Attorney: Teen au pair unjustly arrested, jailed
by Katy Ruth Camp
krcamp@mdjonline.com
September 01, 2010 12:00 AM | 8756 views | 77 77 comments | 19 19 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Attorney Rebecca Keaton, left, goes through documents as east Cobb resident Kimberly Euston watches and her au pair, Brazilian national Julia Gottschalk, points out her Brazil-issued international driver’s license and translation document. Gottschalk was arrested by Cobb Police after allegedly running a red light and being accused by the arresting officer of driving without a valid license. <br>Photo by Mike Jacoby
Attorney Rebecca Keaton, left, goes through documents as east Cobb resident Kimberly Euston watches and her au pair, Brazilian national Julia Gottschalk, points out her Brazil-issued international driver’s license and translation document. Gottschalk was arrested by Cobb Police after allegedly running a red light and being accused by the arresting officer of driving without a valid license.
Photo by Mike Jacoby
slideshow
EAST COBB - Julia Gottschalk, a 19-year-old Brazilian who has been in Cobb since March on a year-long au pair exchange program, was driving Greg and Kimberly Euston's three children to after-school activities in east Cobb on Aug. 18 when she was pulled over for allegedly running a red light. The end result, however, was more than a ticket. Gottschalk was arrested and spent seven hours in the county jail on charges that her international driver's license was invalid.

According to Georgia Department of Driver's Services' website, "Georgia recognizes valid driver licenses issued to and held by residents of other countries as long as the "Out Of Country" license is valid (not expired). Generally, you may drive in Georgia for up to one year on a valid foreign or International license. You do not need to apply for a Georgia license unless you become a resident of Georgia."

Gottschalk, at the time of the traffic stop, produced a valid international driver's licenses, which she said she was required to obtain as part of the au pair exchange program and as a condition to travel in the U.S. She also provided her valid Brazilian driver's license. However, Cobb Police spokesman Sgt. Dana Pierce said Georgia law regarding international drivers states that Gottschalk needed a valid Georgia driver's license.

"Let's bank on Georgia law, which is what an officer banks on, not on a website," Pierce said in reference to what is stated on the state driver's services' website.

Pierce said Tuesday that members of the department will research the matter further today; however, according to how officials interpret the law, he said Gottschalk was violating Georgia code, as she was neither a full-time student, nor did she obtain a Georgia driver's license prior to being in the state for more than 30 days. But state law 40-5-20 states that only a resident of Georgia must obtain a Georgia driver's license within 30 days.

Gottschalk's defense attorney, Rebecca Keaton, who was hired by the Eustons, said Gottschalk is not, nor is she seeking to become, a Georgia resident, and that both state law and the Georgia DDS's handbook are clear in that Gottschalk could drive on valid, international and Brazilian driver's licenses up to a year. Gottschalk is due in Cobb County Judge Maria Golick's court on Sept. 30.

Arresting a person for the violation and taking him or her to jail to post bond is up to the officer's discretion and is based on whether or not the officer believes the suspect made a serious violation and/or would likely appear in court, Pierce said.

"I can't dispute what the officer did and why he did what he did, but I would say running a red light with three children in the back seat is pretty serious violation. That, coupled with her lack of paperwork and a valid Georgia license, he felt he needed to physically make that arrest," Pierce said.

When Gottschalk handed Smith her international driver's license along with her official Brazilian driver's license, Gottschalk said he told her it was not valid.

"I said no, but it is. He said it was not, but he went back to his car to verify it and I sat in the car with the kids for about seven minutes while he was in his car. When he came back, he told me to step out of the car. I gave him the car keys, but he threw them back into the car. I only had one window down, and he put his face to the glass to see the children inside," Gottschalk said.

Once she walked to Smith's patrol car, Gottschalk said she heard the kids crying and screaming in the car, parked along Johnson Ferry Road near Hampton Farms Drive in Marietta. Gottschalk said she was told to turn around because she was being arrested for driving without a valid driver's license. She was then handcuffed and put into the back of the Smith's car.

"I thought it was a joke. I thought there must be cameras somewhere because I had not done anything wrong," Gottschalk said.

Gottschalk and Kimberly Euston said the kids were in the "sweltering hot car" for more than 30 minutes before Greg Euston was able to arrive and drive the kids home, though the police report said there was only 16 minutes between the time of the stop and the arrival of Greg Euston. It also states that the car was parked in the shade.

"If I left my kids in my car shopping or something in the heat for that long, I'd be arrested, and rightfully so," Kimberly Euston said. "They could have put the keys in the ignition and driven the car, jumped out of the car into the road, who knows what could have happened. You're taking racial profiling to the next level when you're putting children's lives in danger."

Gottschalk also said the officer was "taunting" her as she cried in the back seat of his car on their way to Cobb Jail.

"I told him my handcuffs were hurting me, but when I asked him to loosen them, he said no. I was just so upset that the children saw me in handcuffs and were left in the car for so long with no air, and he said, 'this is life experience' and 'you must love it here because there are a lot of Brazilians here' and 'you can't run to Mama every time something happens,'" Gottschalk said.

"We did a precinct investigation based on a complaint issued by Kimberly Euston. The au pair has not issued a complaint at all, and our officers have been in contact with Euston," Pierce said.

Keaton said, "This happens a lot in Cobb County, and is an abuse of 287(g), which the officers use as an excuse to arrest people they think may be illegal immigrants. This officer obviously doesn't know the law, and should. She never should have been arrested."

The Marietta attorney added that officials from the Brazilian consulate have written a letter to Georgia's attorney general, complaining about the arrest and stating that this is "a constant problem."

Gottschalk, who was released about 7 hours after her arrest on a $600 bond posted by Greg Euston, said she successfully obtained a Georgia driver's license Tuesday.

"I came here because I wanted to experience the American culture," Gottschalk said, who added that she wants to go back to school to become a journalist. "Everything up until now has been wonderful. But that was not the experience I was looking for in this land of freedom and justice."
Comments
(77)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Roberto Delmanto Jr
|
September 17, 2010
Roberto Delmanto Junior5:44 am

I am a Brazilian lawyer who lives in Sao Paulo. I often travel to the US for vacation with my kids, expending a lot of money and helping US economy. There are a huge number of US citizens here in Brazil too, who really loves our Country too, running huge US business here. They all are treated with kindness and all respect, as it should be, for sure. I have a relative who lives in Georgia as a director of a multinational company and a VERY SIMILAR CASE happened to my brother who also is a lawyer. He rented a car at the airport with the Brazilian drivers license and was stopped on the road by a police officer during the night. There was no traffic violation at all. The officer asked for his papers and he showed the Brazilian licence explaining he went to visit his sister in law for a week. The officer did not accept his license and ordered him to call his sister in law to pick up the car and take him home OR HE WOULD BE CUFFED AND ARRESTED! Imagine if he did not have a cell phone with him ! She came to help him with her husband and a 1 year baby who was sleeping at midnight very scarred ! It WAS A NON SENSE ! Roberto Delmanto Junior, attorney at law
Crissyl
|
September 03, 2010
@openyureyes

First of all, what you propose is not at all a 'resolution to the problem' - you're complaining about the way things have already been done which does nothing to help the situation at hand.

Secondly, in case you are unaware, few families are able to survive on a single parent income these days. What would you suggest parents do with their children while they are working in order to afford food, clothes and a house over their heads? The au pair program is a very cost effective option for childcare. They are not being 'raised' by the au pair, they are being taken care of and taught by the au pair. Do you think children that attend school are raised by their teachers? An au pair has a set number of hours a week and the parents still have plenty of time with their children. An au pair becomes a part of the family, more so than any daycare teachers or even regular nannies.

Thirdly, why is being taken care of by someone from a different culture a bad thing? In comparison to other countries, Americans are very insular and it can do a world of good for a child to grow up realising that there are many different cultures out there.
operyureyes
|
September 03, 2010
Hey el paso

have you ever heard of a non-compact state??? this is a group of states that,in a not shell, do not have to honor some of the other states drivers histories, suspensions and other misdamenor violations. in other words, to hold the driver accountable for their actions, they have to post a cash bond because the state that they hold a license will not suspend a license for traffic charges, furthermore , it is the officers decision to take the violator to the closest jail to post a cash bond if he or she believes the violator would possibly miss court, move to another state or MOVE TO ANOTHER COUNTRY that does not reciprocate to the laws of the state that the violation was committed in.

That being said, it was the office discretion to take her to jail to post a cash bond. Bond is paid to assure that the peson either pays the fine or returns to court. I'm not a lawyer like you say you are EL PASO, but I think that it was not a violation of the law to make her post bond for running a red light and endangering those chilren.

But if the mother was driving that would tell me that she was where she was suppose to be....with her kids, raising them like you should and be with them ,nurturing them as everyone should with their OWN kids. Raise you own kids and you don't have issues like this to contend with. God forbid that those children get hurt in an accident. where is mom when they call for her....God bless
trustissuesinwestc
|
September 03, 2010
Dear Darth Bunny,

I wish Andy of Mayberry would have been there too! It would have taken him 5 minutes to figure out what was going on! And saved everyone involved a lot of time, trouble and money!!

Darth Bunny
|
September 03, 2010
Poor "Trustissuesincobb".

I wish Andy of Mayberry had been there and he could have devoted a whole episode to prove there was no probable cause to arrest you.

Jail is not supposed to be a nice place. But I am glad you were not familiar with bonding procedures. It would be great if fewer people were.
el paso
|
September 03, 2010
The officer and his supervisor should have known the lady was licensed based on the documents she presented. Either they did not know the law or ignored the law. An officer can either issue a ticket or arrest someone for driving with out a license. Since the police are exercising such poor judgment, the policy should be to ticket. If the policeman in this case had broken her nose and eye socket, some of you would be saying she deserved that also.
trustissuesinwcobb
|
September 03, 2010
To Allthisdrivel:

You just don't get it...and I didn't either until I was handcuffed, thrown in the bag of a police car..then paddy wagon... and transported to jail, treated and talked to like a criminal, finger printed, my glamour shot taken and sat in the jail for 8 hours...on a full moon Saturday night until my husband posted bail for me..which by the way...we had no clue on how to do. And for what??...for being in the wrong place at the wrong time and a CCPO not taking the time to investigate!!

So, am I whining??~~~heck yes~~I'm still whining. I have been traumatized and will never, ever forget this experience. Getting arrested is serious business!!!

I just hope that one day you or someone you love and care about get to experience one of CCPD's finest. Then maybe you will get it!
Darth Bunny
|
September 02, 2010
Apparently no one in Brazil has ever been arrested for running a red light and having an invalid license.

Those with valid licenses get to sign a citation and drive away because if they don't show up for Court their licenses get suspended.

Those without a valid license have to post a bond to assure they will show up for Court.

The cop did the proper thing. Sorry your spoiled brats got hot. It would have been a lot worse if they got in a wreck with your unlicensed au pair.
west cobb driver
|
September 02, 2010
We need to make sure that Mr. Houser, the new Police Commissioner is reading these important comments so he realizes how the citizens of Cobb County really feel about the Police. He wrote a convincing article in the MDJ about how great the Police were and now he needs to hear the truth!!

I would like to get his email to forward this link if any one knows it.
Good Grief
|
September 02, 2010
It makes me sick how everyone is always so quickly judges the actions of the police. Why is it that no one seems to be able to accept responsibility for their actions. The officer was not driving the vehicle. The parents of these children should be grateful she was pulled over. The next light she decided to run might have killed the children.

If an accident had occured, the police would be blamed for that too. Because somehow she was on the road without a proper license.

Stop the police bashing. So funny, when they are out eforcing traffic laws everyone hates it but who do they call when they are afraid? They call those men and women who will gladly risk their life for someone else.

So for God's sake get off the back of the police!!! The officer was just doing his job.
openyureyes
|
September 02, 2010
OK lets start with a logical resolution to this problem. the Eustons should be ashamed to allow someone that

1)is not a family member.

2) a person that they only have known for a short time.

3)is from a different culture and raise her children.

Forget the traffic stop, forget the arrest and forget that this girl is probally driving without proper documents. The point is that, this EAST COBB family feels like they can get their fifteen minutes of fame over someone that, (if you were in her country,) wouldn't give you the time of day. The girl is here for a free ride on an americans dollar.

Here is an idea.....WHY DON'T YOU RAISE YOUR OWN KIDS!!!!!!

You gave birth to them and you want an unknown person raise them. or are we too busy playing tennis and golf. Oh I don't see the children in the picture. where are they????at a babysitter? RAISE YOUR OWN KIDS. no wonder so many east cobb kids are on drugs and alcohol. the Cleavers do not live in east cobb, but i do and i see these kids are loved with material things. cars,money and even drugs...wake up....
Hope4ChangeInOctober
|
September 02, 2010
To CommonSenseLacking: The Eustons are hardworking successful US taxpayers. In fact, they probably support your welfare or 99 weeks of unemployment benefits. To leave three small children in a hot car was an egregious mistake on the part of the police.
HopeForChangeInOct
|
September 02, 2010
To CommonSenseLacking: The Eustons are successful hardworking tax payers who are probably funding your welfare payments or 99 weeks of unemployment. Leaving young children unattended in a hot car is unacceptable to most but maybe not to you.
Being Honest
|
September 02, 2010
To Allthisdrive!

What do you know besides English, you moron? And THAT makes us better than you. I don't care if I'm writing correctly or not. It's just a comment! I just wanted to give my opinion and respecting it is the least you could do. Be the better person and accept it! And give the girl a break! There are three sides of every story: one side, the other, and the truth. You were not there to know exactly what happened. None of us were. It's not up to you to judge her.

And there's nothing wrong with the name choice. I wasn't doing anything besides being honest. Leave it be. Go find something else to do and I'll do the same.
Ksaw
|
September 02, 2010
To drs0501ccpdretired: Thank you for your service, I wish some of the current/younger officers had your attitude. Frankly, if someone is breaking into my home I'll call the police to clean up the mess afterwards and write their reports - reaching for my phone wouldn't be my first reaction in that situation.
el paso
|
September 02, 2010
The Cobb police should quit making arrests for no drivers license, unless others offenses such as DUI are involved. This would deter the "officers" who make false arrests or show such poor judgment in arresting people for minor offenses. This is why Homeland Security found so many abuses present in the 287(g) program. Officers arrest people for little or no reason and take them to jail, where often the accused is deported before trial. I believe the Justice Dept. will be involved unless Cobb drastically changes the current mode of operation.
Allthisdrivel
|
September 02, 2010
I had no idea there were so many whining babies in this county. I'm sorry that a few of you have had bad experiences with local law enforcement, but that's a far cry from the police state that some of you would have us believe exists. If you don't want trouble with the law, don't give the police a reason to stop you. It really is that simple. People have gotten so used to routinely violating rarely-enforced traffic laws that when the law finally does get enforced they act like their rights are being violated. And do any of you honestly believe that this officer knowingly placed those kids in danger in a "sweltering" car? If you said "yes" then you are a moron or a liar. To "Trustissue", you complain that the investigating officer only looked at one side of the story, yet you expect us to do the same thing?. Oh, and to "BeingHonest" (ironic choice of name by the way)that's some chip ya got on that shoulder, and try proofreading next time, or learn english.
AngelaGA
|
September 02, 2010
Kimberly Euston, Thank you so much for sharing what must have been a horrific experience for you, your children, and your au pair. Your voice will help so many who are suffering due to the 287g program in Cobb. This is just another example of how 287g is legalizing racial profiling instead of making our communities any safer.
trustissuesinwcobb
|
September 02, 2010
What can I say? I am not surprised one bit that this incident happened. I, unfortunately, have had a very bad experience with the CCPD. Long story but the bottom line is...the police officer failed to investigate...meaning he never spoke to the other party involved..which was me! Took one side of a story and issued a warrant for my arrest. After six months of pure hell, I went to court & the judge found me "not guilty!" Imagine that! If only the police officer would have taken the time to INVESTIGATE , this would have never happened!

I wrote letters to the people who needed to know about my first experience with the CCPD! This "handling of my case investigation" has still not been resolved yet. Why..because there has been so many changes at Headquarters....just read the paper and listen to the news. Also, I have come to the conclusion that they just don't care! That's why I have experienced this "moral negligence" from this so called "decorated police officer!"

He can..he will..and he did!! At least that's how I see it working in West Cobb! Thank goodness our justice system has a brain and can see through this kind of nonsense that takes up so much of our legal systems time and tax payers dollars!

I know how devastated this young girl feels. It is seven months down the road and I am still trying to recover emotionally, physically and finacially from this nightmare! I still am in shock that I was denied the right to fill out a police report or even share my side of the story. The saying "you are innoncent until proven guilty" is highly overrated!

Hopefully, one day very soon I can move my family out of Cobb. I have MAJOR trust issues and have absolutely NO faith in my local "decorated police officers!"
CobbGuy
|
September 02, 2010
Some of the Cobb Police Dept employees are truly the best. The earn our respect every day. Others, sadly, are incompetent. This is stupidity in action if GA law allows this woman to drive legally and the officer did not know the law. The three kids just make it look worse for the cop. The Cobb Police MUST do better in hiring and training or this will happen again and again. (And hopefully the paper will print the law so we all can see it.)
*All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will be rejected.