Cobb, Marietta schools choose not to 'Race to Top'
by Jon Gillooly
jgillooly@mdjonline.com
January 21, 2010 01:00 AM | 1202 views | 10 10 comments | 15 15 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA - Gov. Sonny Perdue announced Wednesday that Georgia has submitted an application to the U.S. Department of Education for the first round of federal Race to the Top grants, although neither the Cobb nor Marietta City school districts are part of that application.

Perdue said Georgia stands to receive up to $462 million over four years to implement its plan if selected.

The Race to the Top fund is a $4 billion grant opportunity provided in President Barack Obama's American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 to support new approaches to improve schools. The fund is available in the form of competitive grants to encourage and reward states that are creating conditions for education innovation and reform.

The application also calls for Georgia to adopt and implement common curricular standards and internationally-benchmarked assessments that indicate Georgia's ability to compete within a globally-connected economy, Perdue said in a press release.

Twenty-three local school districts have signed on to partner with the state in implementing Georgia's Race to the Top plan. These districts, which make up 41 percent of public school students in Georgia, include Atlanta, Ben Hill, Bibb, Burke, Carrolton, Chatham, Cherokee, Clayton, DeKalb, Dougherty, Gainesville, Gwinnett, Hall, Henry, Jones, Meriwether, Muscogee, Rabun, Richmond, Rockdale, Spalding, Valdosta and White.

Perdue said the state will work closely with these systems to implement the ideas contained in the application. Fifty percent of the funds awarded to Georgia will be distributed to the local partners to enact the Race to the Top reforms. The state will study the effectiveness of these practices to identify and scale up those that prove to be effective.

In a Jan. 4 memo to the Cobb school board, Superintendent Fred Sanderson recommended the district wait to find out more before seeking any of the money. Marietta City Schools Superintendent Dr. Emily Lembeck said her system didn't apply for the grant because it's not eligible. After the state submits its application this month and finds out if it is awarded the grant or not, local school systems that qualify as "low performing" will be contacted to participate. While Marietta has its share of economically disadvantaged students, the system is not considered a low performing district and therefore, "We do not qualify," Lembeck said.

U.S. Rep. Tom Price (R-Roswell) ripped the federal program.

"While the lure of federal money is always tempting, the cost of this slush fund will be felt through the further erosion in local control of education and more power to the federal government. Like the rest of the stimulus, this program relies on the false premise that all our solutions reside in Washington," Price said.

U.S. Rep. Phil Gingrey (R-Marietta) was equally critical.

"While I applaud the president for his commitment to improving our country's educational system, I believe that this is, once again, an attempt to give the federal government more control over our schools. In the over 40 years since the creation of the Department of Education, Washington's involvement in local education has not narrowed the achievement gap between disadvantaged students and their peers," Gingrey said.

State and local educators are in the best position to measure individual student progress, provide resources to those students in the most need, and know how to best use technology in the classroom, and they should have the maximum flexibility to make these important decisions, Gingrey said.

"Yet, the Race to the Top Fund only will create more bureaucracy diverting the attention of educators from their real duty - improving educational opportunities for their students," Gingrey said. "Furthermore, Race to the Top will pick winners and losers among applicants, leaving the distinct possibility that the achievement gap we are trying to close will only widen. Additionally, as I understand it, a school district like Marietta would not even be eligible to apply for these grants, even though the program is being funded with taxpayer money."

State Superintendent of Schools Kathy Cox is a supporter of the grant, but the two Cobb candidates running against her this year have concerns. Retired educator and former state Rep. Roger Hines of Acworth, a Republican vying for Cox's seat, called it the federalization of education. And retired Cobb educator Dr. Beth Farokhi, who is running on the Democrat ticket for the state school superintendent's seat, said it is unacceptable to require states to link student achievement data to individual teachers, which Race to the Top mandates.

"Our students need to be assessed on how they improve over a year in multiple ways, not just one test score. An evaluation of a teacher also cannot and should not be determined based on the test scores of their students," Farokhi said.

But U.S. Rep. David Scott (D-Smyrna) is a supportive of the application.

"Georgia has an extraordinary opportunity in the Race to the Top Fund grants program," Scott said.

"Our state has had its share of challenges in education, and this grant program provides states with the potential to receive federal backing to support improvements to our schools. The Race to the Top program will encourage states to improve teachers who are not effective, and to identify advances in student achievement and successful instructional practices. I strongly support Georgia to meet the requirements of this grant, by means of an ambitious plan for education reform. This grant opportunity is too valuable not to pursue, and all Georgians will benefit from their support," Scott said.

The U.S. Department of Education estimates that round one winners will be announced in April 2010. Forty states and the District of Columbia submitted Race to the Top applications.
comments (10)
« Vela McClam Mitchell wrote on Monday, Jan 25 at 05:21 PM »
To all of you. It's about the children. It's also about our country. Our children will compete on a world stage. We need to stop the fighting and start working together before we find ourselves living in a substandard country with kids who can't compete. Don't you realize that with excellent education, you won't have to worry about taking care of unemployed people because with education, they will become innovators and learn to take care of themselves.

Don't you understand that we all have to play a part in the success of these children. Not just the teachers, but the parents as well, along with those of us in the community who don't have children in the schools. It matters to me because I don't want to pay for people later who we chose not to educate. Because, believe me, we will pay. We will pay when they are in prison. We will pay when we keep moving from neighborhood to neighborhood trying to find a safe haven from crime. We will pay when all the jobs are in other countries with a more educated work force. Please stop the nonsense and start working together. I am so sick of Republicans vs Democrats. Just remember this problem has been here for awhile rather a Republican or Democrat is in the White House. These children need our help now. Stop the bickering and start doing something now!!
« East Cobb Mom wrote on Friday, Jan 22 at 03:12 PM »
Also, while there is still plenty of debate about how to identify effective teachers, there is no debate that empirical research shows that the single most important school-related factor for student achievement is the teacher. It's not the school or the curriculum or the class size. It's the teacher. Race to the Top encourages states to develop ways to identify effective teachers and then develop programs that train others teachers to do what they do, to scale it up. In my view, this is an excellent use of our tax dollars. I think we can figure out how to train, hire and keep good teachers much more easily and inexpensively than we can figure out how to fix parents who are not involved in their children's lives or neighborhoods that lure children off the education path. Those are societal ills school reform can do little about. Yet, they will persist. So, we have to figure out how to teach -- and teach well -- children who come from those environments. That's the nut that Race to the Top is encouraging states to crack.

However we determine our merit-based pay and retention (test scores, evaluations, credentials, etc. or a blend), the days of purely tenure-based retention need to be over.
« East Cobb Mom wrote on Friday, Jan 22 at 02:23 PM »
Response, I'm sorry your students parents have not shown up. Teachers have a tough job, no doubt about it. And, I suspect you're one of the good ones. But, you probably know there are bad ones "doing time" in your school, too. Have you read the Atlantic Monthly article? Before you respond, read it -- all the way through. Then, I'd love to hear more about what you have to say. But, I agree with the article's basic premise that nothing contributes more to a child's educational success than the teacher. I good teacher is worth his or her weight in gold. We can't do anything about the families and neighborhoods that poor children go home to each day. That's just a reality. So, if we really want to turn our schools around we need to figure out how to identify good teachers who can teach those children well, train more teachers to do what they're doing and get rid of the dead wood.
« to the teacher wrote on Friday, Jan 22 at 01:56 PM »
i will agree with you i believe parents should take the role of being a parent. I believe the teacher does not feel like one i believe they feel like a daycare teacher.
« cobbmom wrote on Thursday, Jan 21 at 06:44 PM »
I'm so sick of the partisanship in the US government. The Republican representatives from Georgia thought No Child Left Behind was a great idea, but it has torn the education system to shreds. I'm sure the poster Thank Goodness thought it was great even though it gave the federal government more control over the school system. Thank Goodness, are you willing to pay more in property taxes to make up the shortfall in the school budget? I doubt it. The schools need help and the politicians need to ask educators for assistance rather than thinking they know it all. But the Republicans of Cobb County choose to believe that a Democrat can't have a solution or be willing to work on anything bi-partisan. Truly pathetic that you would rather see the students go without than accept something from a Democrat. By the way, I'm not a Democrat, I simply get my news from a source other than Fox so I don't believe Democrats are from Satan.
« Rsponse East Cobb Mo wrote on Thursday, Jan 21 at 05:26 PM »
Apparently, you are not a teacher. I just had five scheduled conferences with parents this past week. None of those parents came to their scheduled conference that they confirmed. I rescheduled and only two had shown up. I am on my third reschedule. All of those parents children are at risk. Why should I be paid based on student test scores when the students do not do their homework, the parents do not show up for conferences, the parents do not sign the agenda, the parents do not make sure their children do their homework, and I can not get them to help their children? The public has no clue as to how hard we work and receive no help from the parents. Please do not criticize the county for not buying into a program that will penalize good teachers. If you were not aware, Obama's head of education came from Chicago. This man closed down schools and blamed teachers for failing students. A study just came out that those very students who were from those schools and placed in successful schools, are failing at the new schools. It is the student who decides their own fate and success in school. If a student makes the choice to not study or learn, the best teacher in the world will not make a difference.
« Cobbmom wrote on Thursday, Jan 21 at 05:13 PM »
this it to thank goodness, first of all Cobb did not aply because of its SPLOTS tax second cobb has the top schools in the nation so im sorry for that you are so ignorant
« Curious ? wrote on Thursday, Jan 21 at 03:04 PM »
Cherokee and Gwinnett are going for the bucks for student/school improvement but Cobb does not seem interested and Marietta "claims" to be unqualified ? Sounds fishy to me ?
« East Cobb Mom wrote on Thursday, Jan 21 at 03:01 PM »
I'm not so sure opting out of this is such a good idea. There is an interesting article in this month's Atlantic about what makes an effective teacher. It points out that one of Race to the Top's goals is to push states to figure out better ways to evaluate teachers and identify those that are effective and get rid of those who are not. The NEA, the largest teacher union, of course opposes Race to the Top, using this same trope that the federal government is muscling in on something that should be local. Local control of teacher hiring and retention. As Dr. Phil would say, "How's that working for ya?" Not too good, I'd say.
« Thank Goodness wrote on Thursday, Jan 21 at 10:29 AM »
They finally made at least one good decision. This money comes with too many ties to an administration that believes in brainwashing our children a la William Ayers (Weather Underground, socialist, radical, U. of Chicago education profeessor when he should have been in jail all those years). I'm actually surprised Cobb isn't taking the bait, but I guess when you are so corrupt, the idea of opening their files to the feds scares the bejeebers out of them. Is there ANY oversight of this monstrous district with its monstrous budget? It's looking more like the federal government each day. Isn't Cobb supposed to be a majority Republican county? How can the Republicans on the board justify what the district has become?