KSU's new race, gender department under scrutiny
by Jon Gillooly
jgillooly@mdjonline.com
March 29, 2011 12:00 AM | 7278 views | 52 52 comments | 21 21 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Kennesaw Hall rests on the campus at Kennesaw State University. KSU Interim Provost Dr. Ken Harmon will determine whether to greenlight a new department within KSU’s College of Humanities and Social Sciences called The Department of Cultural and Regional Studies.<br>Staff/Todd Hull
Kennesaw Hall rests on the campus at Kennesaw State University. KSU Interim Provost Dr. Ken Harmon will determine whether to greenlight a new department within KSU’s College of Humanities and Social Sciences called The Department of Cultural and Regional Studies.
Staff/Todd Hull
slideshow
KENNESAW - The creation of a new department at Kennesaw State University that would house various racial, gender and environmental programs has come under fire from one longtime KSU professor who sees it as a hive for radical indoctrination.

In the next month or so, KSU Interim Provost Dr. Ken Harmon will determine whether to greenlight a new department within KSU's College of Humanities and Social Sciences called The Department of Cultural and Regional Studies. That department would have seven academic programs under its banner: African and African Diaspora Studies, Gender and Women's Studies, Environmental Studies, Asian Studies, Latin American Studies, Peace Studies and American Studies.

"This is being put together by a bunch of activists," said Dr. Melvyn Fein, a tenured professor of sociology at KSU. "These folks do not have degrees in what they pretend to teach. To call it neo-Marxist is being very modest. These are activists who are going to use this to try and indoctrinate instead of teach."

But Arlethia Perry-Johnson, KSU's vice president for external affairs, said the seven programs that would make up the new department already exist at KSU, and the proposal is to simply consolidate them into one department. Bringing together professors who teach similar subject matter creates synergies and aides in communication, she said.

For example, at present, part of the Environmental Studies program is housed in KSU's College of Humanities and part of it is housed in KSU's College of Science and Mathematics, because students take courses offered by both colleges to shape their degree, based on whether their focus is more policy or science oriented, she said.

Perry-Johnson said the proposal for the new department has been created by the coordinators of each of the seven programs in question.

They are: Dr. Jesse J. Benjamin, associate professor of sociology, (African and African Diaspora Studies); Dr. Susan M. Rouse, professor of philosophy, (American Studies); Dr. May H. Gao, associate professor of communication, (Asian Studies); Dr. Mark W. Patterson, associate professor of geography, (Environmental Studies); Dr. R. Ugena Whitlock, associate professor of education and gender studies, (Gender and Women's Studies); Dr. Ernesto Silva, assistant professor of Spanish, (Latin American Studies); and Thomas M. Pynn, assistant professor of philosophy, (peace studies).

Pynn recently introduced KSU President Dan Papp at an event where he described "The Communist Manifesto" by Karl Marx as "a call to conscience."

Although the Journal requested comment from any one of the seven professors listed above, Perry-Johnson said it would be inappropriate for them to comment since the proposal was at the provost level.

Fein accused the professors in question of trying to push through subject matter in the proposed new department that they have failed to get approved in existing departments. Once the new department is created, Fein said it would intrude on courses taught in other departments, by claiming to have a stake in them.

"It's going to be detrimental to the reputation of the university as a serious school," Fein said.

There's a reason why programs such as women's studies are on the decline nationwide, he said.

"Departments are closing around the country because students have learned, among other things, that if they want to get a job they shouldn't major in them. If your major is in women's studies, any employer who hires you is crazy. You're hiring a lawsuit, for heaven's sake," Fein said.

Among the subjects offered under the Gender and Women's Studies program, according to KSU's website, are Gender in Popular Culture, Transnational Feminisms, Black Feminisms, and "Queer Theory & Sexuality." The latter describes itself as "an interdisciplinary course that considers the global emergence and significance of theories and practices that 1) refute and destabilize the notion of an essential, normative sexuality and gender, and 2) suggest that sexuality is fluid and varied and is constructed by social, political, and economic factors."

Perry-Johnson said the new department is not expected to incur any additional cost to KSU since no additional faculty are expected to be hired to run it. Moreover, she said the proposal has already gone through two sets of votes by those faculty who would be involved. Faculty from the departments impacted voted 33-4 in January to authorize the initiation of discussing such a proposal.

A New York University consultant, Dr. Mary Louise Pratt, came to KSU in January to give advice for the program. She was paid $3,309 for her work.

Faculty then voted, 49-6 in favor of creating the program in a referendum from March 21 to 23.

Perry-Johnson also said Fein should have followed the chain of command in airing his concerns about the proposal.

"If his goal is to confer about his concerns and his opposition, the process exists for him to be able to do that in a manner that would have impact, rather than using the newspaper as a bully pulpit, when in fact his colleagues are here and open and accessible to him," Perry-Johnson said.

But Fein said he has made use of the chain of command, asking to speak with Papp, at which time he was referred to Interim Provost Ken Harmon.

Harmon said he looks forward to meeting with Fein and hearing his concerns. Once Harmon makes his recommendation, he will take it to Papp, who did not return calls for this article.
Comments
(52)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Demo tonic
|
April 02, 2011
"US Colleges Eliminate Gender And Ethnic Studies Departments To Steer Students Into Getting Skills That Will Land A Job After College; Restaurants Panic At Loss Of Servers"

Gender and Ethnic Studies Departments are a joke we don't need to subsidize. We can get more bang for our buck elsewhere.
yah yah
|
April 01, 2011
I'm glad Dr Fein spoke his mind. This is what college campuses should be all about. Open debate where people are not afraid to voice their opinion.

By the way, I've always wondered what a women's studies, African studies, or peace studies major can add to a company. What special skillsets do they bring to a technology or manufacturing company?
Christy Rogers
|
March 31, 2011
This is the most absurd thing I've ever heard. So apparently KSU now allows teachers to just teach whatever they want without being educated in it? Yeah, I believe THAT. Also, I'm a 20 year old woman, and you think a department is going to INDOCTRINATE me? Most classes are taken for 1 hr 15 min twice a week. If a 18 year old person can be "indoctrinated" in less than 3 hours a week, there are much bigger problems going on.

And where is this guys evidence? Has he looked up all of the professor's degrees? Has he talked to every person who agreed that the department was a good idea? He has NO proof.

An argument without proof is no argument.
Keep it real
|
March 31, 2011
Thank you Dr. Fein! We appreciate your courage in exercising your right to free speech while warning the public of what is happening. We also fully "appreciate" the specious arguments, intolerance, and namecalling of those attempting to respond.

I urge KSU to keep striving for rigorous standards and relevant content, and therefore to decline establishing this phoney-baloney "department" that will prove to be nothing more than a hotbed for leftist activism and grievance-mongering. Leave that to the other colleges now being held hostage in supporting such parasitic departments. Thanks to those sorry examples, we can do better here.

Just keep hiring excellent history teachers, literature and language teachers, philosophy, business and science and math teachers who know how to teach, and are too professional and ethical to indoctrinate students in accordance with any Marxist or other political agenda.

While you're at it, please ensure that your School of Education is rigorous, effective, and reality-based as well. My daughter wants to become a teacher, and Hillsdale College is rather far away.

We rubes in the community are quixotically determined to have excellence in academia in our midst--not another dreary, politically-correct leftist token department.
Shef Rogers
|
March 30, 2011
These comments remind me of two things:

1. Leaving GA was the smartest thing I ever did.

2. Sherman was far too gentle.
Schnee
|
March 30, 2011
Dr. Fein says the process was not followed, but indeed it was. KSU has a shared governance structure and the proposal would not have reached the administrative level without having gone through the proper chain of command. In the meantime, Dr. Fein continues to try to force another decision to go his way so he resorts to using the media to air his case. It appears to me that D. Fein prefers tyranny to the democratic process.

His remarks about the program and the faculty at KSU is there to indoctrinate students makes the presumption that the students are too stupid to know that they are being indoctrinated. That is not my experience with KSU students--they are mostly bright people who would push back at any attempts to manipulate them.
melanie j
|
March 30, 2011
I didn't judge taxpayers--I simply stated they have no right to influence curriculum--especially concerning subjects about which they are woefully uneducated. The fact that Marxism = bad and teaching a book (which is taught around the world) is treason is embarrassing.

Academic freedom has nothing to do with shutting down classes or silencing voices--which is what Mel Fein is trying to do. Having taught and worked at KSU, if you had the theory and academics to back up your "side", there is not a professor I know who would not respect your view (even if they disagree). That isn't the point of this article though--it's about Mel Fein stomping his feet because he's "unhappy".
OMIPS
|
March 30, 2011
@ Fairness needed -

Please learn to read blogs. I did not call Fein a whiner. The blogger commenting on my earlier comment called him a whiner.

A Taxpayer
|
March 30, 2011
Melanie J, who are you to judge the taxpayers? I'm probably twice your age, I have two college degrees, and I'm a student at KSU working on my M.A.

Stop throwing around the words "yellow journalism" and "red scare tactics" in hopes the fear factor will shut people up. Patriots, taxpayers and capitalists have as much right to First Amendment protection as America-bashers and communists do. Academic freedom is about open debate, not trying to shut down one side so that only one view prevails. And in my own experience as a student at KSU, a lot of professors still need to be reminded of this. Kudos to Dr. Fein.
fairness needed
|
March 30, 2011
@OMIPS--

Please reread the column. The point is not that his side did not win out but that due process was not followed. Also there seems to be a lack of open discussion on campus. As best I can tell, Dr. Fein is a true hero. To call him a whiner is shameful.
On the Sidelines
|
March 30, 2011
@OMIPS - Imagine if every government employee could complain publicly about every decision he or she disagreed with? Going to the press every time you don't get the answer you like is a very slippery slope:

--I don't think the professor gave me the right grade (whine).

--I don't like my parking spot (whine).

--I didn't get a "fair" review from my boss (whine).

I'll bet the process for creating this new department has been going on for some time, as nothing happens quickly in a university. The article says Fein already had a chance to weigh in. That Fein is whining now is just that, whining because things didn't go the way he wanted.
Melanie J
|
March 30, 2011
I am ashamed (and embarrassed) that the Marietta Daily Journal has allowed itself to seep to such levels of promoting anti-intellectual discourse and Red Scare-tactics in an attempt to gain readers. This article is insulting to KSU, to academia, and mostly to those professors you list in your article. Their work should not be undermined by those who simply are threatened by its existence.

Mel Fein is a joke and so are the very "tax payers" who believe they have "right" to dictate curriculum, yet have no degree.
geezus
|
March 30, 2011
before you complain about these programs, it would be smart to first, enroll in the classes and research the curriculum.

Dr. Fein: Feed your head.

Throw the bums out: You should totally let you kid decide for his/herself where he/she wants to attend college. I hear your kid screaming "leave me alone mom/dad. stop smothering me"

OMIPS: you talk like a conservative...and it's clear that you don't know what you are talking about.

I'm Hungry
|
March 30, 2011
I am a student of the Gender-Women's Studies program and I THOROUGHLY ENJOY THOSE CLASSES!

I take pride in my education. Dr. Fein obviously doesn't want me to.

KSU veteran
|
March 29, 2011
Embarrassed4You:

Since you apparently speak from some knowledge and experience about these courses that have been around "for some time," I would love to have you--or some spokesperson from the seven centers--deal with the following questions:

1. What percentage of graduates from these courses are gainfully employed, except in hothouse imitative departments in our "progressive" colleges and universities?

2. How did these courses pass the Board of Regents approval when the rule has been for ages no unnecessary and expensive duplication of services?

3. What openness and diversity of thought exists in these departments as revealed through faculty publications and presentations, topics at conferences, and student publications and presentations?

4. What diversity of public presentations occurs?

5. Why was the vote kept from the public and campus at large.

I am somewhat familiar with these issues, having been at KSU for some time but thankfully in a legitimate department. I await someone to counter my answers. 1. I know of few if any graduates from these departments who went on the gainful employment outside a similar and narrow academic field. 2. I know that the discussion and vote was hurried and done without public or campus publicity. I don't imagine for a minute that KSU received Regents approval for the new department. 3. There is very very little diversity in faculty, presentation, and student output. Specifically the Hispanic movie series has been without exception left of center and pro-immigration, and American Studies conventions have to my knowledge NO presentation that could be considered right of center.

If I am wrong, please cite chapter and verse. And please do not call those with whom you disagree "uneducated, close-minded, and sheltered." That is not very tolerant, is it?
Samuel Adams
|
March 29, 2011
For those of you who believe Dr. Fein "called the paper" you must not realize that he's been a columnist or a guest columnist at the paper for months, writing informative, educated opinion pieces not related to KSU at all.

So he's technically an insider in both organizations, which happens all the time on the left of the political spectrum.

As far as allowing the students "decide the fate of the program" (Shane) I can tell you right now that these students (and you might be one) are naive as can be, swimming through the muck of left wing political correctness likely through their entire education. My own experience with a women's studies course at UGA in 1980 was: wake up, often times hung over, hit 7am swim class, barely make it, sopping wet across campus to women's studies, try not to laugh at the professor's ridiculous directions to find passages in the Bible that show Christians treated women like dirt. That is the extend of the class and I still have the Bible where she made us highlight the "horrendous" passages. I think back now and realize I had NO idea the purpose of this class back then. It was a time waster elective. But now I realize the propaganda, both anti-Christian and anti-male. I've wondered many times since 9-11 if this professor is still teaching and whether she ever, EVER mentions how women are treated under Sharia law and Islam, or whether she sticks to Christian bashing still. But back then? It was something to be endured and something to waste money on. I was clueless...
Really?
|
March 29, 2011
Why is it that anyone who wants to study or understand the history of non-white male groups immediately labeled leftist and radical? To deny students at the 3rd largest public university in ga the opportunity to take these classes only furthers the general perception that those in the south are racist, biased, and unwilling to accepts ALL people. These histories exist. Why be upset that people want to learn? Denying this doesn't change the fact that people can and will see the world differently. It saddens me that people could be so narrow-minded and insular.
Enough already!
|
March 29, 2011
The only thing Mel Fein has succeeded in doing is to prove yet again that he is a close minded, intolerant bully who believes he is right and everyone who doesn't agree with his warped views is wrong. Those who have worked with him for years and know him well consider him irrelevant, so he has discovered a megaphone, called the MDJ, as a tool to bully and intimidate his colleagues. And the MDJ has gladly obliged. Bravo! No one on this newspaper seem to know, or have forgotten, what the role of a university is. Or maybe they are just determined to remain in the stone age and keep everyone else there with them. Maybe KSU should be renamed the University of North Cobb and then they can hire all of you on here to come run it. Ignorance is bliss!
Whatazoo
|
March 29, 2011
We likes our journalism yaller here in Mayretta!
nomoremel
|
March 29, 2011
One angry professor does not speak for the university. Mel Fein is wholly out of touch. Hiring a Women's Studies major is hiring a lawsuit? Really. You have some evidence for that Dr. Fein? The new department is neo-Marxist? Evidence? Course descriptions are posted on line--are these professors currently teaching neo-Marxist, American bashing courses? Are their courses any different from those taught at UGA or Emory? Evidence? Can you elucidate the "activism" of these professors? In which objectionable activities do they engage? Evidence?

I believe the quota on stirring up nonsense to suit your own personal agenda is one per 30 days. Dr. Fein has now had two. Enough is enough.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides