Hearing to decide fate of Crooks recall effort
by Jon Gillooly
jgillooly@mdjonline.com
February 23, 2010 12:00 AM | 1541 views | 11 11 comments | 22 22 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Carrie Nicholas- Welkis prepares to submit an application to recall school board member Dr. John Crooks, Post 6, with more than 100 signatures at the West Park Government Center in November. A hearing March 9 will determine whether to move forward with the recall effort.
Carrie Nicholas- Welkis prepares to submit an application to recall school board member Dr. John Crooks, Post 6, with more than 100 signatures at the West Park Government Center in November. A hearing March 9 will determine whether to move forward with the recall effort.
slideshow
MARIETTA - A hearing has been set for next week to determine whether a petition to recall Dr. John Crooks from the Cobb school board can move forward.

The hearing is scheduled for 9 a.m. Thursday, March 4, in Cobb Superior Court before Rome Circuit Court Judge Walter Matthews.

Last July, Crooks called for a vote to allow a 150-foot cell tower at Eastvalley Elementary School, a proposal many parents and residents opposed as an unwanted eyesore. Crooks placed the cell tower matter on the board's agenda the day of the July meeting without advance advertising, saying he did so to avoid a "circus." Several families therefore filed suit against the school district, arguing that the board violated state Open Meetings law by failing to give proper advance notice on the vote.

Cobb Superior Court issued a temporary restraining order against the board, halting any work from being done on the tower, but then Crooks called for second vote on the tower in October. This time it was advertised on the agenda in advance, and the board approved the tower in a vote of 4-2-1.

Following that second vote, Eastvalley mom Carrie Nicholas-Welkis launched a campaign to recall Crooks from office, charging him with intent to mislead the public, lack of constituency engagement, violating the Georgia Open Meetings Act and conduct unbecoming of an elected official.

There are a number of steps to recalling an elected official. The first step is to obtain 100 signatures, submitting them to the Cobb Board of Elections. Nicholas-Welkis submitted 119 signatures. The next step is for a judge to determine whether the grounds for recall are sufficient. That is what is scheduled to occur next week.

"Bottom line, she has to make her case that her petition needs to move forward," Crooks said.

If the judge green lights the recall effort, Nicholas-Welkis must then obtain signatures from 30 percent of the active voters in Post 6, which she estimates being between 13,000 and 14,000.

Crooks said Monday while he didn't care to respond to her allegations, he will not seek re-election when his term expires at the end of the year. Retired Dodgen Middle School principal Jim Snell has announced he is running for Crooks' seat in the July 20 Republican primary.

Nicholas-Welkis said she was unaware that Crooks had decided against a re-election bid, but even so, "I don't feel warm and fuzzy about him staying in office until December. He hasn't represented us fairly. We don't believe he's complied with the policies, and we don't think he keeps his word."

The only way Crooks would satisfy her, she said, is to resign or be recalled.
Comments
(11)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
CrooksMustResign
|
March 11, 2010
John Crooks can not represent East Cobb as a lame duck under a vigorous recall effort.

With $100,000,000 in budget cuts coming - East Cobb needs a warrior to defend its schools.

Please join me in calling for his resignation.
Nate Collins
|
February 26, 2010
I would love to see Crooks ousted. He is so selfish and out for himself... If there is a way I can sign that petition please send me information and I will comply. He has been a personal thorn in my side dealing with some other Cobb County issues that has driven me over the edge. His response to my concerns after several messages were never addressed. Send me information so I can sign.

Nate Collins

Cobb County Resident

nate_collinsdirect@yahoo.com
Dr. Ricky A. Welkis
|
February 24, 2010
"General Wheeler", It's nice you consider a judges order a "difference of opinion" of Glen Brock. I didn't think lawyers and judges had equal enforcement of the law, but maybe you know something I don't.

I guess you also forgot about the comment Dr. Crooks made referring to the concerned Eastvalley citzens as being members of a "circus", or the numerous times Dr. Crooks pledged to the community to do his due diligence in assessing community support or opposition before voting on the tower.

No, instead he sneaked the cell tower item on the Board's agenda at the begining of the busiest board meeting of the year in order to "avoid a circus".

Now that's a real man of integrity.

Regarding the tower placement at Wheeler and Eastvalley: Wheeler has a two 129 foot towers on light posts set back at least 300 feet from the school. Eastvalley is getting a 150 foot cell tower setback approx 40 feet from the school, also in a tightly residential community. For more perspective, Wheeler's campus is at least 3-4x the size of Eastvalley's meager 7.2 acres (the second smallest Elementary school campus in the county).

And that tacky sign... it's on the property of the 90 year of lady, who John Crooks proclaimed, in reference to her opposition to the the cell tower, will "die soon anyway".
General Wheeler
|
February 24, 2010
To Dr. Welkis,

I noticed that you did not comment on anyone else’s pen name until someone posted who disagrees with you, but I’m happy you think it’s “cute!” And since you clearly still have your nose out-of-joint on this issue- for your information, I also live in the shadows of Eastvalley, have read the recall petition, have to drive by the tacky recall sign in the neighbor’s yard every day, and I stand by my comments and opinion on the issue and on Dr. Crooks. Also being a former public servant, I can tell you that the job is never easy, and there is always at least 2 sides to every issue. So, since you are passionate about issues, I would encourage you to run for office and see what it’s like to be on the hot seat. Inevitably, you will have to deal with an unpopular issue and make a decision that you believe to be in the long term best interests of all your constituents, regardless of the personal consequences (if you are a person of integrity). I understand your point about the process, but I cannot fault Dr. Crooks for relying on the advice of counsel. Judge Stoddard’s restraining order means that he is in disagreement with the Board’s counsel and while corrective action can be taken for future episodes, it had nothing to do with the ultimate outcome, which is completely legal. My question to you is, if you are this opposed to the cell tower at Eastvalley, and since Eastvalley is a feeder school to East Cobb M. H. and Wheeler H. S., will you send your children there, since they will be there for 7 years under the Wheeler cell tower?

Retreat Hell...
|
February 24, 2010
"someone of the caliber of John Crooks serving them." General Wheeler that "caliber" is questionable when he has still not publicly condemned the actions of the thief who took the recall documentation from Ms. Welkis back in early November. As a public servant he should have immediately condemned that action and actively worked to identify the individual involved.

His comments portraying his constituents as a "circus" and trying to improperly avoid public discussion of an issue also say much for his "caliber". Changing your opinion when additional information is presented is not wrong, failing to present your reasons for changing it and insulting the concerned parties was his mistake.
Dr. Ricky A. Welkis
|
February 23, 2010
This comment is directed to the person below "General Wheeler".... I find it ironic that everybody needs to hide behind cute names when posting comments. Sure my last name looks familiar. Just read the article above and make the connection. I would love to rebut your comments but do not have the space to write it here. Please....do me a favor and google my name so that you can call me and we will have a great little chat on this cell tower issue and on the "stellar" job you think John Crooks is doing. Also, next time have the nerve to use your real name. My comment on the recall...John Crooks had a chance to redeem himself to most of his constituents by voting against the cell tower at the 2nd cell tower vote which was seen by all as a "farce"! There were over 100 people there in opposition (Neighbors, parents, children and taxpayers - who live in the shadow of the tower to be) and they believed that their voices counted. They got slapped in the face by John Crooks a second time. Not to mention that he broke the law in regard to the 1st vote of which John Crooks and The CBOE were found guilty by Judge Stoddard's temporary restraining order. I could go on but I think for now his record speaks for himself. Enuf Said! If you didn't quite catch my name before....Dr. Ricky A. Welkis...a proud parent, PTA member, neighbor and taxpayer living right nest door to East Valley Elementary School.
General Wheeler
|
February 23, 2010
As a board observer, Cobb County citizens should be proud to have someone of the caliber of John Crooks serving them. As a first time elected official, Dr. Crooks has learned that his primary responsibility is to listen to all sides, which he did, evaluate & then do what is in the overall best interest of his constituency, knowing that you can never make everybody happy. I would be willing to bet that if most of his detractors were in his shoes, they would have done the same thing. Interesting that it is always the vocal minority that gets the attention. Interesting also that a cell tower has sat for several years next to the football field at Wheeler H. S., less than a mile from East Valley, without any fanfare or problems - just providing much needed revenue for the school that does not come from the taxpayers...If this is how we treat the good people, who would want to run for office and be subject to such unwarranted criticism. Certainly not well informed people!
lhs mom
|
February 23, 2010
Can we also recall David Banks? He is as bad as Crooks, if not worse. As a matter of fact, lets recall them all and start over clean.
JoHn Gerbil
|
February 23, 2010
Crooks must go!
Retreat Hell...
|
February 23, 2010
Reverend Crooks has flip-flopped before and he will most likely do it again so don’t stop the recall process now.
Monty P.
|
February 23, 2010
Does he float?
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.