Bill Dunaway: TSPLOST Rail: Will lack of courage, vision hold Cobb back again?
Oct 02, 2011 | 1989 views | 11 11 comments | 5 5 recommendations | email to a friend | print
In the 1960s, Cobb County had a county commission chairman with great vision and greater courage. Ernest Barrett had the temerity to take the county into debt to start Cobb’s water and sewer systems. Much of Cobb’s economic success in the past 40 years can be attributed to the Cobb County Water System and the Cobb Marietta Water Authority.

Unfortunately, for years, Cobb has not had the leadership and voters with the same courage and vision on transportation matters. The traffic problems of Cobb today are largely the results of the lack of leadership and decisions not made for these many years. None of us would be talking about TSPLOST projects and votes today if people had stepped forward over the past 40-plus years. For much of the time, Cobb leaders have either ignored or intentionally not made any decisions about transportation. Simply put: no vision and no courage.

During the eight years I served as Marietta’s mayor (2002-09), and during the years I served on many boards, I participated in, and/or reviewed, multiple transportation studies, plans, proposals and pipe dreams. I have been through multiple “alphabet soup” meetings: ARC, GRETA, GDOT, C of C, GMA, etc. I think I have seen the results of most, if not all, of the transit options: Bus Rapid Transit, toll lanes, HOV lanes, commuter rail, trolleys, heavy rail, light rail, more lanes, new roads, better interchanges, routes north and south and east and west — none of which are without problems.

I read with interest and agreement a Marietta Daily Journal guest commentary by Dick Hodges (Sept. 1). He was correct in so many ways. One of his comments concerns when MARTA was voted down in Cobb in the late 1960s. People can and do disagree on that issue and vote. However, if MARTA had come to Cobb, we would not have as much of the urban sprawl that we have today. Much of our denser commercial, office, and residential developments would now be concentrated along the transit lines instead of eating so much of our green space in all parts of Cobb.

No transportation decisions are going to give the “immediate gratification” that some people seem to demand. I am not supporting any transit proposal over the other, but I do know that the county needs to start now on transit solving for the future. These projects might not be completed in my lifetime, but that does not stop me from wanting us to make decisions now that will give the county the best future.

So any transit operation for the entire county would not be finished or fully funded in the next 10 years? No meaningful solutions will. Is this a reason to stick our heads in the sand like we have done for the past many years?

So transit fares would not make the system self-supporting and it would have to be taxpayer subsidized? I cannot think of any transportation in metro Atlanta that is not subsidized to some extent. The roads we use are not entirely funded by the gas tax; the sidewalks and bike trails are not paid by tolls from the people who use them; the Kennesaw Mountain Park trail that I, and so many people enjoy, is maintained by the National Park System using federal taxes; the Atlanta airport is not completely funded by user fees.

So only poor people and gangs would use public transit? I just had a daughter and her family to use transit to get to the airport. It was cheaper and faster than any alternatives. We all have business friends who use public transit in Atlanta for the same reasons. Public transit users also include people too young to drive and people too old to drive. I have many friends that will not, cannot and should not drive on I-75 to go to Atlanta to enjoy the many benefits that Atlanta offers like sports, the zoo, Olympic Park, the aquarium, etc. I will probably join that group in the years to come.

Human nature truth: many times, people and politicians find it more convenient to just be opposed to ideas without bothering to propose solutions. This TSPLOST proposal is the first viable alternative Cobb has had in years, and this opportunity will not likely occur again in the foreseeable future.

To paraphrase an old quote, “The hottest places in Hell are reserved for people who, in times of great problems, maintain their neutrality.” Our leaders and our citizens need to step forward and support solutions for our traffic problems.

I wonder whether 30 or 40 years from now the citizens of Cobb will look back on this TSPLOST proposal and thank our current leaders and voters — or whether the county, with lack of vision and courage, will still be inflicted with stagnation from the results of doing nothing.

William B. Dunaway served two terms as mayor of Marietta.
Comments
(11)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
l Knight
|
October 12, 2011
Bravo, you are right as can be. I wish some of these crazy people had the sense and the money to travel to other cities and Countries, they can't

because they are stuck on 75 between Wade Green Road and 285. SAD
NotsoPC
|
October 03, 2011
@steelekirk

And all you have to do is look at Fulton and Dekalb to see what kind of fiscal damage jumping on board with MARTA can do.

It is the Grady Hospital of transit systems!!!!

Right now Gwinnett is so far ahead of Cobb, in almost every category, including transportation it would be laughable if it weren't so depressing.
steelekirk
|
October 03, 2011
I applaud the former mayor for his thoughts. I agree that a rapid transit system of some sort is needed. One only has to look at Gwinnett county to see what is wrong with ignoring Marta and other alternatives.
Gridlock Fix
|
October 03, 2011
Mr Gridlock Booster overlooks the fact that more than 3/4 of Cobbs project money goes to that "transit alternative". $856 million is a lot of money to some of us.
chirag1
|
October 03, 2011
To solve commuter problem, we may not need a marta - but a train system will definitely help. A train from Acworth (possibly all the way to Cartersville) to Atlanta with stops in Kennesaw, Marietta, Smyrna and appropriate park and ride and feeder bus can do plenty of good for the city.

Extending Marta to Wildwood /Windy Hill office complexes in Cobb can do plenty of boost to improving traffic.
Gridlock Booster
|
October 03, 2011
The former mayor forgot to mention that there are a number of additional projects in this regional T-SPLOST which, collectively, will have much larger benefits to commuters and do more for he region's economy than this one transit project in one part of Cobb County. I don't know what the benefits and drawbacks of this particular transit alternative are or whether it is worth doing. The reality is that none of the letter writeers or bloggers do. The County is currently spending over a million $ on a study to figure that out. Until that work is completed, everyone is spouting unsupported opinion. So why not wait for the study to be completed, critically evaluate its conclusions and base a position on those conclusions? If the numbers work then do it, if the numbers don't work then try something else. Sadly, I expect a large majority of Cobb voters will vote a resounding NO on the regional TSPLOST because of reservations over a small portion of the total package. The evidence is overwhelming the the region must eventually address its transportation needs or it will become economically uncompetitive. It is easy to oppose doing something when the cost of doing something can be easily estimated. Unfortunately, most commuters recognize that there is also a cost to do nothing. We are paying that cost every single day and it is constantly rising. Of course no one has ever calculated the cost of doing nothing or compared it to doing something. So TSPLOST opponents can take comfort in knowing that it is easier to vote with them and always will be.
FuzzyLogic
|
October 03, 2011
Sorry Bill.

I have to disagree with your "let's do something even if it's wrong approach" to the transportation dilemma in Cobb County.

And as far as your contention of concentrating development around transit lines and stations is concerned all you have to do is look at our neighbor DeKalb County to see that theory does not always pan out.



Having "vision" is NOT doing the same thing again and again and expecting a different outcome. I think that is the much accepted definition of insanity.

Informed citizens in Cobb look at the current light rail proposal in the context of the other recent and less than successful experiences around the country and ask why we would expect a different result.

We are not the Big Apple, we are not Chicago, we are not San Fran and we never will be. Why would we want to be like those cities?

We need a different transit solution that works for us.

One that is affordable to build, operate and maintain. Not one that breaks the bank and generates huge perpetual subsidies.

Jammer51
|
October 03, 2011
Have to agree that there has not been a great deal of vision and leadership on transportation. I will have to disagree in that there are no transportation decisions that would give "immediate gratification" to many citizens. One that comes to mind is sequencing the traffic signals on US41 (Cobb Parkway). The actual programming is probably a relatively simple process. What is needed is some cooperation between Cobb County, Smyrna, Marietta, Kennesaw, and Acworth elected officials.
DonAustell
|
November 25, 2011
Richmond Va, has timed state routes and people know drive the speed limit you will make the lights. Case and point to make the lights on Austell Rd. Speed 55mph or 27mph works very well for 12 years? See the problem either way! I have been riding 'MARTA' since 1961 and CCT since conception. You can not compare the two and not just a matter of scale. And how is Acworth more financially feasible than the cancelled Austell Route #35? Utilize what you have before creating a long term questionable project. I worked on rail and bus in Atlanta you still use the bus to ride the rail and ride the bus until rail is completed!
C.H.
|
October 03, 2011
Bravo, sir! You are right on the money with your comments - I hope for the future of Cobb County that alternatives to road expansion (such as rail) are prominent on the county's TSPLOST list and approved through the vote next year. Any leaders who promote nothing but automobile transit solutions are doing a great disservice to this community with their shortsightedness!
Say not to TSPLOST
|
October 03, 2011
So I guess the rumors of you wanting to run for Cobb County Commission Chairman or Mayor again are grossly wrong.

To believe Marta would actually cause businesses to locate along certain routes ignores the obvious. Why did Fulton County not develop such a pattern with their vote for MARTA years ago?

It might not be such a bad thing you stepped down from public office, after all.

p.s. I do applaud your daughter's ability to get to the airport in record time, however my own experience was much different as is true of everyone I know.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides