Scalia says no 'falling out' with Roberts
by Jesse J. Holland, Associated Press
July 19, 2012 02:55 PM | 1345 views | 2 2 comments | 7 7 recommendations | email to a friend | print
In this Oct. 18, 2011, file photo U.S. Supreme Court justice Antonin Scalia smiles during a college address in Chicago.  (AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast, File)
In this Oct. 18, 2011, file photo U.S. Supreme Court justice Antonin Scalia smiles during a college address in Chicago. (AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast, File)
slideshow

WASHINGTON (AP) — Justice Antonin Scalia said he hasn't had a "falling out" with Chief Justice John Roberts over the Supreme Court's landmark 5-4 decision validating much of President Barack Obama's health care overhaul.

In an interview that aired Wednesday on CNN's "Piers Morgan Tonight," the justice said that, despite reports that he and Roberts had clashed, there is not a personal feud going on between the court's two leading conservatives.

"There are clashes on legal questions but not personally," Scalia said of the court.

The Supreme Court earlier this month upheld much of Obama's signature health care law, with Roberts siding with the court's liberals to uphold the hotly debated core requirement that nearly every American have health insurance. The decision allowed the law to go forward with its aim of covering more than 30 million uninsured Americans.

Since then, Roberts has been the focus of derision from some of the nation's leading conservatives, and there have been reports of fractures in the relationships on the court's conservative wing, of which Roberts and Scalia are members.

"No, I haven't had a falling out with Justice Roberts," Scalia said, when asked about a purported clash between him and Roberts.

"Loud words exchanged, slamming of doors?" prompted Morgan.

"No, no, nothing like that," said Scalia, who noted that he was out of the country for most of the criticism of Roberts.

Scalia also emphasized "the court is not at all a political institution" and said he believed "not a single one" of his Supreme Court colleagues considers politics when making decisions at the court.

"I don't think any of my colleagues on any cases vote the way they do for political reasons," he said. "They vote the way they do because they have their own judicial philosophy."

Scalia also defended the court's 2-year-old decision in Citizens United to give corporate and labor union interests the right to spend freely to advocate for or against candidates for state and local offices.

"I think Thomas Jefferson would have said the more speech, the better," said Scalia, when asked about so-called super PAC spending on national elections. "That's what the First Amendment is all about. So long as the people know where the speech is coming from."

Scalia also said in the interview that the case that brings about the "most waves of disagreement" is still the ruling that decided the 2000 presidential election between George W. Bush and Al Gore. But the justice said his normal answer to people who ask about Bush v. Gore is to "get over it."

Scalia said it was Gore who decided to bring the courts into the battle. "The only question in Bush v. Gore was whether the presidency would be decided by the Florida Supreme Court or the United States Supreme Court," Scalia said. "It was the only question and it's not a hard one."

In fact, Bush's legal team was the first to go to court, asking a federal judge to block hand recounts in several Florida counties. Several days later, Gore's lawyers were in a state court seeking to force Florida Secretary of State Katherine Harris to accept updated county vote totals.

Scalia said he had no regrets about the court's decision.

"No regrets at all," the justice said. "Especially because it's clear that the thing would have ended up the same way anyway. The press did extensive research into what would have happened if (what) Al Gore wanted done had been done, county by county, and he would have lost anyway."

The justice's recollection of the outcome of the vote-by-vote review sponsored by eight news organizations, including The Associated Press, was more definitive than the AP reported when the review was released in November 2001.

"Completing two partial recounts that Gore unsuccessfully pursued in court showed Bush maintaining a lead ranging between 225 and 493 votes.

"Under any standard that tabulated all disputed votes statewide, however, Gore erased Bush's advantage and emerged with a tiny lead that ranged from 42 to 171 votes.

"Strikingly, all these outcomes were closer than even the narrow 537 votes of Bush's official victory. With numbers that tiny, experts said it would be impossible to interpret the survey results as definitive," the AP reported.

Scalia is beginning a book tour promoting his new book, "Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts" with co-author Bryan A. Garner.

___

Associated Press writer Mark Sherman contributed to this sto

 

Comments
(2)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
A Bradford
|
July 21, 2012
Additionally, although you seem intent to subtly contradict Scalia's assertions, you also fail to mention that Gore's team quashed untold numbers of military absentee ballots, plus the Florida panhandle still had polls open when the networks called Florida for Gore, thus affecting voting in a highly Republican region.
A Bradford
|
July 21, 2012
You are incorrect about who started the court proceedings. It was Gore who started it when he went to court to prevent Bush from being certified as the winner so he could do recounts in the counties he selected. See Palm Beach County Canvassing Board v. Harris. You needed to do your research before suggesting Scalia was wrong.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides