Zoning board orders fowl to fly the coop
by Kim Isaza
newseditor@mdjonline.com
September 15, 2011 12:22 AM | 4614 views | 36 36 comments | 15 15 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Joseph Pond and his 10-year-old daughter, Madeline, hold a couple of their chickens which they raise in the backyard of their northeast Cobb home. By a unanimous vote, the five-member Board of Zoning Appeals on Wednesday gave Pond and his family 45 days to get rid of the 11 pet chickens he’s keeping on his half-acre lot on Plantation Drive, near the intersection of Johnson Ferry and Shallowford Roads. <br> Photo by Laura Moon
view slideshow (2 images)
NORTHEAST COBB — In the age-old question of which came first, the chicken or the egg, Cobb County’s answer is: the ordinance.

By a unanimous vote, the five-member Board of Zoning Appeals on Wednesday gave Joseph Pond and his family 45 days to get rid of the 11 pet chickens he’s keeping on his half-acre lot on Plantation Drive, near the intersection of Johnson Ferry and Shallowford Roads.

A county ordinance in place since 1972 requires at least two acres for keeping livestock such as chickens. Pond bought his chickens in April — and told the board Wednesday that he believed at the time they were legal under a state law. He was cited by code enforcement on June 29, after which he requested a zoning variance.

Pond’s supporters in the audience on Wednesday included his wife and two children, plus a few more people who support backyard chickens.

Carole Kell, whose backyard abuts the Ponds’ property, spoke against allowing the animals to remain. Jill Flamm, president of the East Cobb Civic Association, also spoke against it.

Pond was the only person speaking in favor of allowing the chickens.

“My hens are not in any way nuisance animals. They stay in their coop almost all of the time. … The laws, as clear as they are, are not black and white. They are shades of gray. I just want to provide safe, fresh eggs to my family and keep my family’s pets,” he told the board members.

After the vote, Madeline Pond, 10, burst into tears. Her father, Joseph, said he’s not sure what he will do with the chickens now, and may retain legal counsel.

“I have to look into what my options are,” he said.

Kell believes Pond has no one to blame but himself.

“He chose to break the law. He knew there was an ordinance when he bought the chickens,” she said. “We teach our children — you know, I was a schoolteacher and principal forever — we teach our children to obey the law. To me, he is demonstrating to his children it’s OK if you don’t like the law, you just go ahead and then you try to get forgiveness.

“I disagree with the fact that he put the chickens on his property. I would have bought two acres somewhere if I wanted chickens,” she said.

David Poteet, the zoning appeals board member who represents the area, said he believes that allowing the chickens on such a small lot “would nullify the code.”

“To approve this variance request is overstepping our bounds,” Poteet said.

The decision can be appealed in Superior Court, according to the county’s zoning manager.
Comments
(36)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Joseph Pond
|
September 21, 2011
This is an e-mail I received regarding the number the dogs or cats that one can have in Cobb County:



We have no county ordinance pertaining to pet limits. However one must be able to provide adequate care for all pets. All cities within the county do have pet limits.

Don Bruce | Operations Manager

Cobb County Animal Control
property Rights
|
September 19, 2011
to all the anti-chicken/pro "law" comments - maybe you should spend some time reading "Civil Disobedience" and some info on chickens before you judge the Ponds (and all the other chicken keepers in unincorporated Cobb county). Like I said before - it is just an ordinance - an arbitrary local rule imposed by the Commissioners in the 70's (and most likely for snob reasons). Chickens are pets! - they just happen to lay eggs and are good for the micro-environment (the person's yard.)
J. Dotson
|
September 18, 2011
I live next door to the Pond's, and i must say that I NEVER heard those chickens. They are quiet creatures that are producing healthy, hormone-free eggs for their owners. The Pond's were extremely excited to finally have finished their coop, and now the county is requiring them to evacuate it. I absolutely disagree with it. The neighbors behind us are unreasonable, the coop never caused any trouble... and saying that Mr. Pond is "okay-ing" law breaking is a stretch. His morals are much stronger than to support blatant law breakage. I'm sorry to his kids Madeline and Sam. This family did not deserve this treatment.
sad in W. Cobb
|
September 17, 2011
To: ridiculous...

if you are going to make a counterpoint, at least make it plausible and include some facts. Cherokee Co. passed an approval for chickens last year. They found no facts to support a decrease in property values.
To Jack Wilson
|
September 17, 2011
You want people to LEASE cats? Isn't it cheaper to just buy a cat and build equity?

;-)
toooooooo ridiculous
|
September 17, 2011
Wait ... you would BATHE in a hot tub??? The only way you'd save on your water bill is if you didn't change the water afterwards.

Ewwww...
jack wilson
|
September 16, 2011
The ordinance says it OK to raise rabbits. Maybe he should raise rabbits in his pen. Talk about flies and stink. Gee. I had a neighbor who had rabbits and some would get loose and starting digging holes. And they multiple like...well...rabbits. Yet, People all over the county have exotic pets. Have you been to the Pet Marts lately? All the different cages for ever animal: snakes, lizards, parrots, gerbils, rats, ferrets, all kinds of birds. A chicken is just a bird. Then you have the exotic chickens that don't even look like chickens (seramas and silkies) selling for up to $500 a piece at shows. If the ordinance hasn't been updated since 1971 then it definitely needs an overhaul. And with all the world going Green, Cobb needs to step into 2011. I vote 5 animals or 50 lbs of "pets", whichever is LESS, dogs and cats excluded with a max of 2 dogs and 2 cats. Do the cat people know that according to the Cobb ordinance that cats are suppose to be on lease when outside?
ridiculous...
|
September 16, 2011
I can't stand this government overreach! All I want is a hot tub in my front yard, but this ancient ordinance clearly says I can't have one in my front yard! Having a hot tub in my front yard will ease my skyrocketing water bill (since I can bathe in it), and relieves my stress after a long day. It also gives me a chance to meet my neighbors! I think I'll just go ahead and plop one in my front yard, and to heck with the ordinance. If the chicken guy can do what he wants then I'll do what I want too.
sad in W. Cobb
|
September 16, 2011
So exactly what is the difference between 3 dogs in my backyard vs. 3 hens? For the naysayers,I'm looking for substantiated facts please, not speculation like Ms. Kell seems to go by.
Brass
|
September 16, 2011
Why hasn't anyone reported on the fact that this is a blatant VIOLATION of STATE LAW!!!

State law DECLARES that no county or municipality has the right to create laws regarding animal husbandry practices in the state of GA.

The Cobb County ordinance from the 70s is in violation of state law.
kaliko
|
September 16, 2011
This is very stupid, and it is pet discrimination. Dogs and cats are allowed and so should chickens. Dogs are nastier, bark constantly, and are more annoying. Get rid of dogs too.
anonymous
|
September 16, 2011
Pit bulls that threaten neighbors = OK.

Chickens that lay eggs = NOT OK.
anonymous
|
September 16, 2011
You folks that oppose backyard chickens do know that hens don't crow, right? Have you ever seen a chicken outside of KFC or Chik-Fil-A? Hello? Anyone? The odor of a few properly cared for chickens is no worse than that of dogs.

At a time when we as Americans should be trying to be more resourceful and independent, when we should be trying to be more *American*, it seems the board and a vocal, uninformed, controlling minority are preoccupied with witholding simple property rights that cities and communities with muchdenser population than ours freely allow.  
anonymous
|
September 15, 2011
Really, Mr. Pond, maybe you *should* move. Who wants to live around shallow ilk who have nothing better to do than worry about their (crumbling) home values (endemic of a much larger problem in this country) and the (invented) threat of avian flu (a hysterical response, if ever, and contrary to CDC research). Their lousy behavior as neighbors contributes more to the perception that Cobb is an undesirable place to live much more than your hens ever would.
Brass Balls
|
September 15, 2011
Sorry No Balls but their is a county rule about how many dogs can be at one home . I beleave 3 it the max though many do go over that number.
anonymous
|
September 15, 2011
I live on an acre in unincorporated Cobb. I had a neighbor in the woods behind my house firing his gun. Fearing for children that might be playing in the woods, I called the police. The cop that arrived explained, at length, that you can fire a gun, even hunt in your backyard in Cobb county, as long as you are not shooting at a person or another property. Net sum: you can hunt in your backyard in Cobb - even use an assault rifle if you wish - just don't try to keep a chicken back there. 

But I guess that's "okay" for property values.

Maybe if you give guns to your chickens...
Chicken Terror
|
September 15, 2011
Come on now. The things that contribute to real estate values are things like the public schools and the geographic location. The schools in east Cobb are good for Georgia...but they're still in Georgia - something akin to being the best of the worst. Not exactly a big draw. As for location, well, just look at the parking lot that is 75 north at rush hour. It's no wonder people are gentrifying Atlanta. A friend of mine paid a premium to get a house in Decatur. It's smaller than my Cobb house, and older. But it's a lot closer to things to do...and he can even (legally) keep hens on his tiny lot. The neighbors don't even resort to theatrics over it!
doggiemom
|
September 15, 2011
I love my chickens. They not only provide eggs, but eat ticks and other bugs. They will also take care of mice and some snakes. They give me joy after a stressful day. I wanted chickens at first for fresh eggs for my family and friends, but found they give me joy. They are working the ground for a future shade garden. They are natural tillers and fertilizers. Surprisingly they don't create any horrible oders. In the short time I have had them, they have already softened the ground for my future garden. I plan on putting falling leaves in the pen with them this fall to help cultivate the ground. Shame on Ms. Krell for complaining. It seems to me that she is old enough to remember hard times. Maybe she's one of those protected southern bells who didn't realize hard times. I have also had some meat chickens, which are now in my freezer to feed my family. Some may not like that, but we have to survive hard times. I hope you continue to fight Mr. Pond and family.
w in Marietta
|
September 15, 2011
OFF WITH THEIR HEADS!!!
anonymous
|
September 15, 2011
I bet the MULE PROCURER could settle this with a little help from his Lawyers.

Jack and Jill
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides