Let PSC oversee EMC
February 23, 2011 12:00 AM | 1126 views | 7 7 comments | 5 5 recommendations | email to a friend | print
DEAR EDITOR:

I read with interest an MDJ story by reporter Brandon Wilson regarding the ongoing legal battles of Cobb EMC and was appalled to discover that Cobb EMC is now counter-suing the original plaintiffs.

As a Cobb EMC customer myself for the past 11 years, I've become increasingly concerned with the management and lack of public oversight for the company.

I would like to point out that the Rural Electrification Act, providing the basis for the formation of EMCs, is now 75 years old. What was rural back then are now the suburbs throughout most of the United States.

Perhaps a simple solution would be to convert Cobb EMC from an EMC over to an investor-owned electric utility, and let the Georgia Public Service Commission acquire jurisdiction over its operations. Cobb EMC effectively acts as an investor-owned utility today, except in Cobb's case it's getting all the tax benefits of an EMC.

George M. Ellenburg
Marietta
Comments
(7)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
anonymous
|
February 25, 2011
Exactly, there is more to power than just turning on a light switch. Cobb EMC has served my house very well and is cheaper than my neighbor down the road on GA Power. Brown is paid very well, just like all other CEO's. He has done things differently than other EMC's, therefore he is under scrutiny. By doing things unlike other power companies, he has kept the cost down for the customer.

Since when do we decide how other companies are run? I am a stock holder in Home Depot, ADP, BoA and other companies; do you think they will let me tell them how to run their businesses? If they let everybody decide how to do it, I can guarantee that my stock prices would not be doing too well.

Just because you do not approve of Dwight Brown and how he has run Cobb EMC does not mean that he isn't doing everything he can to provide cheap reliable power for his customers.

Take Back Cobb EMC
|
February 24, 2011
Since we haven't had an annual meeting in years, there's very little oversight right now. Members are struggling to find out what the board of directors are voting on until after it passes.

Whether it's by legislation forcing EMCs to follow open-records and open-meetings laws or being regulated by the PSC, we need it!
Cobb EMC Supporter
|
February 24, 2011
Gotti? Madoff? Laughable! Opening the meetings to members so they can make decisions on how the EMC is run? Name one business that happens in? There isn't one. I own stock in Apple and Microsoft, don't think I can walk in and dictate how they run their business. I don't think I want Joe truck driver, Jane IT and Jack elementary school teacher making decisions on electric supply, infrastructure renewal, etc. You elect directors to govern, If you are fed up show up to vote the next time. According to plantiff Bo Pounds and other EMC managers, Dwight Brown is brilliant in the electrical industry. So yeah let's kick him out, because we think turning on the power is as easy as flipping a light switch.
Anothe EMC Hostage
|
February 23, 2011
EMC Hostage is absolutely correct. Many times people who are breaking the law are at the same time doing charitable work. That sort of deflects the attention away from them.

To Be Careful-If Dwight Brown "boldly changed how EMCs were able to purchase power" thus lowering EMCs rates, then just think how much lower our rates would be if Brown had not used his position as CEO to enrich his bank account and those of his family members, Board members and friends.

EMC Hostage
|
February 23, 2011
I disagree. Cobb EMC needs to be regulated by the membership, not the PSC. However, the membership needs to be given the tools to self regulate. Open meetings would be a start. HB 316 will do a lot to provide the needed information to the members so they can make an informed decision about the operations of the EMC. Most importantly EMC money should not be allowed to be used to financially support the EMC management's preferred candidates.

"Be careful": Just because Dwight Brown did something good for the EMC over a decade ago doesn’t mean that he is any less of a criminal for his actions over the last decade. There are a lot of criminals in prison who did something good for society during their lifetime. That didn't mean that those acts of goodness gave them a pass for their criminal actions. John Gotti was loved in his New York neighborhood for his charitable actions. That didn't make him less of a criminal.

Pat H
|
February 23, 2011
An article in the AJC stated that Stan Wise, the PSC chairman, was a close personal friend of Dwight Brown.

I am also a member of Cobb EMC, and therefore an owner. I do not agree with suing Thompson and Pounds, in fact, I am grateful to them for exposing the theft of our money.

It is time to remove Brown and his board before they do any more harm. Brown needs to join Madorf in his new digs.
Be careful
|
February 23, 2011
Before you jump to this conclusion you may want to review the PSC's most recent rate case approval for GP. I beleive you will discover that on a annual basis Cobb EMC's residential rates are lower.

In fact most of the 42 EMCs in Georgia have lower rates than GP.

If you want to take the time to go to the AJC's website and read Monday's article by Margeret Newkirk you will find that the reason EMC's rates are lower is because, you guessed it, the man you cannot stand Dwight Brown boldly changed how EMC's were able to purchase power. The management that you do not like is doing the best thing to give you, the customer, the most reliable power at the best possible price.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides