Claim of illegal workers now under state jurisdiction
by Katy Ruth Camp
krcamp@mdjonline.com
February 11, 2010 01:00 AM | 2713 views | 24 24 comments | 23 23 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Work continued Wednesday on the new Cobb Superior Courthouse, which is expected to be completed by March 2011 at a cost of $63 million. The watchdog group Jobs for Georgians has made allegations that illegal immigrants are being used by a subcontractor in the construction process.<br>Photo by Thinh D. Nguyen
Work continued Wednesday on the new Cobb Superior Courthouse, which is expected to be completed by March 2011 at a cost of $63 million. The watchdog group Jobs for Georgians has made allegations that illegal immigrants are being used by a subcontractor in the construction process.
Photo by Thinh D. Nguyen
slideshow
MARIETTA - Cobb Chairman Sam Olens and Commissioner Tim Lee say the general contractor overseeing the construction of the county's new Superior Courthouse has taken appropriate action regarding recent allegations that illegal immigrants were employed to work on the project - and any further action is out of their hands. Meanwhile, a state lawmaker is using the local situation as an example for why his bill regarding the hiring of illegal immigrants should be passed.

Members of the watchdog group Jobs for Georgians went before the Board of Commissioners on Tuesday and presented claims that Zebra Construction, the masonry subcontractor on the courthouse project, hired illegal immigrants.

Jose Alvarez said he spent three months visiting the construction site and posing as a bricklayer looking for work. Alvarez said he created relationships with Zebra's workers and has an audio tape that he said proves those workers were being paid in cash, were not checked under the federal program E-verify and were not paying income taxes or social security insurance.

Chip Kessler, president of Suwanee-based Zebra, said the contractor hired by his company to manage the blocklayers was pulled from the project because he told them he was not enrolled in E-verify. Kessler confirmed that this means the contractor was not checking his construction workers through E-verify.

Alvarez estimates that 14 workers employed by the subcontractor were illegal immigrants.

John Ciancia, the leader of the Jobs for Georgians' undercover operation, said he called Virgil Moon, the county's director of support services, and e-mailed Olens before noon Wednesday. By 8 p.m., Ciancia said he still had not heard back from either of them, even though he said they told him they would like to meet and see his evidence.

But Olens said he told Ciancia that he felt the meeting should take place with county attorney Dorothy Bishop, as she can offer more direction.

"A meeting with the county attorney is not what we're looking for," Ciancia said. "The commissioners are the ultimate voice over this project, so they are the ones we feel should know this information."

Olens said he feels Turner Construction, the project's general contractor, has properly handled the situation with Zebra and that the removal of the contractor not registered with E-verify is a significant solution.

"We have a provision in our contract where Turner has to address and solve any complaints within 10 days, which they did, and I don't think the county has that tool to fire the subcontractor altogether," Olens said. "Any further action that can be taken against the contractor or subcontractor is under the state of Georgia's jurisdiction. I would like to see these violations become criminal issues, or to levy a large fine to those breaking the law that will give us the opportunity to tell people that they cannot do this or they will pay the consequences."

Olens said Cobb was the first to fully comply with Senate Bill 529, which provides procedures and requirements applicable to certain contracts or subcontracts, and the county has taken measures no other county has taken to show that illegal employment would not tolerated.

"I certainly thank the bricklayers for finding this out because this is something we need to know," Olens added.

Lee also said he feels Turner has successfully reassured the county that the project is following the law, but that there may need to be some changes in the county's policy.

"I think we need to sit down and figure out ways to make sure this doesn't happen again, to ask ourselves, 'What more can we do? What steps can we take?'" he said. "If it is true, it's certainly not something we take lightly, but we'll learn from it and do what we can to make sure it doesn't happen again. It's a concern any time any county money is being spent and is not being used properly, and we're not going to tolerate any level of unfair or illegal benefiting."

Zebra is also the masonry subcontractor for Southern Polytechnic State University's $33 million Engineering and Technology Center, which is currently under construction and is expected to be completed in August. SPSU President Dr. Lisa Rossbacher said she was not aware of any action taken to look into Zebra's practices, but the subcontractor will be reviewed, if it has not already.

