Dick Yarbrough: Mt. Paran Christian made coaching change, but ... Booted It, Big Time
by Dick Yarbrough
Columnist
May 12, 2012 01:14 AM | 1417 views | 9 9 comments | 14 14 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Dick Yarbrough
Dick Yarbrough
slideshow
I have no dog in the fight that has become the controversy surrounding the Mount Paran Christian baseball program and the recent dismissal of its coach. I don’t know any of the individuals involved and don’t really need to.

I do, however, have a walking-around knowledge of dealing in the external environment and of the role of the media in that environment and it is obvious to me that the administration of MPC, including its headmaster David Tilley, the principal Eric Bradley and athletic director Mitch Jordan doesn’t have a clue.

You already know the story. The school has relieved baseball Coach Harvey Cochran of his duties. Word reached John Bednarowski, sports editor of the MDJ from a number of sources that the coach was not “religious enough” for the school’s taste.

Mount Paran Christian claims it wants to go in a “new direction” which seems a little weird when your coach compiled a 26-2 record this year. Admittedly, I can’t hit a curveball but I know enough about the game to know that about the only direction you can go after a season like that is either very slightly up or way, way down.

There has to be more to the story than that bizarre statement and that is what Bednarowski has been trying to find out. That is his job. Why would a school not rehire a very successful coach? And to his credit, he has called Tilley, Bradley and Jordan more than a dozen times and has sent them a number of emails asking for their side of the story. That is responsible journalism. No one has responded. That’s bad public relations. I assume the trio thinks if they stonewall long enough and continue to ignore the press, the controversy will simply disappear.

Of course, if all else fails, one can always blame the media for “sensationalizing.” (The newspaper has already been accused by one letter writer of turning into the National Enquirer. You knew it had to happen.)

The controversy has unleashed the bloggers who rant on both sides of the issue in anonymity. I know anonymous blogs are the latest thing these days in the media, but I hate them. If I am ever captured by al Qaida, I don’t fear death. I fear they will make me look at pictures of Barbra Streisand naked or read anonymous blogs. Both would be a fate worth than death.

The Mount Paran Christian baseball issue would have been a one-day story and I might be writing about the joys of banana pudding except for the MPC hierarchy deciding to evade the media.

By doing so, they have raised questions about the integrity of Harvey Cochran, put the new coach, Kyle Reese, in an uncomfortable situation and made a lot of people on both sides of the issue angry.

Nice going, guys.

Having spent most of my life as an external counselor, I was taught that organizations need to communicate clearly with the various publics they serve.

After 15 years on the other side of the fence as a member of the media, I am stupefied at how inept some groups can be in dealing with those publics. The Cobb EMC, the Cumberland Community Improvement District and the Ebenezer Scrooge guy who gets his jollies booting cars in downtown Marietta come immediately to mind. Now, add to that the Mount Paran Christian School.

The problem is that organizations and individuals like these develop a bunker mentality. They either ignore what the public’s reaction might be to their decisions or fail to communicate the issue adequately or resort to killing the messenger (the media.) They forget that if the public doesn’t understand or accept your arguments, you have lost. You may not lose right now, but sooner or later you will find yourself being judged by your past actions when you may need the public’s support. Why is that so hard for supposedly intelligent people to understand?

An aside: Our friends in the Legislature are going to lose the fight against limiting lobbyist expenditures. The public has already decided the answer to that one and no amount of high-minded rhetoric will convince them otherwise. The politicians might as well get ready to change the law. This one is a goner.

It is also too late for Mount Paran Christian to come out of this issue looking like a winner.

To be kind, their handling of the dismissal of the baseball coach has been clumsy and hasn’t exactly burnished their avowal to “walk in truth.”

They may have had good reasons to do what they did but they didn’t do it very well.

Stiffing the media is never a good idea. In baseball parlance, the school booted their coaching change.

You can reach Dick Yarbrough at yarb2400@bellsouth.net or P.O. Box 725373, Atlanta, Georgia 31139.
Comments
(9)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Guest1133
|
May 13, 2012
It's none of your business. Get over it.
ease teratega
|
May 13, 2012
Happy Mother's Day Harvey!
J Lands
|
May 12, 2012
You don't like anonymous bloggers! me either, lol. Hate them. Why in the world did I come here then? To see if any of those people wrote you. It is all made worse by the fact your paper then makes a column out of the junk. AT least one time they have referred to them in a news article. Journalism? I don't think so.
MediaEvaderOhNo
|
May 12, 2012
"Evade the media"? Yikes. How dare MP keep an employer/employee relationship confidential. I am sure no other employer in America would deny the MDJ access to their decisions on employment matters. What a bad school and what bad leaders. Matter of fact, will you call Home Depot 12 times for me and ask why they let my nephew go. I am sure they will be as open as a book. However, if they aren't, by all means rip them in the newspaper. I have an ax to grind, so I need your help. By all means be my messnger to the employers of the world. Talk about a bunker mentality or is it entitlement mentality? Go read a little employment law before jumping on MP or any other employer. Look at the history of this school and all the good they have done for their students and community. You guys are tearing down something good and you are too blind to see. "Clueless"? look in the mirror. Acknowledge that sometimes you are the one in the wrong. You and the "sources" John has owe MP an apology. But that will never come.

As for the administrators I am fed up with you bashing them. You do not even know them. They are good men that have dedicated their lives to their family, their faith and to the profession of helping kids reach their potential and from all I have seen they are remarkable in this.

So some hack writer comes in and smears the school and personally attacks good men based on the fact they won't talk to John. Only in America-that is all I can say. And by the way, I am happy we have freedom of the press because it makes our country the best in the world. But not everything is about the media and frankly I understand there is a price to pay in that sometimes our media fouls thinks up. I think we can agree on that if we are honest. As for PR, thanks to the careless writing this school has been unfairly critized and singled out.
esearsst wood
|
May 12, 2012
To be kind, the Marietta Daily Journal is a second tier newspaper at best. I mean who are you kidding? LOL, maybe you could remove that beam from your own eye first.

MPC's "handling of the dismissal of the baseball coach has been clumsy and hasn’t exactly burnished their avowal to walk in truth.” It was handled no more "clumsy" than the way North Cobb handled it 6 years ago. You get fed up with a self centered guy and want to show him the door, but you also want to be kind to a man that has 40 years in the business. You don't want to slander or embarrass him publically, you just want him gone.

I for one, think the MDJ should have done more investigative journalism into Coach Cochran's coaching and leadership tactics, than to start a story that you could not defend. I guess your one way journalism has caused you a few sleepless nights down there on Glover Street. Welcome to the REAL world.

goodformountparan
|
May 12, 2012
Mount Paran should not comment on personnel issues to the media! What they said was enough--otherwise the lawyers would be out in force and they would sue, sue, sue. As a business owner, we have had employees that were stellar sales people, but their personalities did not mesh with our company philosophy and we let them go. There are two sides to every employment issue and it is none of our business why Mount Paran let the coach go. Mount Paran is a private enterprise and can employ people who best fit their model--I'm proud that they have risen above the "winning is everything" attitude.

good observations
|
May 12, 2012
I am not a ranter, although I guess I am Anonymous, but did want to say that this is just dead on!! Very bad day for the school and the people who run it. It has resulted in a general loss of respect. Too bad.
retiredteacher07
|
May 12, 2012
I don't have a dog in this fight either and haven't been following the story but I do have an opinion. Mt. Paran is a private school and as such I would assume they are allowed to make the decisions they feel best for their school and their students and it is not the media's business. If my children were not already grown I would choose to send them to a private school where such decisions are made by those who know the needs of their schools and students. Too many decisions made by politicians with no background in education and then scrutinized by the media who also have no background in what is best for students have been a big part of the failures of our public education system. Leave Mt. Paran alone...unless you are paying for your child to attend then it is none of your business.
SouthernGal
|
May 12, 2012
Mt. Paran is a PRIVATE School...why is it the publics business how they handle personnel matters???
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides