Don McKee: It's time to boost economy by mandating later school openings
by Don McKee
Columnist
February 19, 2010 01:00 AM | 757 views | 12 12 comments | 8 8 recommendations | email to a friend | print
State Rep. Matt Dollar (R-Marietta) has introduced a bill to prohibit early start dates for Georgia public schools.

The measure is House Bill 1097, which would require local school boards to adopt a calendar "that in no event shall commence the first day of instruction of a school year prior to the third full week of August."

Of course, many Cobb parents would welcome the state-mandated start date later than the first week of August approved by flip-flopping board members who reneged on their campaign promises.

It's not only that families lose summer vacation time and schools have to pay higher energy costs to operate the schools, but the effects on the economy could be substantial - an issue that needs a lot more discussion, especially during the worst recession in decades.

Rep. Dollar made the point that his bill not only would "enhance family togetherness but will save our school systems substantial money and also benefit the state's ailing economy." He said many Georgia tourist attractions have to shut down early in the summer "resulting in economic loss for the attractions, their local communities and the state as a whole."

Estimates from other states indicate that the economic impact is very substantial - either positive for late start dates or negative for early school starts.

In Michigan, where state legislators mandated a post-Labor Day school start in 2005, an analyst for the Michigan Boating Industries Association said the result was an increase of $10 million in the state's tourism tax revenue for the first year, reported WSBT-TV in Indiana, where late-start legislation won state Senate approval this month.

The Southwest Michigan Tourist Council's executive director said that every year since the late-start law was enacted in the state, tourism in lakefront communities in August has exceeded that of July. "That was never, ever the case before," said the official, Millicent Huminsky. "July was always the No. 1 month."

Her assessment of the later school start: "Absolutely positive."

In Alabama, a study released by Save Alabama Summers estimated the state loses $26 million for every August day school is in session.

In Indiana, the Association of Convention and Visitors Bureaus supports the bill to prevent pre-Labor Day school opening, saying it's long overdue.

An official of the South Bend/Mishawaka Convention and Visitors Bureau said the local economy loses each summer day that schools are in session. With 8,000 jobs depending our tourism in the county, "It's a big economic driver here," said the official.

Nearly a dozen states have mandated late August, post-Sept. 1 or post-Labor Day school start dates: South Carolina, Florida, West Virginia, Minnesota, Wisconsin, North Carolina, Michigan, Texas, Virginia and Arkansas.

There's a lot of talk by Georgia legislators about promoting economic growth this session.

HB 1097 is an easy, painless, no-tax way to promote economic growth through tourism right here at home - and save money and family vacations - by preventing schools from starting classes before the third week in August.

dmckee9613@aol.com
Comments
(12)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
anonymous
|
February 22, 2010
ATF,

The tax dollars generated by the businesses pay for the education of all our children. More to the point, our school board is not making good use of our tax dollars in very tight economic times. Making the best use of our tax dollars to provide the best possible education for all our children is what I am after. The Balanced Calendar will not be the best use of our very tight education dollars. Sadly, our children are the biggest losers.
East Cobb mom of 5
|
February 19, 2010
come again maylib - don't understand a word you just wrote!
maylib
|
February 19, 2010
ATF - but you'd ignore an economic truth? teach furloughs ring a bell? cut backs to school funding?

if you think the only metric used to judge when kids come and go from school is educational, you're kidding yourself.

if it helps the economy and it was able to educate the current legion of adults, where is the disgrace in suggesting it's good for all to change it?
anonymous
|
February 19, 2010
wait a minute, don't the schools have to follow State Dept of Ed guidelines? Isn't that a state entity? If you want to go when you want, have them charter out as a district and do it that way so they do not have to follow rules, they don't anyway so at least it would then be legal!
ATF
|
February 19, 2010
Mr. McKee:

This is a local issue, not a state issue. If Cobb County voters decide this is best for the children in Cobb County, then we should vote to keep those on the school board who supported the early school start.

If we decide the early school start is not good for the children, then we should vote them out.

How good or bad early start is for business is not the issue. The idea that you should think the effect on business is a factor is disgraceful and disgusting. I would not sell the effectiveness of my child's education for the good of your and anyone else's business.

matlib
|
February 19, 2010
Don - I could not agree with you more. No one talks about this and it's sad that most of the people now decrying this loss of knowledge over the summer were raised in that very system. They're not dumb, have good jobs, and are now successfully raising families.

Yet, somehow they view the system that got them where they are now as being broken and in need of change so our kids learn more.

If we spent half as much time talking about curriculum as we did calendars, we'd all be better off.

Thanks for getting the big picture on this! It wasn't broken before so let's stop trying to fix it! memorial day - labor day. great bookends on a school year.
KATHIE VV
|
February 19, 2010
This is not a state issue - it is a local issue.

Plenty of counties have gone to this calendar and have adjusted and are thriving under it.

If you want something changed in CC board - then go vote. Do it the right way!!!

Frank McRintock
|
February 19, 2010
Don, I thought Republicans were supposed to be about small government and local control! Yet we have a gaggle of Republican representatives who seek to strip that away for their own interests. The school system isn't in operation to keep Six Flags cheaply staffed or to create economic growth...it's to teach kids. The business interests continue to pay their way through the Legislature to get what they prefer.
GaPatriot
|
February 19, 2010
This is fine...as long as the school calendar is balanced to provide for enough breaks so that a giant lag isn't provided for the kids to lose what they have learned. Considering tourism is great. But one has to consider the entire student population and not just the economically advantaged.
Wait a minute
|
February 19, 2010
Now let me get this straight. The teachers and administration claim that students do not recall work over the winter holiday so we need ot finish early, but they will remember over one week breaks through out the year? Come on guys, you can't have it both ways. Are you saying our children are incapable of retaining any knowledge? If that is the case our teaching practices should be the first thing to change
anonymous
|
February 19, 2010
You heathen! How dare you interrupt our vacation plans. We need a week off every two months!

Love, The Teachers
Lattie Sue Milnes
|
February 19, 2010
What about the need to finish the semester before Winter Break?
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.