Around Town: Latest sex scandal has sheriff singing another verse of the jailhouse blues
by Lee B Garrett, Joe Kirby and Otis A. Brumby
April 20, 2013 12:00 AM | 13243 views | 7 7 comments | 23 23 recommendations | email to a friend | print
A COBB SHERIFF’S SERGEANT has been demoted and a recruit fired in the latest sex-related incident involving those who run the county jail.

Sgt. Orlando Clarke, 38, a 10-year veteran of the Sheriff’s Department, was demoted to jailer as of March 4 and has been out on family-related sick leave since then, according to Sheriff Neil Warren.

“I hope he doesn’t come back,” he told Around Town on Friday. “He’s not the type of supervisor I want here. I think he’s a predator.”


CLARKE and Deputy Nadja Bauer, 24, admitted under questioning by Internal Affairs to having a had a romantic relationship, according to the sheriff. Additional allegations have been swirling that the two had trysted in a control tower overlooking one of the “pods” at the jail and in a parked car while they were working as security for the North Georgia State Fair last fall. But Internal Affairs investigators were unable to corroborate those rumors, the sheriff said.

When confronted, Bauer claimed she had initiated oral sex with Clarke in an office at the jail, a claim Clarke denied, the sheriff said. Both volunteered to take a polygraph test, which though inadmissible as evidence in court, remains a good investigative tool, the sheriff said.

“He passed his polygraph with flying colors — that he had never had sex with her or anyone else on county property while on duty. … But she failed the hell out of hers,” the sheriff said.

The test results were then sent to the GBI, which drew the same conclusions as the Sheriff’s investigators, he said.

“The only improper thing we could find they did on duty was spend extra time together at lunch, and hold hands on occasion and maybe kiss on the cheek,” he said.


“THERE WAS NO DOUBT that she and Clarke were having an ongoing relationship on the outside,” he said. “But at the end of the investigation, we determined the allegations that they had sex while on duty was not provable.

“However, because he was a supervisor, and based on several incidents where he spent too much of his time on duty with her, and bought her gifts and showed her too much attention, which was a violation of our policies, we determined that he failed to supervise her in a proper way and used poor judgment.”

“So we had an internal affairs hearing and I busted him. Took his stripes away,” he said.

Clarke had the right to appeal the decision to the Civil Service Board, but chose not to, the sheriff said.

Bauer was terminated. She was still on probationary status and no right of CSB appeal, he said.

“I felt she was too immature for the job and used poor judgment,” the sheriff said. “I didn’t feel she was someone we needed to keep. And if I could have proved anything, I would have terminated him, too.”


THE CLARKE-BAUER EPISODE is the latest sex scandal to rock the Sheriff’s Department this year. A Cobb grand jury indicted former Sgt. Alvin Blake Sutherland of Douglasville last month on 21 counts including rape, sexual assault against someone in custody and violating his oath of office. And in February Sgt. Kristopher David Travitz of Douglasville was arrested and charged with sexually assaulting a female inmate.

“I had two sergeants who committed terrible, terrible acts,” Warren told Around Town. “And I’m going to do everything I can to put them in the state penitentiary. And I guarantee that if I find any other conduct in this department that is not morally right that interferes with the operation of this department, that they will be terminated.”


ARE YOU TIRED of seeing veteran educators kicked to the curb by the Cobb School District’s Central Office? Tired of the CCSD’s rabid enforcement of a state law that requires all school employees (and volunteers) to report any suspected child abuse within 24 hours of hearing about it? A law that carries fines of up to $1,000 and a year in jail — regardless of whether the alleged assault even happened?

We’re tired of reporting about such miscarriages of justice, and many subscribers have told us they’re tired of reading about them.

And now, and to his credit, Cobb School Board Chairman Randy Scamihorn has joined those ranks.

Scamihorn raised eyeballs — and hopes — during unexpected remarks during Wednesday’s school board work session.

“I need to thank the Marietta Daily Journal,” he said. “A week ago Saturday, we had a news article about the way we do business and we’ve had two news articles in the MDJ the last week and a half and two editorials.”

Those stories, editorial and Dick Yarbrough column focused on the retirement under a cloud of respected Kell High Principal Trudie Donovan for failing to report a pair of slapping incidents involving a Kell teacher; the firings of Tapp Middle School principal Dr. Jerry Dority and counselor Yatta Collins for failing to report hearsay information; and the attempted suspension without pay of Awtrey Middle School principal Jeff Crawford for failing to report hearing of an alleged off-campus sexual assault involving two students.

As it turns out, the Cobb Solicitor’s Office has now dropped the charges against Donovan for lack of evidence and hope remains that the same thing will happen with Dority and Collins. Crawford’s hearing is next month.


CONTINUED SCAMIHORN: “The reason why I’m thanking them is we need everybody’s participation to try and improve our system. We were already looking at changes and how we do business here at the senior level. It’s not lip service. We want to try and improve and continue to improve the morale of our staff. Hopefully the MDJ articles have helped us move that ball forward and I look forward to in the near future for the MDJ to be able to publish our procedural changes and for us to continue to demonstrate that we do have our teachers and students as number one.”

Scamihorn elaborated further to Around Town on Thursday: “If policies and procedures need to be changed, then that needs to be what happens. I was uncomfortable after reading (the stories) as a retired educator and as a board member. I feel like that whatever the issues are, they need to be looked at in the immediate future.


CITY BEAT: Businessman Marshall Dye told Around Town this week that he plans to run against incumbent Ward 4 Councilman Andy Morris in this fall’s city elections. Dye, 60, has lived in Marietta since the 1970s and is owner/president of Court Makers Inc. on Marble Mill Road, Georgia’s largest tennis court-manufacturing company.

Dye serves on the Zoning and Appeals Board, to which he was appointed by then-Councilman Van Pearlberg. He’s also on the boards of Net Work Ministries and the Marietta Country Club’s Long Range Planning Committee. He previously served on the Cobb Landmarks Historical Society Board and Marietta Pilgrimage Tour of Homes Committee.

He and wife Cindy live on Church Street in the former Medford home and he is the father of two daughters, Bridget Davis and Eileen Johnson.

“Over the years I have watched WellStar Kennestone Hospital grow into the thriving facility that it is today, as well as taken part in the revitalization of the historical district right next to the hospital,” Dye said. “My goal is to help both of the areas continue to grow in harmony with each other.”

Morris won the Ward 4 seat in a special election last July to replace Pearlberg, and is running for reelection.


POLITICS: Look for Gov. Nathan Deal to sign HB 349, this year’s major criminal justice legislation, following his remarks to the Marietta Kiwanis Club on Thursday at the Marietta Hilton/Conference Center on Powder Springs Street. … Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle will host a fundraiser for state Sen. Judson Hill from 5-7 p.m. Tuesday at The Georgia Club.


THIS YEAR’S 40th annual Swordsman’s Ball benefiting the American Cancer Society Aug. 24 will take place in a different venue — the Waverly Hotel, reports Babe Atkins-Byrne. Co-chairs are Bill and Valerie Hilley and Dan and Janet O’Brien.


THIRSTY? Informed sources tell Around Town the new Starbucks in the former Krystal’s location on Whitlock Avenue just off the Square will open on Friday.

Comments-icon Post a Comment
Col. Kurtz
May 09, 2013
So ...let me get this right ...LEO's ARE capable of unethical and illegal behavior, must be big news to the law enforcement community ... !
April 22, 2013
“I hope he doesn’t come back,” he told Around Town on Friday. “He’s not the type of supervisor I want here. I think he’s a predator.”

If I were that deputy, I'd sue the sheriff's butt off for that statement. Either it's true and the deputy should have been fired instead of demoted or it is highly misleading and harmful to the deputy.
April 22, 2013
Yep. The Sheriff acknowledges he has no proof and then goes on to defame the guy. Get ready to pick up the tab for a defamation lawsuit, Cobb County taxpayers.
April 20, 2013
That's a whole lot of detail of the personal interactions of jail employees. Sounds like someone at the MDJ really likes talkin' about jail sex.
Just Sayin'....
April 21, 2013
Thanks Sheriff for that response.
Michael Tovey
April 26, 2013
Well Anonymous,

Why haven't you used your name?

Just goes to show that you want to stir things up, about something you have no knowledge about.

Sheriff Warrens statements ring true - would you like to have staff who are not trustworthy enough to be professional and perform duties they are expected to carry out?

Fortunately, 99.99% of law enforcement personnel are honest, committed to enforcing the law, and are prepared to stand up and be counted.

I retired from the Sheriffs office just over 6 months ago and was proud to serve under Sheriff Warren - Cobb residents should applaud and be grateful to have someone of his caliber!

Anyone wanting to make negative remarks about ANYONE should have the guts to use their real name!
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides