy. problem
West Cobb Mom
|
February 27, 2010
Good Job Dick!

Most of us get the point, but some are so far entrenched in their own self importance, they will never see the reality here.

Thanks for helping to keep the real issue at the forefront, maybe some self awareness will leak into some highly indignant, self important people related to this incident.
Walkerparent
|
February 27, 2010
Mr. Yarbrough,

I hope that nothing like this ever happens to any of your grandkids or the school they attend. Somehow I think if it did, you wouldn't be so quick to write about it in your column. Walker is a good school with good students and good parents. There will always be kids who are going to make mistakes, and there will always be parents who don't make the right decisions every time. Let's don't crucify them in the press...have a heart mister!
trisha - West Cobb
|
February 27, 2010
another rule of thumb - don't anger a newspaper columnist. He will always get the last word!
SouthernGal
|
February 27, 2010
Amen!
Excellent points
|
February 27, 2010
Walker: turn your wrath inward!
Just sayin'
|
February 27, 2010
You have absolutely spelled it out clearly and correctly, Mr. Yarbrough. While some details have been disputed, not one person has stated that there wasn't a party at Ms. Busch's home that involved underage drinking by a group of Walker students. Also, no one has disputed the fact that one student was allowed to practice baseball in lieu of real community service as the consequence of his chosen behavior. If you don't want your name and a report of your questionable behavior in the paper.....
Tim Schmerkel
|
February 27, 2010
But unfortunately in all of this, an innocent man who was taken advantage of got his name in the paper and ultimately was forced to resign his position.
facts of case376
|
February 27, 2010
What about the presumption of innocence? No you did not attend the party in question but your article concludes that every fact in the police reports is 100 percent accurate and we all know that police reports are always 100 percent accurate. Have you spoken to Mr Wiles or Ms Busch? I doubt it. Your statements not very responsible when you have such high quality police reports that quote people with the qualifier of "said something like". There is a huge difference between said and said something like. Could they really not remember what was said accurately? Is that not a red flag for those reporting that all may not be what it seems? This case has now been investigated for over two months by the police who failed to charge Mr Wiles or Ms Busch. Now and special prosecutor has had the file for nearly two weeks and reached no conclusion. How can they have all this factual material that is so open and shut but be unable to reach a conclusion but you can state the facts with such complete certainty. If you have not heard both sides of the story then you are assuming and when you assume you make an ass you and an ass of me.
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.