Light rail shoved to ‘back burner’: Cobb’s roundtable reps opt for ‘premium’ bus, bus rapid transit service
by Jon Gillooly
jgilloolly@mdjonline.com
October 07, 2011 12:00 AM | 2644 views | 27 27 comments | 8 8 recommendations | email to a friend | print
ATLANTA — Cobb Commission Chairman Tim Lee and Kennesaw Mayor Mark Mathews on Thursday shoved their once-passionate plans for a light rail line to the “back burner” and won approval from the regional roundtable to focus the county’s TSPLOST revenue on “premium” bus and bus rapid transit service from Acworth to Midtown Atlanta.

Lee said the latest proposal now promotes an Acworth-Midtown bus line. Whether the rail line ever becomes a reality, instead of a widely criticized plan, will depend on two factors: the results of the county’s “Alternative Analysis” transit study due in February 2013; and whether the county receives federal dollars for the rail line. The county now intends to spend most of its TSPLOST dollars on upgrading an Acworth-Midtown bus line.

The rail line “for the moment has been put on the back burner as we seek out the results of the AA and alternative funding. If that becomes available then we’ll talk about it,” Lee said.

The project list now earmarks $689 million for Cobb’s bus/rail proposal. The draft list that the roundtable’s five-member executive committee approved in August included $865.5 million for the Cumberland-Midtown rail line.

“At the end of the day, if funding becomes available and if AA brings it to fruition, we’ll consider looking at the light rail down the line,” Lee said. “If funding doesn’t become available, or the AA doesn’t point that way, then we’ll continue with the Bus Rapid Transit as our final deliverable.”

Lee said his new proposal came after listening to citizens such as state Sen. Lindsey Tippins (R-west Cobb), who questioned the wisdom of spending $865.5 million on a rail line that wouldn’t be operational for at least a decade, when Cobb County residents are suffering from traffic congestion in “the here and now.”

The proposal addresses “the here and now in terms of road projects, the here and now in terms of transit,” Lee said. “We can get buses up and running, mind you, on a corridor that has excessive demand for our current system. This will help, I think, not only demand for our corridor of people in Cobb, but it will be a viable alternative for folks that live in Cherokee and Bartow counties that travel through our community to get to 75 or wherever they’re going.”

Faye DiMassimo, director of Cobb’s transportation department, said that $689 million earmark for “enhanced premium transit service” breaks down into $110 million for bus service from Acworth to the MARTA Arts Center Station and the remaining $579 million for whatever transit service the AA study recommends, be it bus rapid transit or light rail.

DiMassimo acknowledged that the county, in conjunction with the Georgia Regional Transit Authority, already operates bus service from Acworth.

“We’re working with GRTA as to how those express routes would transition into this service,” she said. “This would be a more coordinated, fully integrated, commuter-directed type service in that corridor than what we presently have.”

Other big ticket projects that were approved as part of the Lee/Mathews proposal include:

n $89.5 million to improve the Windy Hill Road and Cobb Parkway intersection;

n $47 million to improve the Windy Hill Road and I-75 intersection;

n $29 million to improve Lake Acworth Drive/SR 92, a regional roadway connecting Cobb Parkway with I-75.

Mathews said after the meeting that he was pleased.

“I think we’ve done a good job at dealing with what was handed to us by the legislature and picking projects that impact the region as well as projects that impact us locally in Cobb County and in the Kennesaw area as well,” Mathews said. “We’ve done exactly what we’ve been asked to do, and I’m pleased with the project list that we’ve got.”

Four of the 21 members on the roundtable voted against the Lee/Mathews proposal. They were: Fulton’s representatives, County Chairman John Eaves and Union City Mayor Ralph Moore; Rockdale County Chairman Richard Oden; and Lake City Mayor Willie Oswalt of Clayton County.

A proposal by Rockdale Commission Chairman Oden seeking to take $10 million for a bike path and another $5 million for a road-widening project from the $984 million allocated to Cobb failed, with only Oden and his fellow Rockdale representative, Conyers Mayor Randy Mills, voting in favor.

Other amendments that seek to take funding from Cobb were tabled until the next meeting on Tuesday. A final vote on all projects in the $6.14 billion list is slated for Thursday.

Mathews said while it is possible Cobb’s list could be revised at the Thursday meeting, he thinks it is unlikely.
Comments
(27)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
anonymous
|
October 10, 2011
"This 'regional' approach is a way to steal Cobb citizens' money to redistribute the same to residents of other counties."

Yes, that is the point of a "regional" approach - don't forget that no one would live in the backwards backwaters of Cobb County, GA if it wasn't for the CITY of Atlanta (and its jobs/airport/schools) nearby. Time to enter the 21st century, Cobb.

This weekend I rode my bike 15 miles through the City of Boston - all on safe, dedicated bike lanes, from my house past my work, through parks and to various T stops, to the front steps of Neiman Marcus and other stores, and along the river path to other towns. It was a beautiful ride. I just moved from Atlanta and boy do I feel sorry for you folks, you have no idea how much better it could be if you would just think regionally and about something other than 20th century highway solutions.
Alan Faircloth
|
October 08, 2011
Rick, the CCT Express buses are "express" buses and not general commuter buses. Yes, maybe adding a few routes in the time between 8am (last bus in the morning) to 3:30pm (first afternoon bus) would be helpful, but it isn't a death knell. And this is NOT what Matthews and Lee are suggesting. They aren't planning to use the money to augment what we have but start something new from scratch. WASTE OF MONEY.
Back at you
|
October 07, 2011
Natthews did sell his people out look at the family business SHAME SHAME SHAME!
homeownernextdoor
|
October 07, 2011
Did anyone see the news last night Thusday October 6th on Fox 5 or CBS 46? It was about the bus driver who got stabbed on her bus while driving in September. There was a meeting for all the Marta drivers to air their concerns over crime. And actual Marta drivers were on camera and on record saying how much crime there is on Marta. One driver mentioned she thought shields around the driver would be a good idea.

I'm not going to argue whether Lee is right or wrong, whether rail is right or wrong etc.

BUT let's put one thing to rest: There is crime on Marta. And please do not try to argue it is confined to buses and does not occur on rail.

Is there crime on CCT buses? Well yeah. But do you want to invite more of it of the magnitude that the vocal majority of Marta drivers live in fear of for their very lives?

Sell outs
|
October 07, 2011
Matthews and Lee would sell thier mothers out for the right price. Citizens beware these jokers need to go!! Mark Matthews could not make a decision if his life depended on it. Must be an election year. KENNESAW BEWARE!!!!
Gave mine up
|
October 07, 2011
@ Watcher: I do, but I pay far more in Federal, State and SPLOST taxes than I get in return in transportation savings. It is available to anyone that wants to take advantage of it.

I hate that the bus system is a money loser. The system needs more passengers. If the fares were get much higher, I'll go back to driving.

My point is - I love my car and trust me I enjoy driving it more than most people enjoy theirs - I never considered public transit until I had no place to park at my work.

Maybe instead of more ways to get there, we need less parking at the destination.
Who Decides?
|
October 07, 2011
Who decides what "Alternative" to buy with the $689 Million now undefined ?
Piney Woods Pete
|
October 07, 2011
So Cobb gets taxed about $1 Billion, and in return gets $165.5 million for road improvements and a bus route?

All so Lee, Matthews, DiMassimo and Leithead can go cosmopolitan and hang with thier Atlanta pals?

Why don't they do that on their nickel?
Watcher...
|
October 07, 2011
re: Gave Mine UP wrote on Friday, Oct 07 at 10:46 AM

I hope that "Gave Mine" appreciates the large Taxpayer subsidy that he enjoys.
RedBoard
|
October 07, 2011
Ahhhh.....the perfect move for gutless politicians: Protect the funding in any form you can, but don't commit to any particular idea or solution. That way you can look like a hero when the AA comes out or somebody else offers a really good idea...which is when you can claim to have had that idea all along.

Nice move, guys. (Politicians make me sick.)

Only one problem: What happens if we the people (Yes, we are out here.) just say NO to your TSPLOST slush fund. Then what are ya gonna do?

Better make some darn good contingency plans, boys. You're going to need them.
NotSoPC
|
October 07, 2011
I would be very interested in hearing what the Cumberland CID and the Cobb Chamber have to say about this latest debacle by Lee, Mathews and DiMassimo.

Not the public, for print comments, but the real behind the scenes reactions.

A glorified bus line. WOW!!! What a creative solutiion!!

If our political, governmental and business leaders had any guts whatsoever they would have negotiated for Atlanta to build the light rail to the River and then used Cobb's funding to complete the line to Acworth.

That may have generated some support in Cobb County. At least our dollars would have been spent locally.

And it would have comprised a project with REAL regional implications.

But NO!! These numbskulls capitulated to Kasim Reed's locally focused, non regional Beltline "trolley" project and sold Cobb County out!!!

As a result the entire TSPLOST is now in jeopardy.

Way to think regionally!!!

Rick Z
|
October 07, 2011
@ mk - IQ study

If a bridge/tunnel concept for Windy Hill at Cobb Parkway means something similar to what exists now at Delk Road and Cobb Parkway, that could be a vast improvement on both roadways. What you suggest is obviously much less costly, but I think the improvement in traffic flow would also be considerably less significant.

By the way, one of your suggestions -- synchronize traffic lights -- unfortunately loses a lot of its value when you take into account the strange behavior of too many drivers.
Rick Z
|
October 07, 2011
@ Alan Faircloth

The current bus schedules on routes 102 and 480 (and you can throw 481 into the mix as well) can hardly be considered adequate. There are 5 or 6 departures on each line from Cobb County between roughly 5:30 and 8 in the morning, and then they return from Downtown or Midtown between 3 and 5:30. At the very least, improving the bus service as part of a regional plan would allow for commuting in either direction. But ideally there should be routes added at off-peak hours, evenings and weekends. I would say, though, that before anyone votes for this our leaders need to tell us just how much bus service they're intending to provide under this proposal.
Watcher...
|
October 07, 2011
I believe that it is time for the General Assembly to REPEAL this monstrosity!
Gave Mine UP
|
October 07, 2011
Cobb citizens will give up their cars if they have no place to park them for free. I did.

Xpress gets me to work cheaper and faster than driving my own car.

GRTA (CCT) Xpress works great. They just need more starting points and destinations that will lead to more riders. Downtown is covered; try Perimeter, Buckhead, Midtown, Galleria, Lenox, Sandy Springs.
anonymous
|
October 07, 2011
-- Alan Faircloth wrote on Friday, Oct 07 at 08:40 AM » WHAT EXACTLY IS THE $110 MILLION GOING TO PROVIDE THAT IS NOT BEING PROVIDED NOW??????? --

Competition! Remember, competition helps keep costs down! ...that's what I am waiting to hear next from the brainerds Mathews. Dimassimo and Lee.

Alan Faircloth
|
October 07, 2011
IDIOTS! We already have bus service from Acworth to Arts Center (Route 102) and Downtown (Route 480). The buses already are premium buses. The schedules and number of routes are adequate. WHAT EXACTLY IS THE $110 MILLION GOING TO PROVIDE THAT IS NOT BEING PROVIDED NOW???????
mk - IQ study!!!
|
October 07, 2011
There is so much deception & pocket lining this T-Splost,... it ain't even funny!

FIRST, the Alternative Anaysis Study is an unnecessary waste. The study, headed up by Croy Engineering should be immediately canceled & that money refunded to Cobbs taxpayers. (by a fluke), IF this tax passes, then put the bus system in place FIRST, do the work to untangle the Windy Hill, 75/285 nightmare,.. then in 5 years , a study could be feasable to see what direction to go in following all these systems in place!!

Another huge waste (that I think has some self-interests involved)- is spending 90 MIllION at Cobb Parkway/Windy Hill.

I asked Bob Ott about this @ the town hall meeting Tues.,& looks like the 'plan' is a TUNNEL or a BRIDGE--over Cobb Parkway- ???????!!

WHAT in the world are they thinking??

Cobb Parkway needs updating & gets backed up along there,.. but the way to solve Cobb Parkway would be FIRST =

1-synchronize lights

2-move cones OUT of left lane on Windy Hill that block traffic flow

3-add right turn only lanes east & west on Windy Hill

4-add 'keep moving' signs to theses new lanes

5)utilize Cobb/Smyrna police at intersection for hour & 1/2 during morning & afternoon rush

These are cost effective remedies that could better use OUR tax money to fix our traffic problems.

Then you can spend the 75 Million that's left to do needed similar work ay OTHER Cobb Parkway intersections such as the horrible ramp that dead ends to Spring Road w/ no way to get into left turn lane Spring Road towards Smyrna.

I know, I'm just one of the 'little' people & have no idea what I'm talking about!!

Wrong Again
|
October 07, 2011
Buses? Mabe they are just trying to secure jobs as driver for themselves after they are voted out for being so narrow minded? They must not realize the majority of people in Cobb County will never give up their cars. That same majority is going to vote them both out of office. I hope they make driver hats for heads as big as theirs.
Still voting NO!
|
October 07, 2011
Quoting the article: "Four of the 21 members on the roundtable voted against the Lee/Mathews proposal. They were: Fulton’s representatives, County Chairman John Eaves and Union City Mayor Ralph Moore; Rockdale County Chairman Richard Oden; and Lake City Mayor Willie Oswalt of Clayton County."

The fact that the policticians on the other side of Atlanta have a voice in the spending of Cobb citizen's contributions to this proposed sales tax is enough reason to vote NO to the entire deal next year. This "regional" approach is a way to steal Cobb citizens' money to redistribute the same to residents of other counties.

*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides