
Federal regulators say design flaws in the San Onofre nuclear power plant in north San Diego County, Calif., above, appear to be the cause of excessive wear in tubing that carries radioactive water through the plant. The future of the facility could balance on an inescapable question: Is it worth the money to fix it?
The Associated Press
The Associated Press
Engineers face a daunting task finding a solution for problems that knocked the seaside plant offline last winter. And even if they come up with a plan that fully addresses safety and operational issues, will it all make sense on a balance sheet?
The twin reactor plant between San Diego and Los Angeles has long been a source of lower-cost power, but its complex and costly mechanical troubles have raised questions that might have seemed unrealistic just months ago.
“Shutting down the plant, at the end of the day, might not be the worst-case scenario for shareholders or customers,” says Travis Miller, director of utilities research at equities analyst Morningstar Inc.
Two decades ago, San Onofre’s Unit 1 reactor was shut down and then dismantled when owners faced the prospect of swallowing a $125 million bill for upgrades and repairs. Oregon’s Trojan nuclear plant closed its doors in 1993, rather than replace steam generators that had leaky tubes.
Now, similar issues will be on the table for San Onofre’s two remaining reactors, shuttered as engineers try to figure out how to stop unprecedented decay in generator tubes that carry radioactive water. The plant hasn’t produced electricity since Jan. 31.
The plant normally generates enough power for 1.4 million homes. With summer here and no restart date in sight, state officials are encouraging conservation to ensure the lights stay on in southern California when temperatures and electricity use peak.
Regulators and plant owners insist the reactors won’t be restarted until all safety issues are addressed. Meanwhile, costs mount and scrutiny intensifies.
The state Public Utilities Commission plans to vote on an order next month requiring plant owners Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric to disclose the potential economic hit for ratepayers, ranging from a relatively quick restart to a permanent shutdown of the twin reactors.
The agency, which determines how much utilities can charge homeowners and businesses for electricity, plans to scrutinize the cost of replacement power, repairs and, ultimately, who gets stuck with a bill that is increasing daily, according to a draft order.











Follow us on Twitter!