Irate member wants answers on why grand jury probe hidden from board
by Brandon Wilson
bwilson@mdjonline.com
January 21, 2010 01:00 AM | 2473 views | 28 28 comments | 19 19 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA - An incredulous Cobb School Board member is demanding to know why the superintendent, former board chair and vice chair knew about a Cobb grand jury inquiry into the board's secretive policies while other board members were kept in the dark.

In a terse, one-paragraph e-mail addressed to Cobb school board Chairwoman Lynnda Crowder-Eagle and also sent to Superintendent Fred Sanderson and other board members, irate board member Alison Bartlett asks that an "immediate explanation" be given for why her colleagues were not told about a Dec. 1 grand jury inquiry and the scathing presentments from the inquiry that were delivered Jan. 7. Bartlett also recommends that a retreat planned for Amicalola Falls at the end of the month be postponed and replaced by a special called meeting at the school district headquarters on Glover Street in lieu of the retreat. At that time, she says succinctly, she would like for Crowder-Eagle, Abraham and Sanderson to explain how such a highly unusual inquiry by a grand jury into the procedures of a school board be kept from most school board members.

"The integrity of the school system and credible governance of this Board depends on an immediate explanation as to why all board members were not promptly notified of the Grand Jury Inquiry," Bartlett wrote Wednesday night.

Crowder-Eagle did not return a message left late Thursday by the Journal seeking a response to Bartlett's request.

The Journal reported Wednesday that then-school board Chairman Dr. John Abraham, then-Vice Chairwoman Crowder-Eagle, Sanderson and board attorney Glenn Brock appeared before a sub-committee of the grand jury on Dec. 1. However, board members not in attendance say they first learned of the inquiry by reading the Journal report. They were kept uninformed about the grand jury's presentments, which were delivered Jan. 7.

Board member David Morgan also wants to know why he was not informed.

"I didn't know there had been an inquiry," Morgan said. "That totally took me by surprise. I will be eager to hear how things transpired and why I was not told about it."

Morgan does, however, think the issue could be addressed at the board retreat.

Bartlett said board member John Crooks also did not know about the inquiry. When asked when board member David Banks found out about the inquiry, he told a Journal editor Wednesday that he had not "had an opportunity to read this document" and declined further comment until doing so.

Board member Holli Cash also confirmed to the Journal that she did not know about the inquiry or its presentments, but said she was "not concerned about it."

Cash - whose been a staunch supporter of Sanderson - said board chairs are, from time to time, called to appear before a grand jury, adding,d "I'm sure at our next meeting they will update us on the information."

"It was the first time John and Lynnda had been involved in one and they handled how they handled it," she said.

When read the summary of presentments that were printed in the legals section of the Journal on Jan. 15 that claimed the board was reluctant to entertain public opinion, Cash said, "I appreciate the grand jury findings, but we are operating in a more open way than has ever been done. We've done more than they have done in the past, so I'm not really sure what more we can do."

In its presentments, the county's last grand jury issued a scathing report that blasted the school board for "operating in a manner that severely limits the open and public debate of school policy decisions prior to vote and implementation." The grand jurors also recommended a stern follow-up measure for the board, saying it should be formally reviewed by future grand juries "no less than 4 times per year."

According to the presentments, the discussions focused in part on the new balanced calendar that starts school on the first Monday of August. Board members approved the three-year calendar just weeks earlier, on Nov. 12, after dozens of parents protested the plan at the board meeting.

The grand jurors also reviewed minutes and videos of board meetings, and surveyed public reporting on recent board activities.

"The Grand Jury would respectively remind the Board that as an elected body, they have an implied obligation to operate in an open forum environment. This would include allowing a full and open debate of all pending board decisions where the public can freely express opinions on both sides of the issues," wrote the grand jury, which was headed by foreperson Tommy Perkins Jr.

"Based on this Grand Jury's review, the current Board is operating in a manner that hinders the expression of opposing views and/or makes policy decisions in non-public forums."

Bartlett said a special meeting in lieu of the board's retreat "gives us an opportunity to look into how we handled the inquiry."

For an estimated cost of about $5,800, the Cobb school board is scheduled to have a team building retreat on Jan. 29 and Jan. 30 at Amicalola Falls State Park Lodge, where consultant Nancy Broner is scheduled to give team building training.

"The purpose of retreat is team building - and to be a team, we need open communication," Bartlett said of why a meeting should be called in lieu of the retreat. "I just think we need to have an open discussion and look at how we did this and how we can improve communication."

Cobb County convenes a 25-member grand jury every other month, for a total of six in a year. Members meet periodically over an eight-week period, investigating criminal and civil matters and reviewing government agencies.
Comments
(28)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Omar the Begger
|
January 22, 2010
Ok people; listen to what I say the reason the board leaders and there lawyer friend, hid the results from the whole board is because the board leaders did not want the public to know what a bad job the board chair person, the superintendent and there lawyer’s are doing. If you think what I have written is wrong just look at how many times the Grand Jury has told the school board that they were doing wrong. Look in order to have the school board stay on the straight and narrow show up at a few meeting, a room full of people from the county will let the board know that they will have to do the right thing and not just something that there lawyer say is right.
Next meeting?
|
January 22, 2010
When's the next board meeting? We need to show up and air our disgust at this RIDICULOUS amount of spending!!! Then if they don't hear us, we need to get EVERY TV station in town to show up and show to the entire public how arrogant and self-serving this board is! I promise to be there.
It's real simple
|
January 22, 2010
As long as Brock runs everything, there will never be a reponsive, ethical, honest, functional Cobb County BOE. It's tougher now without the Fa ility Group, but someone must take the money.

Good luck Cobb.
The Voice
|
January 21, 2010
During normal times, a retreat usually is twice the time needed.. but in this case.. they REALLY need it.

Alison Bartlet and crew need to put their heads back on straight and find something else to get in the news.. like school bus maintenance, the effects of making AYP versus the $100million jail, continued outreach to teachers and parents,

a different perspective on school administration.

The way this got out of hand from a few questions is what identified the problems of the past board.

Perhaps the staff may have something to do with it.. or maybe haven't had enough to do with it.

Concepts, strategies, the duties of the board to secure a safe, learning environment. I hope we hear about those things from the retreat.. and I hope that Alison doesn't try to stay away.

The school board battle is not going well.. maybe it's time to do it... retreat.
Cobb Teacher
|
January 21, 2010
It is incredulous to me how the board members have the audacity to squander $5,800.00 on a team building retreat when we have no pens or pencils at my school and have been told to be careful with paper supplies as they are dwindling. UNBELIEVABLE!!! But then again, their total disregard for what is best for students and teachers takes a backseat to the decisions or whims of the board members.
80rcbxr
|
January 21, 2010
are you kidding me? wait a minute! I'll say it louder. ARE YOU FREAKING KIDDING ME???????? What a bunch of idiots. The Cobb school board wants to know why there were kept in the dark about a grand jury investigation?? How about answering why they make all of their decisions and keep the public in the dark. What a bunch of dumb idiots. Give me a break! They should all be FIRED along with Sanderson!
stop the drama
|
January 21, 2010
In the words of Rodney King...can't everyone just get along? Constant conflict and drama doesn't solve anything- it just creates sides and more animosity. We need to look at who we are really hurting- the kids and the numerous dedicated teachers/paras/cafeteria workers/bus drivers who go the extra mile for our kids on a daily basis. This makes me sad that we can't be mature enough to look at the big picture here. It's about the kids- period.

I'm glad they are going on the retreat- yes- it's 1/3 of a paraprofessional's salary but if it will help bring some resolution and stop the craziness-that's got to be a good thing.
Tetrazzini/slope/ecm
|
January 21, 2010
Apparently you three do not understand that the board works for the people. Alison Bartlett is the only one who questions the boards actions due to the people she works for requesting answers. tetrazzini does not watch or know what is going on at the board meetings. Alison Barlett and David Morgan were the only two questioning extending the useless superintendents contract due to there being NO data to show he was performing to receive a raise or contract. A board that is working as a team would notify the rest of the board. Holli Cash is so useless. PLEASE VOTE THESE PEOPLE OUT!
bus driver
|
January 21, 2010
hey "just wondering" wake up, or maybe im wrong..

This borad is out of control, if not whay is the Grand Jury investagating them? Read, listen, grasp, there are jus to many problems going on here...

MDJ keep up the good work please, please...
S. Slope
|
January 21, 2010
Alison is a woman scorned because she rode her

bid to be the Board iconoclast down a blind

alley last month. Her effectiveness on this BOE is as compromised as that of 5 of the other members. D. Morgan is the one left standing because he's has yet to become enamored with the sound of his own voice; a trap the other 6 members have often fallen into. In the case of this Board there has been more loose talk than governance. They (including Alison) have made it about themselves instead of the school district,

thus damaging the credibility of a stellar school

system. This current board will never achieve

solidarity.

Former Teacher
|
January 21, 2010
Being an educator, I've always tried to support my administration and school board. They are supposed to have the best interest of our students as their priority. However, I'm having trouble with this group. Although I feel the MDJ likes to stir the pot, I keep seeing and hearing things that this Board is doing that disturb me. I still have not been shown any proof that this "balanced calendar" is going to vastly improve my childrens education. If you can't be open and honest with your own board members, how can you be open and honest with your constituents? Sad.....
Cappela
|
January 21, 2010
AB is trying to extract her pound of flesh as

payback for her debacle last month, with the

bottom line being that this BOE has been rendered

totally ineffective by their internal squabbles,

by the unrelenting attacks of the MDJ, and by

their own clumsiness. Rather than retreating,

they'd do better by the public if they just

didn't meet until every person on this board

has left or been re-elected. Now, there is no

way this Board can work together. They are too

busy figuring out ways to drop dimes on each other.
East Cobb Mom/Lawyer
|
January 21, 2010
According to the Georgia Code, grand juries have the power whenever eight or more members deem it necessary to form a committee and inspect the county board of education or the county school superintendent. Thus, it does not appear a prosecutor or other official has to bring the issue to their attention first. They can decide to inspect on their own.
East Cobb Mom/Lawyer
|
January 21, 2010
I'm not sure about state grand juries, but in the federal system, while the grand jurors and the prosecutors can't reveal what happens in the proceedings, witnesses are free to talk.
East Cobber
|
January 21, 2010
John Abraham has lost focus as to why he ran for this office. I hope he keeps one promise, not to run again for the board.
Irony
|
January 21, 2010
To prove to the Grand Jury that she was serious about no more 'secretive' actions, Crowder-Eagle promptly her the Grand Jury testimony and findings from the rest of the Board and the public.
GRRR!
|
January 21, 2010
This retreat needs to be CANCELLED IMMEDIATELY, and not just for the reasons Bartlett mentioned, but due to fiscal concerns. Cobb employees took a 2 percent paycut. Teachers had one day eliminated from their conracts (ie furlough). As we speak, three furlough days are in the works. There is also talk of cutting staff. $5800 may not sound like much, but one penny is too much for a "retreat" under such circumstances.
West Cobb Mom
|
January 21, 2010
People don't you see this is a subculture that breeds egomaniacs that feel they are superior to all other living beings. That is why the BOE make decisions without taxpayer approval. That is why the Transportation is in the shape it is in. After all it is our money they are spending or should I say wasting. Holli Cash is a joke or a good actress. Crowder-Eagle states she will comply with the Grand Jury and see that the publics opnion is heard. First order of business should be to give the public more than 30 minutes to address the board in their meetings. I am ashamed to admit I am a Cobb taxpayer that has allowed this board to waste money, be disrespectful to us and allow intimidation of employees to the extent of Grand Jury involvement.

We should start with Bartlett and build a board with her integrity and committment around her.
Samuel Adams
|
January 21, 2010
No one said Bartlett is a saint, but come on (people who continue to attack her)-- she is the only one with the courage to stand up and ask questions. The fact that Abraham and Eagle were at the Grand Jury mere days before their orchestrated show attacking Bartlett is reprehensible, and shows that even this planned retreat is a pile. Eagle has no intention of building a consensus, a team or even of including her fellow board members in matters pertaining to the business of the people.
Long Time Observer
|
January 21, 2010
Of course Grand Jury inquiries are held in confidence, but when the Board of Education is called to testify, all members should have been notified (unless some secrecy was involved among Board members).

We definitely need to have an elected School Superintendent as well as elected Board members. It will prevent empire-building by a sitting Superintendent. As it is, recent Superintendents seem to fill the central office staff with cronies. Our school policies seem to be made by s very select group of individuals, most of whom we do not even know exist.
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.