Guns don’t belong on college campuses
by Bill Maxwell
September 12, 2012 12:00 AM | 1284 views | 2 2 comments | 5 5 recommendations | email to a friend | print
On two occasions during my career as a college professor, I feared for my safety when students confronted me about their final grades.

Because of the gun violence on our campuses and in other public spaces today, I think more and more about those confrontations.

In the first instance in Chicago, a young male student said to me that I would not “get away” with the grade I had given him. Even though I was in my 20s, athletic and a former Marine, I never again relaxed on campus. The second confrontation occurred in Fort Lauderdale, when a female student brought her father to my office to argue her case for a higher grade. The father became so angry and threatening that I telephoned security to escort him and his daughter from my office.

Over the years, several colleagues have told me about similar threats. Some took the threats seriously. Others saw them as part of the job.

Call me cowardly or super-sensitive for believing that the growing gun violence on school campuses, the easy availability of guns, and laws in an increasing number of states that permit concealed weapons on campus will turn our institutions of higher learning into places of open fear.

Now 35 states have campus concealed-carry laws. The University of Colorado is the latest to join this gun-toting madness. Florida considered a concealed-firearms law in 2011, but in a rare move the GOP-led Legislature voted down the measure.

The legislation’s failure had little to do with logic or reason or common sense. It had almost everything to do with the power of Sen. John Thrasher, a St. Augustine Republican. As chairman of the Rules Committee, Thrasher persuaded lawmakers to reject the law.

Here is what transpired: On Jan. 9, 2011, 20-year-old Amy Cowie saw her twin sister die after an accidental gunshot at Florida State University from their friend’s AK-47. According to the Miami Herald, the shooting “involved a contact close to Thrasher.”

One positive outcome of this tragedy is that it encouraged Thrasher to use his power to block the law. If passed, it would have allowed students in Florida to legally enter campuses with concealed firearms.

I teach writing as an adjunct at St. Petersburg College. I vowed that if Florida passed the concealed firearms law, I would not teach on another Florida campus. I still hold that vow. I refuse to stand in front of a classroom if students have the legal right to carry firearms. And I refuse to expose my students to the potential danger of concealed firearms in their presence.

Instead of being hostages to the bullying of lawmakers obsessed with guns and paralyzed by their fear of the National Rifle Association, our colleges should be beacons of moral clarity and learning. They need to follow the findings of scholars and the observations and conclusions of physicians who treat the victims of gun violence, who are trying to develop a science-based, workable approach to dealing with the carnage.

Gun ownership has become second nature to us. How, the experts ask, can we prevent violence as a result of too many guns? To start, we need to treat the gun like a virus. Evidence shows that following each well-publicized shooting, people get caught in the contagion of buying guns either for protection or retaliation.

We need a public health approach to the problem. We need to be working on ways to prevent more harm from guns, not ways to easily own more guns.

Dr. Stephen Hargarten, a gun violence expert who treated victims of the Sikh temple shootings at the emergency department he directs in Milwaukee, told the Associated Press: “What I’m struggling with is, is this the new social norm? This is what we’re going to have to live with if we have more personal access to firearms. We have a public health issue to discuss. Do we wait for the next outbreak or is there something we can do to prevent it?”

Experts and scholars at our universities should lead this cause and not run away from it out of fear of political reprisals. And they should convince lawmakers that guns do not belong at our institutions of higher learning.

Bill Maxwell is a columnist for the Tampa Bay Times.
Comments-icon Post a Comment
September 12, 2012
Your animus towards concealed carry laws is convoluted logic at its' worse.

Every law abiding citizen in this country should have the right to protect themselves, their loved ones and their friends from those who would do them harm.

Although it is cliche' it is still a very true statement: "If you outlaw guns, only outlaws will have guns."

I know you are bright enough to realize this, but I suspect your political ideology and your need to be accepted by those who share that ideology, drives your public pronouncement and renouncement of our constitutional right to bear arms and protect ourselves.

I hope it never happens, but if and when you are put in a situation where you are responsible for your own safety and survival you will wish you had the means to protect yourself.
El Guapo
September 12, 2012
I am a college professor as well. I, too, have thought a lot about this issue and come to the conclusion that should this sort of horror occur in my classroom, the only real chance for my students and me will be return fire from other armed students. I don't want a gun myself, but have more trust in responsible gun owners than laws that are always ignored by killers and police who simply can't respond quickly enough (through no fault of their own.). I welcome reforms that will allow concealed carry on campus - we'll all be safer when that day arrives.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides