Don McKee: Cobb voters need to take part in TSPLOST project choices
by Don McKee
Columnist
August 22, 2011 12:00 AM | 1212 views | 3 3 comments | 7 7 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Don McKee
Don McKee
slideshow
Let's have a round of applause for state Rep. Ed Setzler of Acworth, chairman of the Cobb legislative delegation. He has zeroed in on the glaring problems with the proposed TSPLOST priority to construct a mile of light rail linking Cumberland Mall to an Atlanta MARTA station.

Setzler wants the legislators to review the TSPLOST project list at a meeting today, a very good idea since the list was put together by a regional committee that included Cobb Commission Chairman Tim Lee and Kennesaw Mayor Mark Matthews. Judging from the results, there was no input from the people at large.

The latest cost estimate for this rail line is $857 million for Cobb's portion - which gobbles up most of the total $1.1 billion for projects in the county. It comes out to $4,000 a year for each household in Cobb County, as Setzler points out.

"Four thousand dollars just to construct it, and it services Cumberland Mall?" Setzler said. "Five percent of the people in Cobb County might be able to use that as a transit tool, but every household's going to pay $4,000 just to build it?"

Then there's the little item of operating costs, pegged at nearly $10 million a year. All of this to move maybe 5 percent of the people in Cobb to the Arts Center MARTA station, not enough to justify the cost of the project, Setzler says. So he wants voters to understand what they will be voting on in next year's referendum.

His idea is a good one, first meeting with the legislative delegation and then he might set up some public forums or town hall meetings across the county. People need an impartial source of information in addition to the "educational" material being put out by the Cobb Chamber of Commerce and the looming pro-TSPLOST campaign by the Cumberland Mall and Town Center improvement districts to sell the new 1 percent sales tax to the voters.

It would take 15 years to plan and construct the rail line. How much congestion relief could be achieved within a few years by strategically planned highway widening and improvement projects? And it would take another 15 years to extend the line to Acworth, per the proposal.

The major beneficiaries of the rail line would be developers, retailers and people living in the Cumberland Mall-Galleria area and the people that might commute to the station for a ride to Atlanta and connections to somewhere else.

It's possible to change the TSPLOST project list for Cobb since the deadline for the final list is Oct. 13. Rep. Setzler says the TSPLOST concept "created a process whereby the region could vote down the project list or accept the project list or change the project list for a reason, so that good projects and only good projects would ever be put on the ballot."

It's up to Cobb voters to get involved in this process and come up with a better list of projects.

Comments
(3)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Soldout
|
August 22, 2011
If you take a look at the proposed TSPLOST project list it is pretty obvious to most informed voters in Cobb County that they are being sold out by Lee, Mathews, the Cobb Chamber and the CID's.

The project list needs to be changed or voted down.

Unfortunately, as pointed out in Mr McKee's article, if it is passed regionwide with the current project list intact, we are stuck with the projects on that list whether we like it or not. That includes the unaccounted for ongoing operating costs ($10M/year forever) of a rail line that only goes to Cumberland Mall.
railroadman
|
August 22, 2011
Duty....The use of CSX trackage looks like the simple answer, but it is exactly the opposite, as operationally, commuter rail service here would be a nightmare. Additionally, due to massive track and signalling changes necessary to have a commuter/freight mix, costs will become huge very quickly. This is not just a matter of adding a few Amtrak-type cars and a locomotive every 20 minutes. We're talking hundreds of millions of dollars in bridges, additional track, real estate acquisition, environmental studies, signalling, and stations...plus new rolling stock.

Railroading is far more complex than meets the eye. Been there, done that.

Happily, there is a much better solution available. You'll hear about it very soon, and you'll like it.
Duty
|
August 22, 2011
We don't know enough about light rail versus heavy rail. We are being pushed to make a decision before the information on which to base a good decision is even available. Wouldn't it be better to use existing tracks that go through Smyrna, Marietta and up in the north points of the county as the major artery and then put light rail from the heavy rail line into places like Cumberland and Town Center?

I live in East Cobb. Put light rail around Cumberland and I will still go to the North Springs Station to get to/from Atlanta.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides