Obama's scheduled address to kids drawing criticism
by Marcus E. Howard
mhoward@mdjonline.com
September 04, 2009 01:00 AM | 1462 views | 19 19 comments | 9 9 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA - President Barack Obama is scheduled to deliver a national address to school students across the country on the importance of taking responsibility for their success in school, and some Cobb conservatives are not happy about it.

The president will speak at noon Tuesday from Wakefield High School in Arlington, Va. The address will be broadcast live via the Internet on the White House's Web site, www.whitehouse.gov, and televised live on C-SPAN.

Obama is scheduled to talk for 15 to 20 minutes. The U.S. Education Department is providing educational resources for teachers. Classroom activities for students in pre-kindergarten through 12th grade can be found at www.ed.gov.

The planned speech has sparked an outcry from conservatives across the country and in Cobb. Minnesota Congressman John Kline, a Republican, has demanded that the president publicly release his remarks in advance, which the White House plans to do several hours beforehand, online, so parents can read it.

Michael Optiz, president of the conservative Marietta-based Madison Forum, said he is specifically opposed to the White House sending out educational material related to Obama's speech. He said doing so violates the law.

On Thursday, he sent an e-mail to more than 100 of the forum's members and e-mail list guests, opposing allowing students to watch the address and linking Obama's education policy to a 1960s radical.

"We need to understand how Georgia's children will be subject to this and other classroom propaganda discussions supporting Obama's directions using William Ayers' classroom techniques to indoctrinate children," Optiz wrote.

Sherri Reese of Kennesaw has two daughters who attend Hayes Elementary School in grades three and five. She is against allowing the president's address be heard in schools and said she will not allow her daughters to watch.

"Talking to my children about their personal educational goals is my job as a parent, not the job of government employees," said Reese, who sits on the Madison Forum's advisory board. "If a teacher were to do this, they should ask parents to join in such a project."

In an interview with the Associated Press, Heather Higginbottom, White House deputy policy director, said, "I think it's really unfortunate that politics has been brought into this."

"It's simply a plea to students to really take their learning seriously. Find out what they're good at. Set goals. And take the school year seriously."

She noted that President George H.W. Bush made a similar address to schools in 1991. Like Obama, Bush drew criticism, with Democrats accusing the Republican president of making the event into a campaign commercial.

Schools do not have to show the speech. Districts in states including Texas, Illinois, Virginia and Wisconsin have decided not to show it to students.

The Cobb School District has made it optional for its schools to participate. In a message posted on the district's Website, Cobb Schools Superintendent Fred Sanderson wrote:

"The District has confirmed that the speech will remain available for viewing on the White House web site following the live broadcast, which provides an excellent opportunity for parents to watch this historic presentation with their children at home if they so choose. We encourage schools to recommend this option, and to also provide information to parents about how they can view the speech with their children."

Sanderson said that if schools want to incorporate the speech into their curricular activities, "they may do so on a voluntary basis provided they notify parents in advance and provide an opportunity for students to opt out of the broadcast. Students who do not participate will not be penalized in any way."

Officials in the Cobb district said the schools and central office have received quite a few calls about Obama's address, mostly from parents wondering whether or not it's mandatory.

Officials with the Marietta School District also said it will make watching the president's address optional. A letter will be sent to parents today stating that the speech will be available for students to view, but students will not be penalized if they decide not to participate, according to the district.

The U.S. Education Department invites students of all ages, teachers and administrators to participate in the address. It's launching an "I am What I Learn" video contest. On Tuesday, students age 13 and older will be invited to respond to Obama's challenge by creating 2-minute videos describing how they intend to improve their education and what role education will play in fulfilling their dreams.

The videos should be uploaded to YouTube by Oct. 8 and can be in the form of a video blog, public service announcement, documentary or music video. The public will then vote to determine the top 20 finalists. Those videos will be reviewed by a panel of judges, including Education Secretary Arne Duncan, who'll choose three winners. Each winner will receive a $1,000 cash prize.

The Associated Press contributed to this report
Comments
(19)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Tired of this....
|
September 05, 2009
For me, the premise behind any President wanting to address our nation’s students and encourage them to do well and stay in school is wonderful. It’s admirable and may take some kids who are headed in the “wrong” direction and set them straight.

Where I take issue is with the federal government issuing lesson plans and telling teachers what to do. The Federal Government is not supposed to be involved in the running of our local schools. Curriculum is up to the local school district, school board, teachers and parents – NOT the Executive Branch of our Government – regardless what political party they represent.

In almost 30 years as an educator, I do not recall any president – democrat or republican – providing such a suggested lesson plan to accompany his speech.

From what I see and hear, a good portion of our country still does not trust this new president. Not enough is known about him or his past and we haven’t seen anything so far in his administration that is going to change any minds about his capabilities or intentions. If the trust were there, this whole situation would not even be an issue.

Also – it did not appear that this was a well planned and well thought out even. I know that several school officials did not even know about this even one week before the date. That is not usual with a government agency.

Yet – another reason to be skeptical….

Maria Acevedo
|
September 05, 2009
It's sad that some parents are considering not letting their children listen to our President speak to them about the importance of education and staying in school. Like others have said, it is not a Democrat or Republican issue. It is an issue that everyone can agree with, whether you voted for President Obama or not. It's a great opportunity for teachers to have a discussion, with their students, after the speech. Please don't politicize this into something it's not.
East Cobb Mom
|
September 05, 2009
Lisa Hanson, you clearly do not know what socialism is. But, I'll help you out. It isn't a speech to elementary school students about the importance of working hard in school.
GaIgnoranceIsBliss
|
September 05, 2009
For the bewildered, upset, and perplexed citizens who think it is such a nice, non-political jesture for President Obama let me give you a clue why some of your neighbors are somewhat agitated. First you need to read some in-depth history of Europe in the 30's -- what you got in high school is not enough. The rise of every socialist or communist leader included a direct appeal, then a stealing away, of the youth. Here's a clue: Nationalsozialistischer Deutscher Studentenbund.
anonymous
|
September 05, 2009
I am an Obama supporter. This is pure racism. Reagan, Bush 1, Clinton and Bush 2 all addressed schools. All white. The hysteria all around the country directed at President Obama is fueled by lack of information. My advise to those Reoublicans who are so hysterical stop listening to Fox, Limbaugh, et al.
OBrother
|
September 04, 2009
It's MY job as a parent to encourage and instill a solid hard working characteristic within my child. NOT any former, current, or future President of this or any other country. The fact that this Presidents' doctrine includes the demonization of those who do work hard and become individually successful is the reason my child will not be watching Tuesday.
An American
|
September 04, 2009
What is the matter with these people. After eight years of hell under George Bush they should get on thier right wing Christian kneees and thank

God we have a President to inspire our children to work hard in school.
a mom
|
September 04, 2009
Why, I ask, are Cobb County schools not showing the Presidential Broadcast, however these same schools feel no harm in school children taking time away from lesson plans to participate in Boosterthon Fun Runs and other events. What kind of message does this send to the children ? It's ok to take time away from school work for money earning events but not for the leader of our country. Why is it ok for children to watch a movie for before a holiday break but god forbid we let them watch a 15-20 minute speech made by the President of the United States ?
citizen of the U.S.
|
September 04, 2009
So Sherri thinks that government employees shouldn't talk to her children about their educational goals? Teachers are government employees, and teachers certainly do talk to their students about the importance of having educational goals. As several others have noted in response to this article, it seems to be less about respecting the office of President of the United States and showing respect for the President, who is taking the time to encourage students to study and do the best they can so that they can be successful when they grow up than it is sour grapes because a Democrat won the Presidential Election and there's a hysterical perception among conservatives that he's a "socialist", if not much worse, a communist. It is absolutely insane to infer that the President is attempting to indoctrinate students into a reprehensible life philosophy because he is making a speech to encourage them to study and do their best. His encouragement to apply oneself and study is a lesson that was apparently lost on all the naysayers who are upset about this speech, because they obviously failed to pay attention and learn when they were in school, otherwise they would not be so eager to display their ignorance by promoting the agenda of the Madison Forum members and conservative "shock-talk" radio hosts.
marietta businessman
|
September 04, 2009
Maybe if more parents took an interest in their childerns education,(that is not doing the work for their children) we would not need to have the President remind the students about the importance of working hard. If just one student does not drop out because they were indirectly or directly encouraged by the President to work hard in school, then that would be a success.
Give me a break
|
September 04, 2009
Why is this being politicized?? I didn't vote for Obama and don't agree with many of his policies but this is a speech by the president on the importance of education. When did the importance of education become a Democratic /Republican issue? I like to think our children are smarter than adults give them credit for.
no way
|
September 04, 2009
So, let me get this straight...

We basically require every school child to pledge their allegiance to the flag and our country five days a week.

Yet, when the president of THAT VERY SAME COUNTRY wants to tell them of the importance of the education and good study habits, we freak out and scream HELL NO????

As much the last president made me head hurt, I still had my daughter watch every State of the Union Address (all painful 8 of them), because he was our PRESIDENT, love him or not.

This saddens me and angers me beyond all comprehension.
anonymous
|
September 04, 2009
This is a rid1culus public outcry. The man is the President of The United States, and for parents to refuse to let children hear him speak is certainly their right, but reeks of partisan paranoia. When I was in first grade, we had to learn how to spell Eisenhower. My parents were old line Southern Democrats, but certainly didn't raise a stink about that or the fact that his picture hung in the classroom.
lisa hanson
|
September 04, 2009
Can you say "SOCIALISM?"
East Cobb Mom
|
September 04, 2009
This is the first time I've actually thought Fred Sanderson had the right end of the stick. I have no problem with the President of the United States, whether Republican or Democrat, speaking to my elementary school kids about the importance of education.
David W
|
September 04, 2009
Where is the viewpoint of those that support hearing about the importance of education? With the high dropout rate, I am personally open to everyone talking about education in an informed manner to our children. Democrat or Republican. Governor or President. Last thought...Teachers are government employees. So yes, while it is a parents job to speak with their kids about education, government employees do it every day.
anonymous
|
September 04, 2009
Does this remind you of Hilter's Youth?
LeeTB
|
September 04, 2009
The ignorance astounds me. And we wonder why education in Georgia remains at the bottom of the list? Here's an idea: keep your children out of school on the day of the President's speech and take them to Walmart.

God forbid they have to listen to the President's speech on forming educational goals.

where were they?
|
September 04, 2009
Where were all these infantile and hyper-sensitive GOP parents when President Bush went to read "My Pet Goat" to Florida elementary school students back on September 11th 2001? Look, if the country being under attack back then couldn't stop Bush from reading to those students I seriously doubt a little manufactured outrage by right wing hyperventilators will keep President Obama from speaking next week. Oh, and kudos again to the Marietta Daily Journal for providing a ready outlet for immature behavior by local right wingers that's really more suitable for a pre-school.

*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.