"As far as I know, they have been following the laws that everyone else has to abide by," Rossbacher said. "And at some level, we have to trust the process because we are simply not set up to implement our own independent cross-checking of each worker. But if it turns out that the same processes implemented elsewhere are defective, then we will certainly look at what action needs to take place from there."

Ciancia said whatever the outcome of his group's findings is, he ultimately hopes subcontractors will be given a level playing field as they bid for projects and that unemployed, legal taxpayers will be given the jobs they need and deserve.

"Other subcontractors who are playing by the rules are suffering because they can't compete with the low bids generated by those saving money through hiring illegal workers. These general contractors can pick and choose who they want on their project, because the economy is so bad and everyone wants work. So by picking someone they know will probably find a way to be cheaper, even if it is illegal, they are taking that risk and, to me, saying they don't really care," Ciancia said. "Taxpayers are paying for that building to be built. Illegal activity shouldn't happen anywhere, but certainly not at the cost of citizens for a government building. And Cobb County taxpayers are the ones missing out on all those taxes that will probably never be traced. There's a lot of disappointment in this whole thing, but to me, that's the saddest part."

Illegal immigration activist D.A. King said he believes the hiring of illegal workers was no accident.

"Somewhere along the line, there was someone involved in the process who just didn't care if Cobb residents' money was being used improperly. And I think there should be a full investigation into where every bit of taxpayer money went," King said.

The local situation hit the Capitol Wednesday, where Rep. Rick Austin (R-Demorest) presented House Bill 1164 before the Georgia House. Austin's bill proposes severe consequences for public entities that knowingly employ illegal workers. In Austin's bill, a local government who knowingly employs someone who is in the country illegally will lose its qualifying local government funds for a year. This includes all state funding and matching. If a state agency knowingly employs illegal workers, it will lose 10 percent of the state-funded budget the next year.

A spokesperson for Austin said the lawmaker is presenting his bill today, and has printed out copies of the Marietta Daily Journal's Wednesday article to use as an example for why his bill should be passed.

Rumors circulated that other subcontractors were absent from the courthouse project site Wednesday due to their own employment of illegal workers, but Turner spokeswoman Sharon Eckhert said the employees were sent home as a safety precaution due to high winds.
Comments
(24)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
American worker
|
February 13, 2010
Oh, Kim - which is it, we won't work, or we want a living wage in our own country? You are all over the map with your feelings.

Yous should debate D.A. King you seem very confident of your feelings. ahaahahahahahaahaa
are you serious seri
|
February 13, 2010
Yes, we are all a bunch of meanies because we want American jobs to go to legal workers. You must make your money from the crime of illegal imigration, si?

How awful it must be to cross the border illegally, get a job illegally, steal ID - illegally, and live as a fugitive. I can see where "working with ICE" may be a problem.

ILLEGALS: GET OUT! ILLEGAL EMPLOYERS TO THE JAIL HOUSE!.. I hope that I have not offended anyone.
are you serious
|
February 12, 2010
@Practical Logic -- Yes, if they look different and speak a foreign language, they must be illegal.

I suggest you walk a mile in their shoes. I challenge you to spend just 30 days with an immigrant legal or not. Most of you complain if you have to standin line at the DMV for 10 minutes. Try working with ICE. If you think the IRS has a bad rep, you haven't seen anything.

Fight just as hard for immigration reform and you won't come off looking like the biggest red neck bigots in the world. After all, very few ancestors of all you knowledgeable posters were born or even came here legally.
anonymous
|
February 11, 2010
From the article , the contractor CLAIMS THE DID NOT KNOW the subcontractor hired ILLEGALS. The Mafia always covered their trail with fake enterprises. All of the ILLEGAL EMPLOYERS realize that many "subcontractors" are organized exclusively to hire ILLEGALS while they persist in seeking out these “subcontractors” and they use their supposed "ignorance" of the hiring practices to "end run" the law. Construction, Oil Refineries, Retailers, and many others use the services of "subcontractors" to secure their "cheap labor" at the expense of United States Citizens. As our President commented, as long as the ILLEGAL EMPLOYERS are able to claim ignorance of the law without penalty they will maintain their effort to secure “cheap labor” resulting in the ILLEGALS continuing to scurry across our unsecured national borders.

"Members of the watchdog group Jobs for Georgians went before the Board of Commissioners on Tuesday and presented claims that Zebra Construction, the masonry subcontractor on the courthouse project, hired illegal immigrants.

Jose Alvarez said he spent three months visiting the construction site and posing as a bricklayer looking for work. Alvarez said he created relationships with Zebra's workers and has an audio tape that he said proves those workers were being paid in cash, were not checked under the federal program E-verify and were not paying income taxes or social security insurance."

jobs for georgians
|
February 11, 2010
We are not going to let up until the removal of Zebra and ban them from Cobb county the dynamic duo (Turner and Zebra)also did the new jail up the street think of all the taxes that were lost there.

People join jobsforgeorgians.net its free!!!!! Keep the faith!!This is just the beginning....
Kim Huffman
|
February 11, 2010
My point is, we gladly accept cheaper prices for food because it is picked by illegals, by living in more affordable homes ( built by illegals, re: new construction ), yard work and other grunt work that Americans won't do for the same wages... done by illegals, ...and every time someone says "unionize" for better labor, you bemoan the cost of labor and their power. Fat Cat construction owners?, that's just good old capitalism, ain't it?

American Worker: Our American jobs were packed up and sent over the boarder and over seas to Mexico, China, India so we 'mercians didn't have to pay union wages and get our flatscreens and cars made cheap. Practical Logic: Those car plants your refer to are subsidized through your tax dollars to the point they never will pay taxes, and they are assembly plants for parts mfgd, in other countries....Stop pouring your dollars out for foreign made goods, or is that deal at Walmart to good to pass up?

to cobb taxpayer
|
February 11, 2010
Where were they??? They were at an $11,000.00

retreat that was paid to Hall County at Lake

Lanier Islands. Me thinks they need to RETREAT back to Cobb County and DO THIER JOBS!!!!!
Ticka
|
February 11, 2010
Activist Barbara Coe stated that our veggies

and fruits should be picked by American prisoners

and Jail birds.

I think she is right.
American worker
|
February 11, 2010
Kim, be careful on re entry, OK? Have you read the news recently? More than 15 million Americans are out of work. Holy Moley, pls tell us you don't vote? Please?

It is a crime to hire illegal labor...get it?Oh nevermind.
Cobb Taxpayer
|
February 11, 2010
Who is the Cobb County "contract compliance officer" ? Guess he/she along with Olens, Hankerson and even part timer Lee failed miserably. Where was the Rifleman Warren and chief sharpshooter deputy and Cobb Public Safety Director - they had evidence provided by others and could have shut-down the building site and done there constitutional jobs - I strongly suggest that Olens and his gang (before resignations) hire D.A. King to be the Cobb County Compliance Contract Officer ( Maybe Cobb BOE should hire King to do the same ) - he would do a marvelous job, be effective and efficient, and he is available and prepared today !
FMX
|
February 11, 2010
About time. I am sick and tired I seeing these fat cat contractors use illegals on government contracts.
Indian Joe
|
February 11, 2010
How about this Kim - why don't you step up to the plate and offer to pay the taxes, social security, medicare levy, etc for all of these illegals? They are spensding most of this money on rent, food and transportation? You are so in la la land. When you put 15 or 20 people into a single family residence/apartment, just how much do you think each one is paying. They can also get food stamps, rent subsidy, free medical care (emergency rooms) because they have children who were born here and they have no means of "support" that is provable. Sure, they spent on transporation, without driver licenses or insurance. I know of 4 people who have been involved in accidents where the at fault party is illegal, with no insurance. In which case the claim was made on their insurance - resulting in an increase in premiums. Law abiding citizen is absolutely right - when you are breaking the law just by being in this country, why should you feel you have to obey any other law?
Their Job
|
February 11, 2010
Huffman- using your logic, each time before we go to the grocery store, every shopper should go to the fields & check for green cards before purchasing their food. NO, that is the job function of our government. But guess what? They don't do it. Gov't high ups & those elected only want to have the money & vote of big businesses, so our laws are NOT enforced.
Practical Logic
|
February 11, 2010
In large commercial construction jobs like the court house, the hiring of illegals is hidden in the layers of subcontractors. So the customer, like Cobb County gov't & Turner can say they hire legally. All the INS & every other agency that deals with illegals has to do is GO to the construction site & check for green cards, SS cards, etc. It is done at meat processing plants in the mid-west, so do it here. NOW! To Huffman-The majority of citizens do NOT knowingly purchase an item or service that is made or provided by illegals. Buying a toy, made in China, is definitely not the same as knowlingly hiring an illegal to lay brick or do yardwork. Your logic is more than absurd. I know several career bricklayers who were born in Cobb & Paulding counties, who would love to be working at this site. In my area for at least 3 yrs, before most home construction came to a halt, I never saw brick & stone layers on the site, who looked like they were anything, but Hispanic. And when I walked or rode my bike past them, they were not speaking English. I suspect they were here illegaly.
ugly kim
|
February 11, 2010
Kim, you are an idiot. Who are you to decide that the Cobb County Commission can spend the taxpayers' money illegally? Yes, illegally, it is against the law for them to award a contract to a company, Turner Construction, that knowingly hired subs who hired illegals. This very situation has occurred in Jacksonville, so they have been on notice.

Where private citizens spend their money, say on "foreign cars" is their business. But where public money is spent is determined by the law. And those "foreign" cars are probably built here; i.e., Kia in LaGrange.

Cobb employs managers and other personnel who should have been checking. The IRS will do audits on the subcontractors of the subcontractors - for FREE. So no excuse Turner. And no excuse Sam Olens and the rest of the commissioners. You should have demanded the audits and overseen the results. How much building is going on that you cannot keep track?

We demand zero tolerance for all our school children to obey the rules, and they are punished and expelled for bringing a tiny toy gun to school. We should demand zero tolerance for our elected officials. You all have forgotten that you work for us. Punish Turner, take away that contract. Give it to an honest contractor who will reward the taxpayers by playing by the rules. And resign commissioners, take the county manager with you. Forget running for Attorney General as well.

workingsue
|
February 11, 2010
I wouldn’t blame D.A.King for shouting out a great big “I TOLD YOU SO"!

The only silver lining to this horrible story is its timing. Rep. Rick Austin should have no problem finding support for his HB1164. Any lawmaker not supporting this bill should be as suspect as those subcontractors who were absent due to “high winds”.

Kim Huffman
|
February 11, 2010
What hypocrites we are..its o.k. for illegals to slave away in the fields and pick crops ( we can't see them there ), but come into town and lay some bricks ( how many red blooded American bricklayers exist anymore anyways ) and pow, its the invasion of all time.

How many of you whining about your dollars going to illegals ( they will at least spend a good amount here for food, rent, transportation ) consider the bucks you spend for that big screen go to China with no local spending impact?, or that foreign made vehicle and the oil it runs on is pure money out the country. Wake up 'merica!
Pat H
|
February 11, 2010
Whoever thinks that all Cobb projects are abiding by the law and only hiring legal workers please stand on your heads. I have personally written to Sam Olens and Tim Lee about illegals working on Post Oak Tritt Road - thank CW Williams for that. The laws are being ignored and so have the citizens. Those of us who have attended meetings and complained about illegals and lax enforcement were treated horribly. No response, no change. Thank you so much Jobs for Georgians. Please visit the road construction site on Sewell Mill Road for additional violations.
Stand up and Clap!!!
|
February 11, 2010
I applaud the "Jobs for Georgians", DA King, Rep. Rick Austin, and all the others who fight for my "American" rights. Many of us are being forced to take pay cuts, less hours, or furloughs and we still have to pay our taxes - that are providing jobs, healthcare, and education for those who are breaking the law by being here illegally - while we struggle to provide for ourselves and our families.
lionel b.
|
February 11, 2010
Illegal immigrants working in cobb county for cash and the situation is dealt with by the board of comm. and Zebra. No, the situation should also be handled by the Internal Revenue Service, who will nail them for back taxes. and require worker s be paid by check and after words deport them.
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.