Around Town: Going negative: Is new mailer proof Lee’s hopes in jeopardy?
by Otis Brumby, Bill Kinney and Joe Kirby
Around Town Columnists
July 21, 2012 01:04 AM | 5123 views | 22 22 comments | 17 17 recommendations | email to a friend | print
IS COBB COMMISSION CHAIRMAN TIM LEE getting desperate? Friday’s mail harvest included a flier that unearthed incendiary anti-Cobb quotes from one of his leading challengers in the July 31 Republican Primary, former commission Chair Bill Byrne.

One side of Lee’s two-sided mailer (which was paid for by “Lee for Cobb”) is standard fare touting his accomplishments and recapping his platform.

The other side consists of a photo of Byrne and a quote from his testimony at a late 2000s meeting of the Polk County Election Board.

States the ad, “In 2008 Bill Byrne ran for the Polk County Commission and attacked Cobb County.”

The ad continues with a quote from Byrne’s testimony: “The last thing I wanted to do is live in Cobb County, let alone serve in Cobb County. I want to make damn sure Cobb County doesn’t move to Polk County. I live in Polk, I love this county and want to make sure that we preserve and protect this quality of life, and make sure Cobb County doesn’t move here.”

Byrne served a decade as Cobb chairman before resigning in 2002 to run unsuccessfully for governor. He ran for Cobb chair again in 2006 but dropped out before qualifying, then, ran in 2008 for a commission seat in Polk County, where he owns a horse farm. But the Polk County Elections board ultimately ruled that he was not a legal resident of that county.

Incidentally, Byrne’s 10-acre Polk house and farm were purchased in 1998 on what his critics said were favorable terms from John Moore of Marietta, who then and now was one of Cobb’s premiere zoning lawyers. The arrangement was sufficiently questionable to warrant a seven-month probe by the FBI after it was reported by the MDJ, but no charges were ever brought.

***


THE MORE IMMEDIATE QUESTION on Friday was whether the fact that Lee was resorting to such an ad indicates that his campaign is on the rocks. Candidates who are well ahead in the polls generally don’t see the need to go negative because such ads turn off so many voters, even though they usually are effective. Lee is the best-funded of the four candidates and almost certainly has bankrolled private polling on his race. Are they painting a bleak picture?

Lee has had a rocky re-election run, saddled with his support for the increasingly unpopular TSPLOST referendum and his decision last year to raise property taxes, rather than cut spending, to balance the county budget.

Another indication that Lee’s campaign might be taking on water came Friday when he suddenly seemed to hedge his support for the TSPLOST. Speaking in the third person, Lee told the MDJ’s Jon Gillooly that, “Chairman Lee felt that his vote, how he voted, was one he didn’t want to share, but he supports the referendum and the people’s choice to decide their future.”

As for the mailer, another of Lee’s challengers, retired Marine Col. Mike Boyce of east Cobb, quipped, “At least we kept the race civilized for all but the last 11 days — which might be a local record.”

***


COBB COMMISSIONERS and department heads got an unexpected email memo on Thursday notifying them that Tuesday’s commission work session would start at 2 p.m., rather than the scheduled 1:30 p.m. There was no word as to why.

They found out around noon on Friday. That’s when the Cobb Chamber of Commerce sent out an email blast of its own announcing a pro-TSPLOST rally from 12:30 to 1:30 p.m. on Tuesday. The high-profile event at the Smyrna Community Center will feature Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed as headliner with former Gov. Roy Barnes of Marietta, Cobb Commission Chair Tim Lee and Smyrna Mayor Max Bacon singing backup.

Reed — who is said by political insiders to have gubernatorial ambitions — has emerged as the metro area’s most forceful advocate for the TSPLOST in recent days. Tuesday’s event will mark his second foray into Cobb this summer touting the program. He addressed the Cobb Chamber’s Chairman’s Club on the topic last month.

Tuesday’s event is sponsored by the Cobb Chamber, the Council for Quality Growth and Citizens for Transportation Mobility.

***


THE JULY 31 TSPLOST referendum is doomed, according Around Town’s conversations late this week with current and/or former elected local leaders on an off-the-record basis.

“Those who are opposing it have been extremely persistent,” said a Marietta official. “The Chamber of Commerce has hammered those who are against it. But the ‘antis’ are handling it better. If the vote was held today it would not pass.”

That was echoed by a retired north Cobb legislator.

“It is losing big right now and will lose on Election Day,” he told Around Town.

Another elected Marietta official told Around Town he sees the proposal “struggling” in Cobb but still supports it.

“There’s no alternative out there,” he said. “If we do it again in two or four years we’d probably wind up with a real similar project list. As for the present list, I would have preferred it have more emphasis on rail and less on bus. We might not have the density for rail at this point, but we have to move in that direction.”

The fourth leader contacted mentioned “mean-spirited” comments he’d witnessed at a recent public forum on the part of TSPLOST backers.

“When people take that attitude they usually have seen poll numbers that show things are not going their way and they get angry,” he said. “And (TSPLOST proponents) are probably doing lots of polling. I mean, they have huge amounts of money. I think they see that they’re behind, and they’re getting worried and getting nasty.”

That official, whose name has appeared on both local and statewide ballots in the course of a three-decade political career, also suggested that TSPLOST advocates are guilty of “overreaching” when it comes to their ballyhooed $8 million campaign fund.

“I think they’re spending too much money too obviously and it is backfiring on them,” he said. “If they had been more subtle and not said, ‘Look at all this money we have,’ it would have helped. They basically painted a big target on themselves. They’ve just been too ‘In your face.’”

Another problem is the project list, which the official in question, a Republican, described as “weighted toward ‘feel-good liberal items’ like rail and mass transit and bicycles. The average commuter and the typical housewife just don’t relate to that stuff.”

It also hasn’t helped that backers have changed the ostensible goal of the program from traffic relief to jobs and economic development.

“If that was what it was really about, then why not say that in the first place?” he asked. “It’s hard to shift your rationale so late in the game.”

***


SPEAKING OF THE TSPLOST, two rallies are slated today. Opponents plan the 10 a.m. “Lights for Liberty” motorcade, which will consist of two laps around I-285 in the center lane with lights flashing. Meanwhile, local Untie Atlanta supporters will gather at Dave Poe’s BBQ at 660 Whitlock Ave., from 10 a.m. to noon. That’s just down the street from Cobb Elections Office, where Saturday voting will be taking place. On Monday East Cobb Commissioner Bob Ott is sponsoring a TSPLOST debate at his 7 p.m. town hall meeting at Mount Bethel United Methodist. TSPLOST backers Chuck Clay and WSB traffic reporter “Capt. Herb” Emory will square off against frequent MDJ guest columnist Ron Sifen of Vinings at the event. The church is at 4385 Lower Roswell Road.

***


THE JULY 31 primary isn’t here yet, but state Sen. Judson Hill (R-east Cobb), who’s running unopposed, is already looking ahead. He told supporters at two recent Cobb GOP events that he plans to mount a primary challenge against U.S. Sen. Saxby Chambliss (R-Moultrie) in 2014. And should he be unsuccessful, he then plans to run in 2016 against U.S. Sen. Johnny Isakson (R-east Cobb), he said.

“Good luck with that,” cracked a local politico after hearing of Hill’s plans.

Comments
(22)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
pkandul
|
July 30, 2012
ok, i was suspicious yesterday with the Saturday and Sunday paper, but today took the cake. how did Tim Lee get his sticker on the front page the 3 days in a row before the election?sohteq
so sorry
|
July 22, 2012
Around Town, that in your desire to report on Lee's negativity, you had to try to trash Bill Byrne, who is highly principled and was a highly effective commission chair.
Principled?
|
July 23, 2012
So, exactly what principle was byrne putting forth in his statement"...“The last thing I wanted to do is live in Cobb County, let alone serve in Cobb County. "

Sounds like it is: Cobb county sux and I don't want anything to do with it.

His comments combined by now running to serve in Cobb = a principle: Hypocrisy
SG68
|
July 22, 2012
Once again the Cobb Chamber and Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed are dictating the how, when and where the business of the Cobb County Government should be conducted.

Tim Lee has relinquished all control.

A sad state of affairs.

Personally I would like to see an accounting of the Cobb employees who show up for this dog and pony rally.
Elect Bill Byrne
|
July 22, 2012
He and Cobb County are made for each other.
Knowlege Is Good
|
July 22, 2012
Lee "Going Negative"? Lee "in jeopardy"? Sounds like Bill Byrne went negative all up in Cobb County's face. Sounds like Bill Byrne's the one in jeopardy. Spin it the way you want but quoting someone is not negative campaigning. Words coming directly from anyone's own mouth is very informative and knowledgeable. And as Emil Faber said, "Knowledge Is Good".
LEGITIMATE ISSUE
|
July 22, 2012
The way Burn trashed Cobb County is a legitimate issue. And he wants us (Cobb County) to vote for him. This shows he can't be trusted.
KSUsed
|
July 22, 2012
So we move the commission session because the chamber (which knows when the session usually starts) decides to have their rally for the losing Tsplost right up to the sessions usual start time......good to know who runs the commission.....vote for new and stronger commission chairman.....
dustoff
|
July 21, 2012
All of you people are forgetting that Bill Byrne and his support of th "Family Values" resolution made us the laughing stock of the nation and lost us an Olympic Venue.

Maybe he needs go back to his fancy horse farm in Polk County and leave us alone.

We do not need him of his arrogant attitude and smart mouth.
I Say
|
July 21, 2012
Chuck Clay & Capt'n Herb(Pro TSPLOST) vs Ron Sifen (Anti TSPLOST. Hmmmmm... 2 against 1! That's OK. Ron is good enough he can stand up to 3 or 4. Go gettem Ron!!!!
Had Enough
|
July 21, 2012
I was going to vote for Tim Lee until I received his latest ad containing the ugly and inappropriate criticism os Bill Byrne. I'm voting

for Bill Byrne.
Truth Hurts
|
July 21, 2012
Lee is only providing valuable information concerning Byrnes opinion of Cobb County. Byrne is only interested in power to stroke his out of control ego. I appreciate Lee providing information so voters can decide which is best for Cobb County. Byrnes past reputation speakes for itself, we cannot afford to elect Byrne.
Voted yesterday :)
|
July 21, 2012
We were ones in line to vote yesterday at the Whitlock Ave. election office. It felt good to get that done and out of the way. We voted NO to T-SPLOST. The Governor's announcement about the GA 400 tolls was welcome but he sure picked the wrong time to announce it. His political machinations and intent to sway voters toward the T-SPLOST are so obvious that we and likely many others were quite ticked off because it assumes we are dumb and easily manipulated. We went to Dave Poe's BBQ yesterday and I'm sure glad we did...would have hated to have gone today while the pro-T-SPLOST crowd was there!
I had to hold my
|
July 21, 2012
nose when voting for the chairman position. There was not a good choice, just the lesser of the evils.
Excuse me?
|
July 21, 2012
When Lee puts out the truth it is called going negative, after what all Byrne has said, some true, some NOT, and his add next to your column which directly criticizes Lee? It is important newer people know the truth about some of the things Bryne has done and said and I applaud Mr. Lee for what he has provided to help us know or remember these things. I hope he does more of the same.
Big Shanty Girl
|
July 24, 2012
Lee? Truth?: Oil? Water?

Lets See LEE
|
July 21, 2012
Tim Tax Lee - Let's see what we can negatively say about him:

Ahhhh I promise that if you vote for SPLOST we will not need a mileage increase.

Ahhhh I now have to shut down all services that the county provides - senior citizens centers, libraries, Less police and fire service, actually everything I can think of that will pull on your heartstings - so you understand that this is why I now am going to raise the mileage rate.

Ahhhh- Oh boy the best thing since slice bread T-SPLOST of course we need this - you can get out of your driveway because of all the traffic whats a little 1% tax we are the lowest you know which works for me since I like to raise taxes at least twice a year- rah rah raise the tax!!!

Ahhhhh- I forgot to mention it but of course it is on by website - strong leadership for the chamber of commerce opps I meant Cobb County - I propose another tax that will lower your property tax by a few pennies no I mean dollars.

Get real vote for LEE and pay more taxes.

We need new leadership in this county!
Lee is Best
|
July 23, 2012
I will be voting for Lee, he saved our triple A rating without cutting police and firefighters. You people would end up paying more in taxes if it were not for Lee.
Cobb Watcher
|
July 27, 2012
To say that Lee preserved our AAA credit rating is

to say that you don't have a clue as to how credit

ratings are determined. You've been listening to

Tim Lee.
Grade A for MDJ
|
July 21, 2012
Great MDJ this morning. Very interesting first and editorial pages. Thank you MDJ for keeping us informed.
w in marietta
|
July 21, 2012
judson hill is SOOOOO two-faced, I can't imagine anyone who has met him would vote for him, a "slick" political hack
Pat H
|
July 21, 2012
Thank you Sen. Hill. I will help in anyway possible to have you unseat Chambliss. I will miss you as my Senator however because you have been so responsive and responsible.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides