Voter ID law debate rages, but Ga. driver’s license requirement worse
by Don McKee
July 28, 2013 10:48 PM | 2766 views | 3 3 comments | 42 42 recommendations | email to a friend | print
The battle between states and the federal government over voter identification requirements and the still-alive Voting Rights Act is heating up again.

Texas is now in the sights of Attorney General Eric Holder, who wants that state subjected to federal court approval of a newly enacted voter ID law and redistricting maps — even though the U.S. Supreme Court effectively killed federal pre-clearance under Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act.

But Holder is going after Texas under Section 3, undisturbed by the court ruling. Section 3 allows courts to take jurisdiction and decide if a state has passed discriminatory voting laws and is thus subject to being brought under judicial oversight.

North Carolina may be another target since the state legislature last week passed a tough new law covering voting rights. Alabama, which gave rise to the Supreme Court decision on the Voting Rights Act, also may face a Holder attack on that state’s new photo ID law.

Georgia’s voter ID law, among the toughest in the country, has been partly defanged by a Supreme Court ruling last month that struck down a proof of citizenship requirement in an Arizona case. But the ruling applies only to people registering for federal elections, a small percentage of Georgia voters. Look for the 2014 General Assembly to come up with a fix for the law.

Georgia is among a dozen states with strict photo voter ID laws, and more than a dozen other states are working on similar legislation. Almost 20 states don’t require photo ID, but that number is shrinking.

As of now, only Georgia, Tennessee, Kansas and Indiana have “strict photo” ID requirements, according to the National Council of State Legislatures. Twenty states have no voter ID law. They include two of the largest states, New York and California. Another big state, Pennsylvania, is in the throes of a legal challenge to its new voter ID law.

The strict voter ID laws are pushed by Republicans who talk about integrity of the voting process and the danger of fraud, while Democrats want to let everybody vote basically without any ID other than a name, address and signature.

What’s worse than the voter ID law in Georgia is the driver’s license law. A new applicant — or now even a long-married person simply seeking a license renewal — must show a birth certificate plus a marriage certificate if the name on the birth certificate has changed because of marriage, plus a Social Security number, plus at least two proofs of residence, such as a bank statement and a utility bill. It’s basically ridiculous, forcing many long-married, veteran Georgia drivers trying to renew their licenses to go to the trouble and expense of obtaining a copy of their birth and marriage certificates — even though all the information on their expiring license hasn’t changed in 20 years.

All these requirements are supposed to keep illegal immigrants from getting driver’s licenses. But this goes far beyond a reasonable identification process. If it’s not overkill, then please tell me what is?
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Scott C
July 23, 2014
I just spent 1.5 hours in the DMV as they would not give me a license with the following, my old license, a passport, my birth certificate, and water bill. As I still did not have my social security id. I do not get paystubs, everything is via a computer. But the bottom line is you have to have two documents that have your address on it AND your social security and it has to be printed on an acceptable document. This is ridiculous. The only reason for this level of administrative roadblock is to keep minority voters from the polls. If your poor and don't have a car, or old and poor, and don't have a computer, and no longer have a CERTIFIED copy of the your birth certificate thre is a greater chance that you will just say this is to much trouble. It keeps them away from voting.
Peachtree Corners
July 30, 2013
You proved who you were when you got your voter registration card. The only reason for these new laws is to try and keep the poor and minorities from being able to vote because of some lame republican idea that those people vote for democrats more often.

One more reason to be ashamed of the state that I find myself living in.

Jane Smith
July 29, 2013
This is an example of the BIG GOVERNMENT those stupid Republicans claim to derive. It's not big government when they make sure your papers are in order.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides