A pilgrimage for ‘little Mary’
by Leo Hohmann
lhohmann@mdjonline.com
April 28, 2013 12:30 AM | 9299 views | 9 9 comments | 16 16 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Attorney Robert Kilgo drove from South Carolina on Saturday to see the grave of Mary Phagan, the 13-old-girl who was murdered 100 years ago at an Atlanta pencil factory. Above: Kilgo holds his favorite book about the famous murder mystery while visiting the Marietta City Cemetery.<br>Staff/Leo Hohmann
Attorney Robert Kilgo drove from South Carolina on Saturday to see the grave of Mary Phagan, the 13-old-girl who was murdered 100 years ago at an Atlanta pencil factory. Above: Kilgo holds his favorite book about the famous murder mystery while visiting the Marietta City Cemetery.
Staff/Leo Hohmann
slideshow
Visitors have laid an assortment of mementos at Phagan’s grave.<br>Staff/Leo Hohmann
Visitors have laid an assortment of mementos at Phagan’s grave.
Staff/Leo Hohmann
slideshow
Ed Field, who was active in the Ku Klux Klan in Cobb County several decades ago, lays a bouquet of flowers at the grave site of Mary Phagan on Saturday morning.<br>Staff/Leo Hohmann
Ed Field, who was active in the Ku Klux Klan in Cobb County several decades ago, lays a bouquet of flowers at the grave site of Mary Phagan on Saturday morning.
Staff/Leo Hohmann
slideshow
A historic marker in the cemetery gives background information on Phagan’s life.<br>Staff/Leo Hohmann
A historic marker in the cemetery gives background information on Phagan’s life.
Staff/Leo Hohmann
slideshow
Mary Phagan
Mary Phagan
slideshow
MARIETTA — One by one they came on foot, a steady stream of pilgrims, from shortly after dawn and continuing until the clouds closed in, threatening to send showers washing over the mildew-stained gravestones at Marietta City Cemetery.

They came for different reasons, though.

In the span of an hour there came two young high school students working on a history assignment, a criminal defense attorney and his wife from South Carolina, a university student from Kennesaw, and two men in their 80s who boasted of their past membership in the Ku Klux Klan.

But they all shared the same destination — the tombstone of Mary Phagan.

It’s the most visited grave site in Marietta, according old-timers in the city.

And on this particular day, the number of living souls making their way through the historic cemetery was even more than usual.

It was the 100th anniversary of “little Mary’s” death.

A captivating story

Mary, at age 13, was brutally murdered at the National Pencil Factory in Atlanta on April 26, 1913. She’d come that day to claim her last wages after being told some days earlier that she had been laid off from her job at the mill.

Leo Frank, a Jewish man who was the manager of the factory, was tried and convicted of the killing, but when the governor commuted his sentence from death to life in prison, a group of Marietta men kidnapped Frank from the state prison in Milledgeville, brought him back to Marietta and hanged him from a tree off of Roswell Street.

One of the pilgrims Saturday was criminal defense attorney Robert Kilgo Jr., who drove more than 200 miles from Darlington, S.C. He said he’s been fascinated with the story of Mary Phagan and her accused killer since he was a student studying political science at Emory University in the late 1960s.

“Some history just never fades away,” said Kilgo. “I had always heard about it when I was at Emory, the history of it. I’ve read every book ever written about it.”

Besides the books, the historic whodunit has inspired a movie and a PBS documentary featuring commentary by Marietta’s own former Gov. Roy Barnes and retired Marietta Daily Journal newsman Bill Kinney.

One of the best books on the topic, according to Barnes and Kilgo, is “And the Dead Shall Rise,” penned in 2003 by former Atlanta Journal-Constitution reporter Steve Oney.

“We’ve been talking for months about making the trip here to Marietta,” said Sue Kilgo, wife of Robert Kilgo.

Before arriving at the city cemetery, they stopped to visit the site of the pencil factory in Atlanta.

“The people (who live) over there, they don’t like to talk about it,” Robert Kilgo said. “If you ask them about it they’ll respond in whispered tones.”

Some say Frank was framed and they condemn the group that kidnapped him as a band of vigilantes. Emotions on both sides of the case ran so high that it led to the founding in 1913 of the Jewish Anti-Defamation League in New York. It also led to the rebirth of the Klan in the South.

Frank was pardoned posthumously in 1986.

A Klansman speaks his mind

Ed Field, an 80-year-old Marietta resident who came to the Phagan grave site with flowers Saturday morning, said the Klan was strong in Marietta right up through the 1980s. He ought to know. He was a member.

“I was the Grand Cyclops of the Ku Klux Klan and I led a parade through the Square in 1980,” Field said.

Field said Frank got what he deserved.

“Guilty then, guilty now,” he said as he looked at the historic plaque marking the Phagan burial site. “Nothing has changed!”

Field, a Korean War veteran who grew up in Atlanta and has lived in Marietta for 40 years, came Saturday to the cemetery with his friend, Clelland Jordan, 89.

Field laid his bouquet at the foot of the marble tomb, then bowed his head in silent prayer as Jordan stood a short distance away.

But if Frank really did kill Phagan, what was his motive?

“Rape,” Field said. “He brutally raped her and then strangled her.”

Another suspect was the night watchman at the factory. But Field said it couldn’t have been him.

“There were notes left by Mary’s body,” Field said. “The watchman was a negro. What semi-literate negro would have killed her, then sat down and wrote letters?”

And how, then, would Field explain the sympathy that has emerged over the years for Frank?

“Look. Money is power. And the Jews have the money,” he said. “They came down here from New York and made movies and wrote stories.”

Jordan, a World War II veteran, agreed with his friend’s assessment that Frank was guilty as charged.

“They called them a lynch mob that hung him up but they had themselves deputized,” Jordan said. “It wasn’t no lynch mob.”

Former governor weighs in

Barnes, a Marietta native who was Georgia’s governor from 1999 to 2003, said it was no typical lynch mob.

“The thing is, when Leo Frank was lynched this was not a bunch of ruffians, this was the best in the community, the leaders of the community, that is unusual in and of itself,” Barnes said.

The case remains controversial to this day, 100 years later.

“You still have people that will argue over the guilt or innocence of Leo Frank. But, one of the things I think everyone can agree on is, he didn’t receive a fair trial. There’s no way you can read that record, I’ve looked at the evidence, and from the evidence I’ve looked at, I don’t believe he received a fair trial.”

Barnes, 65, said he started reading up on the case when he was in law school.

Then when he got to talking with Kinney, his interest only grew.

“Kinney was an expert on that case,” Barnes said. “Steve Oney’s work, it’s just a great book. And Bill (Kinney) was one of two primary sources for that book.”

Barnes said he’s not sure what the leaders of the town were thinking when they plotted to kidnap and kill a man who was already in prison.

“Over the years I’ve studied it, the greatest question I’ve had was what got into sane, upstanding people that made them commit such a horrible act?” Barnes said. “(Then Gov.) John Slaton only commuted his sentence from death to life in prison. He was still incarcerated. They took him out of the state penitentiary and killed him. All of that is the reason this case still holds such interest after 100 years.”

Barnes said the original group of Klansmen focused on terrorizing African-Americans. After the killing of Mary Phagan, they expanded their reach.

“This case had a great deal to do with the resurgence of the Ku Klux Klan. Originally they were anti-black, but when it came back it was very much anti-Jewish and anti-Catholic,” Barnes said. “They held rallies out at Stone Mountain. They had a big rally out there, and it was kind of the rebirth of the Klan. Even when I was a child they would have rallies out there every year, burn crosses and everything.

“I grew up here in the ’40s and ’50s and ’60s and there was a lot of racial feeling and it didn’t really subside until about 20 years ago,” Barnes said.

As for Fields, Barnes said he remembers him well.

“I remember that (Klan rally on the Square),” he said. “I was practicing law on the Square at that time.”

He was surprised to learn that Fields, at the age of 80, had made a graveyard pilgrimage to Phagan’s tombstone Saturday.

“I thought all of that was gone,” he said. “People never change, and that’s especially true in racial matters, and with the case of Leo Frank and Mary Phagan. It’s the damndest thing. You could sit and talk about it for hours.”
Comments
(9)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Richard Mamches
|
May 14, 2013
As we mark the centennial of the murder of Mary Phagan and the tragic, controversial Leo Frank case, let us also remember that the murder victim's sister-in-law, Mary Richards Phagan outspokenly denounced the injustice done to Leo Frank and declared her belief he was innocent--in an exclusive interview with Bill Carbine in the Marietta Daily Journal, published on December 23, 1983. When the Georgia parole board initially denied a pardon to Leo Frank the day before, Ms. Richards Phagan was also quoted by the Associated Press as saying: "I am surprised. What's the matter with those people? There must be a lot of those people still around who are so cruel."

Thankfully, the state of Georgia ultimately got right with history and pardoned Leo Frank in 1986.
Leo Hohmann
|
April 30, 2013
I think Bobby Case has nailed it when he poses the simple question, "Was?" To think that racism, or any other form of evil for that matter, has somehow vanished from the earth just because most folks are reluctant to discuss it in our politically correct modern society, is in my opinion naive. If you honestly think we are free of racism in today's world, then this story would make no sense to you. My objective in doing this story was simple: to show that a gruesome crime committed 100 years ago stoked the fires of both racism and a push-back against racism, and that maybe, just maybe, that's why this crime still resonates with people on both sides of the issue today.
Keri M
|
April 30, 2013
Am I the only one bothered by the fact that this article granted so much coverage to the anti-Semitic rantings of a KKK leader?
in acworth
|
April 29, 2013
I can't believe you print the ravings of a former

klansman...This is 2013 and nobody cares what this racist has to say...Shame on you
MeToo22222
|
April 28, 2013
There was a lot of racial hatred in the south. The only way it subsided was for that generation to die off and the world moved on. Same with the old buzzard that is so proud of his Klan past. He'll be gone soon and we won't have to put up with his kind of thinking again. There is no cure or redemption for that kind of moron.
Southern Patriot
|
April 29, 2013
The South continues to have "a lot of racial hatred", today it's frequently called "reverse discrimination". Despite what you may think of his political affiliations, Ed Field is a very intelligent man and warned us many years ago about the impending destruction of European culture here and in Europe. If you follow contemporary reports from around the country and Europe you'll realize he was right. The Boston Marathon bombing is a prime example.
Bobby Case
|
April 29, 2013
Was? Racism and contempt for the disadvantaged and vulnerable is alive and well down here.
anonymous
|
April 28, 2013
Figures the new editor would want to dredge this up again. Been told. I have no connection, but can't we find something else to put on the front page on the day of Taste of Marietta? Let's bring ourselves out of the past and update.
f8bcrusader
|
April 28, 2013
I'm glad to see this story. It may be the past but people learn from the past. I have heard many different stories about this and read many different accounts and only rarely do they all correspond. I knew some old gentlemen that had small parts in the hanging. More or less on the fringe of things and heard them recount the happenings of that night several times. Personally, I like these sort of articles. Like to see more of them.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, and spam will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides