Needed: Remedy for Congress' 'gigantic ineptitude'
by Rod Paramoure
Columnist
September 13, 2009 01:00 AM | 432 views | 2 2 comments | 4 4 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Facing the need to save on expenses, the Cobb County school system recently decided to eliminate about 20 percent of its school bus stops. Not surprisingly, when parents strongly objected, most of the cuts were rescinded.

This raises several questions. One is: what did the school system expect the reaction to be? Another is: do they really know how many eliminated bus stops it takes to provide the million dollar savings anticipated? Still another is: does the public trust the school system's competence? Probably not.

I am confident that the school system's employees are as intelligent and hard-working as those in any other enterprise. They simply lack the experience and training needed to run such a large, multi-faceted organization.

Even their governing body - the school board - is composed of well-meaning citizens who, by and large, are little better prepared than the average parent to oversee such a complex organization.

The Cobb County School System is not alone in having management problems. The City Council of Marietta, by its ventures into hotels, real estate and parks, has demonstrated something akin to a governmental "Peter Principle" that an organization can work well at one level, but fail when it undertakes too much.

But, the problems besetting our local organizations are minor compared to the chaos that reigns in our giant national bureaucracy.

Most government organizations are simply too large to work effectively. Federal agencies, because they are the farthest removed from the watchful eye of the public, are also the least manageable. Can you think of a single federal agency that is known for its efficiency or for its response to the public's concerns?

Medicaid is acknowledged to be overrun with fraud, but the program's administration appears unable to control the losses. The Postal Service cannot make a profit, in part because it is assigned a money-losing task. The safety of our airways is in doubt because the government has never been capable of installing a modern computer-controlled traffic system.

Why are federal agencies so prone to ineptitude? It is not necessarily that federal workers are personally incompetent, but that the agencies they struggle in are designed by the most incompetent component of our government: the congress.

Who knows what motivates Congress to create new laws? Do not most laws seek to "correct" some aspect of a law previously passed? Once a "need" is perceived, laws are written by congressional staffers whose jobs are to write text that most of us will not fully understand. The proposed laws are then voted on by senators and representatives, many of whom are so "busy" that they have to rely on other staffers to tell them what the bills actually say.

It is probably accurate to say that almost no one in Congress will have fully understood the law's content. Even fewer will have considered the inevitable, unintended and unexpected consequences. Congress sends the law, with its inscrutable wording, to an administration that is not competent to implement it. High level administration bureaucrats will make political decisions about implementation; and lower level bureaucrats will try to act on finer points that even the laws originators did not understand.

One need only look at the recent TARP, "Stimulus" bill and the "cash for clunkers" programs to confirm that Congress often ignorantly passes laws that are essentially inoperable. Any law that approaches 1,000 incomprehensible pages is guaranteed to be impossible to administer effectively.

Is there a remedy for this gigantic ineptitude? We can only hope that strong public scrutiny and demand for smaller, more responsive government will have some effect on our "public servants." Perhaps we could give congress a year off and just let the bureaucracy catch up!

Rod Paramoure is a technical writer and lives in east Cobb.
Comments
(2)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Grognard
|
September 18, 2009
To Mr. Rod Paramoure;

I read your article, carefully, twice. Every single word was....spot on. I was only a little disappointed in the proposed solution. American voters don't react until they're threatened and they don't know they're threatened until the media tells them. See the problem? I cringe to recall an old poly-sci adage, "People get the kind of government they deserve." Maybe that's why we're in trouble.

Please contribute more to the MDJ. They need the help.

Grognard
comsequences
|
September 15, 2009
ELECTIONS have them. If you're not happy with your elected officials, and we can count among these both the Cobb County School Board as well as the US Congress and President Obama, then you either shold've worked harder in the last election or get your whining rearside in gear to support the candidate(s) of your choice in the next election. What is it with the right wingers....unhappy with the results of the last election all they can do is sling mud, smears and top it off with a whole bunch of whining...and all this ridiculous waste of energy from the same crew of people who claim to be "patriotic defenders" of our representative democracy and the "party of individual responsibility". How laughable...just a mob of angry whiners if you ask me.
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.