Lee has the Braves but is still looking for votes
by Joe Kirby, Otis A. Brumby III and Lee B. Garrett, - Around Town Columnists
November 16, 2013 12:51 AM | 4972 views | 6 6 comments | 109 109 recommendations | email to a friend | print
THINK OF COBB COMMISSION Chairman Tim Lee as the manager of a baseball team. It’s the bottom of the ninth in the final game of the World Series. The score is tied and he has runners on second and third. All he needs to do is get one of them across home plate. Can he do it? Is his best bet to swing for the fence on every pitch? Or would he and his team be better served by praying for a last-second rain delay that gives him more time to strategize and the fans more time to digest that strategy?

That scenario is roughly analogous to where Lee finds himself this weekend in his effort to lock up a deal that would bring the Atlanta Braves to Cobb County for the next 30 years.

Lee is predicting a unanimous vote by his commission on whether to green-light the deal to bring the Braves here. That vote is slated to take place Nov. 26.

Setting aside for a moment the questions of whether Lee will be able to get those votes, and the question of whether the move makes economic sense, let’s look at whether the deal makes political sense for those who must make the decision.


AS THIS was written, Lee and Northwest Cobb Commissioner Helen Goreham were on record as strongly supporting it. JoAnn Birrell appears to be leaning toward supporting the project based on a generic email reply Thursday afternoon from her county account, stating, “Based on the information I have seen thus far, this is a positive move forward for the economic development of Cobb County.” East Cobb Commissioner Bob Ott has expressed both support and reservation for the stadium in his district and Southwest Cobb Commissioner Lisa Cupid was considered the vote Lee was least likely to get.

Lee does not have to face voters until 2016, a year before the stadium is due to open. At the moment there is tremendous euphoria in much of the county over the announcement. The deal is structured in ways that avoid a direct property tax increase for those outside the Cumberland/Galleria area. So opposition is likely to hinge on three factors:

• Whether the public perceives as “a tax increase” the proposal to extend for an additional 30 years the parks bond taxes now due to expire in 2017 and 2018. The bonds total 0.33 mills worth of debt service, equivalent to $26 a year on the owner of a $100,000 house. Lee and stadium supporters argue it is a “continuation” of a voter-approved tax, not a new tax or a tax increase;

• Whether the county will take adequate measures to mitigate the stadium’s impact on traffic in the already congested I-75/285/Cobb Parkway corridor;

• And whether Lee and his commission are transparent and have given the public sufficient time to digest the funding proposal, which has more moving parts than a Porsche engine.


LEE TOOK A LEAD ROLE in trying to persuade the public to support the 2012 TSPLOST referendum, which would have levied a 1 percent sales tax to fund transit improvements (initially planned as rail, then amended to bus) up the I-75 corridor to Cobb from Atlanta, and which was creamed by voters 2-1. He surely is finding selling the Braves move much easier: Just look at the map released by the Braves showing where their ticket buyers originate.

But will we see the Braves move swamped by a repeat of the tidal wave of anti-tax opposition that engulfed the TSPLOST? Probably not. The taxes for this proposal are targeted in focus, rather than an across-the-board sales tax. Many tax opponents are also Braves fans and will be happy not to have to drive to Turner Field on southside Atlanta. And the less-than-two-week time frame is much more compressed that the summer-long campaign for and against the TSPLOST.


The political calculus is also intriguing for Mayor Kasim Reed and Ott. Sources confirm that several of Reed’s key supporters had to remind Reed that any future statewide race would require Reed to win votes in the critical suburbs, including Cobb, which would explain Reed’s apparent change in tone the day after the announcement, when he stated, “We are not losing anything. The Braves are still in the region so I don’t fee like this is a loss.” However, reading between the lines of his remarks Tuesday, Reed subtly attached toxic buzz words to the Braves deal by mentioning the $450 million (turning out to be $300 million) price tag “liberal” Cobb Countains would pay and that Cobb should expect light rail to follow the Braves to Cobb. No doubt Reed hoped to drum up the same sentiment that torpedoed the transit heavy TSPLOST in 2012.

AT has also has been informed that downtown Atlanta political and business interests have targeted Ott as a political pawn in their plan to try and delay the vote, giving Reed and others time to kill the move. Sources report political operatives have been hired to manipulate the tea party and other conservative activists to try and pressure Ott to delay or vote against the deal Nov. 26.

Gov. Nathan Deal, however, read the political tea leaves correctly this week and quickly expressed his clear conviction about the Braves move and he was “glad they are going to stay in Georgia” shortly after a meeting with Reed.


ON THE OTHER HAND, Lee has, completely unexpectedly, maneuvered Cobb into position to spirit away one of downtown Atlanta’s trademarks. It’s as stunning a turn of events as if Reed had announced that his city had purchased and was moving The Big Chicken.

And while the Braves deal has more zeroes, the proposal is certainly less one-sided than many of the development deals offered by states and communities to lure business and industry in recent decades.

Support for the TSPLOST pretty much evaporated once it moved beyond the Cobb Chamber and the Cumberland Improvement District in the Galleria area. Not so with the Braves. They are a true Georgia icon, and as the aforementioned map proves, Cobb County is the very heart of their fan base. Moreover, the TSPLOST would have reached into the pocket of every voter, whereas the tax hit from Braves deal would mostly touch only those close to the stadium, and is about as close to a sure-fire economic stimulator as there is.

At this juncture, the public is not expected to have an opportunity to vote directly on whether to approve the Braves deal. But it’s entirely possible that if they were given a chance to be heard via such a referendum that they would approve it — and do so by a decisive margin.

Late Friday evening, a poll was released by Georgia based Landmark Communications and Rosetta Stone Communications showing the majority of Cobb residents support the Braves move to Cobb by a margin of 57 percent to 29 percent. President of Landmark, Mark Rountree, noted, “From a political point of view, Republicans support the move even more than Democrats. Sixty-three percent of Republicans support the move while only 47 percent of Democrats say they do. This might provide political cover to that county’s Republican elected leadership who may have to work with economic development incentives.”


Synovus Chair and CEO Kessel Stelling of east Cobb rang the closing bell at the New York Stock Exchange on Wednesday as part of his bank’s 125th anniversary celebration. Stelling, who represents the 6th Congressional District (east Cobb) on the state Board of Regents, was a no-show for Tuesday’s meeting at which the Regents voted to approve the controversial merger of Kennesaw State University and Southern Polytechnic State University, and has declined to answer calls from MDJ reporters since the merger story broke early this month.

Comments-icon Post a Comment
Cobb Cop
November 20, 2013
Does it seem to anyone else that the commission could have easily completed the compensation analysis for all public safety positions in the time and effort they spent on courting the Braves? They are losing officers every day to other agencies, but they are apparently unconcerned. What does Cobb's chapter of the Fraternal Order of Police have to say about low-skilled administrative positions being in the same pay class as those who put themselves in harms way? Their silence is deafening. What has the commission done to keep the best and brightest officers? They committed funds to a Major League baseball team. Cobb will be riddled with the problems Fulton has if they do not compensate their law-enforcement and firefighters better.
J. Winter
November 19, 2013
Enjoy watching our Braves from the 285 parking lot.

November 18, 2013
Shrank Tank

I think the Cobb tax payers need Kevin O’Leary to represent them; a forty five percent owner should get part of the ticket receipts and would also get TV and cable revenue for MLB. The Braves name would be held as well if the team was moved the Braves would have to pay fifty million to retain the name. Rumor has it the Braves are on the block the owner is moving back to a less socialist country. Before you open the gift read the fine print.

I do
November 16, 2013
"• Whether the public perceives as “a tax increase” the proposal to extend for an additional 30 years the parks bond taxes now due to expire in 2017 and 2018. The bonds total 0.33 mills worth of debt service, equivalent to $26 a year on the owner of a $100,000 house. Lee and stadium supporters argue it is a “continuation” of a voter-approved tax, not a new tax or a tax increase;"

Looks like Lee has a few Obama staff working for him. It was approved till 2017 to save land in developed areas for public use.

A new Stadium is very different.
Cobb resident
November 16, 2013
I am stunned that this paper , which used to be so supportive of education, has not raised the issue of tax dollars going to the stadium at a time when teachers are losing jobs. Every national media outlet that has covered this story has mentioned it. Why hasn't the MDJ?
@ Cobb Resident
November 18, 2013
Perhaps the reason the national media and you are "stunned" is because of your collective Georgia school funding ignorance.

School property tax is entirely separate from Cobb Commission property tax, Cumberland CID voluntary property tax, car rental tax and hotel tax.

Today, your school property tax millage is 18.9. Next year, it won't be lower and could only rise to the Georgia cap of 20.0 mills.

Also, sales tax cannot fund school operations under current Georgia law applicable to Cobb County.

When built, the stadium will enhance the values of nearby properties, thereby having a positive impact on Cobb school funding.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides